Tennessee Supreme Court Clarifies Ruling On Motions To Reduce Sentences

Monday, December 10, 2018

The Tennessee Supreme Court Monday held that a defendant who pleads guilty is not required to present proof of post-sentencing changed circumstances to prevail on a motion for reduction of sentence under Rule 35 of the Tennessee Rules of Criminal Procedure, if the guilty plea did not include an agreement as to a specific sentence. 

The case before the Court began in 2015, when the defendant, Jonathan David Patterson, broke into several cars and a building in Putnam County, stealing two vehicles and also stealing property from the vehicles and the building.  Law enforcement apprehended Patterson with some of the stolen property in his possession and arrested him.  He cooperated with the authorities, and this enabled them to recover much of the stolen property and restore it to the victims. Patterson was charged with 42 offenses and eventually pled guilty to 20 offenses without any agreement as to the sentences that would be imposed on the pleas.  A guilty plea that does not include an agreement is known as an “open plea” and requires the trial court to impose sentence. 

At Patterson’s sentencing hearing, the trial court received evidence of his previous felony convictions and parole violations and heard argument from the State that Patterson’s extensive criminal history warranted a lengthy sentence.  Patterson spoke at the hearing, apologized for his crimes, and explained that he had been struggling with drug addiction for many years when these crimes were committed.  Patterson’s sister also testified and corroborated his testimony.  Both Patterson and his sister asked for leniency in sentencing. Patterson emphasized that he had not committed any violent crimes, had cooperated with law enforcement, and had pleaded guilty without an agreement as to sentencing.   The trial court agreed with the State’s argument and imposed an aggregate 31-year sentence.

Patterson then filed a Rule 35 motion asking the trial judge to reduce his sentence.  The trial court granted the Rule 35 motion and reduced Patterson’s aggregate sentence to 19 years.

When the State appealed, the Court of Criminal Appeals held that a defendant cannot prevail on a Rule 35 motion unless the defendant offers proof of post-sentencing changed circumstances justifying a reduction.  Because the defendant failed to satisfy this showing, the Court of Criminal Appeals reversed the trial court’s decision on the Rule 35 motion and reinstated the original 31-year sentence.

The Tennessee Supreme Court granted Patterson permission to appeal and held that Rule 35 provides only one limit on a trial court’s discretion to reduce a sentence—the reduction must be in the interests of justice.  The Supreme Court acknowledged that its own prior decisions had not been clear about the standards applicable to Rule 35 motions seeking reduction of sentences imposed on guilty pleas.  The Supreme Court clarified its prior decisions by holding that a defendant need only show post-sentencing changed circumstances if the Rule 35 motion requests reduction of a sentence imposed on a guilty plea that included an agreement as to the appropriate specific sentence. The Supreme Court explained that the showing is not required to prevail on a Rule 35 motion requesting reduction of a sentence imposed on an open guilty plea.  Because the defendant entered an open guilty plea, the Supreme Court concluded that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in granting his Rule 35 motion without any proof of post-sentencing changed circumstances.  The Supreme Court reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals’ decision and reinstated the trial court’s decision reducing the defendant’s sentence from 31 to 19 years.

To read the unanimous opinion in State of Tennessee v. Jonathan David Patterson, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, go to the opinions section of tncourts.gov.



New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Local Attorney Elected To Regional Leadership Position, Brings Conference To Chattanooga

Chattanooga Chamber Calendar Of Events For June 18-21


Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: A+ QUALITY CONSTRUCTION LLC ADRIANA P HERNANDEZ 4 CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTOR 1106 S. SEMINOLE DR. EAST RIDGE TN 37412 ABSOLUTELY ... (click for more)

Brittany Thomas Faith, of the law firm of Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison, P.C., has been elected by her peers as chair of the American Immigration Lawyers Association Mid-South Chapter and ... (click for more)

June 18, Red Bank/Signal Mountain Chamber Council Meeting 11:45 a.m. to 1 p.m. Red Bank Community Center: Tom Weathers Dr., behind Erlanger Speaker: Vince Butler, Director of Development, ... (click for more)


Business

New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: A+ QUALITY CONSTRUCTION LLC ADRIANA P HERNANDEZ 4 CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTOR 1106 S. SEMINOLE DR. EAST RIDGE TN 37412 ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS INTERIOR NANCY ARELLANO 3 INTERIOR HOME IMPROVEMENT 1035 MT. CREEK RD STE 117 CHATTANOOGA TN 37405 ACTION SERVICE, LLC CHUCK HALLORAN 3 HANDYMAN SERVICES 605 MARLBORO ... (click for more)

Local Attorney Elected To Regional Leadership Position, Brings Conference To Chattanooga

Brittany Thomas Faith, of the law firm of Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison, P.C., has been elected by her peers as chair of the American Immigration Lawyers Association Mid-South Chapter and the Association’s Executive Committee. The Mid-South chapter is a sub-chapter of the national Association that consists of lawyers in Tennessee, Arkansas, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Kentucky. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Chattanooga Auction House Closing; Southside Antiques Moving Into Its Space On Broad Street

The Chattanooga Auction House, at 2423 South Broad St., is closing after over 20 years in business. At the same time, another top local name in antiques and collectibles, Southside Antiques, will be moving. Stan Carnahan, who has long operated the auction house with Perry Voclain and Mike Smelcher, said Southside Antiques will be moving from its longtime location on Williams ... (click for more)

Woman Arrested On Drug Charges After Police Confiscate 50 Pounds Of Marijuana, 23 Pounds Of THC Oil

The Chattanooga Police Department Narcotics Unit arrested a woman on drug charges and confiscated 50 pounds of marijuana and 23 pounds of THC oil. Delores Lawrence, 63, of 1303 Arlington Ave., was charged with possession of marijuana for resale and possession of THC oil for resale. CPD narcotics investigators and Gun Team officers on Saturday stopped a suspect who was ... (click for more)

Opinion

Earl Freudenberg: Remembering 3 Friends (Glenn Draper, Marshall Roberson And Betsy Anderson)

Waking up this Sunday morning (Father's Day), I learned of the passing of three friends who had an impact on my life - Glenn Draper, Marshall Roberson and Betsy Anderson. Glenn was a guest on my radio program many times. He and his musicians represented Chattanooga around the world. In the 50's, Glenn had a national weekly radio program on NBC. He recorded several dozen CD's ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What The Indians Knew

‘Flea’ Chambliss, who was a hale-and-hearty friend for my entire life, died at the age of 81 last week and, when the funeral is held at Lookout Mountain’s Church of the Good Shepherd this coming Tuesday (3:30 p.m.), you can bet some glorious stories will be told. After all, ‘Flea’ was indeed a Chambliss – their family Bible proclaiming he was regally known as John Alexander Chambliss ... (click for more)