Tennessee Supreme Court Holds Defendant Who Enters No Contest Plea Not Entitled To Notice

Tuesday, December 11, 2018

The Tennessee Supreme Court affirmed the trial court’s revocation of judicial diversion for Westley A. Albright, who entered a no contest guilty plea to one count of solicitation of a minor, for which he was placed on judicial diversion and received a one-year probationary term.  As a condition of his probation, Albright was required to register as a sex offender and undergo sex offender treatment.  

The trial court revoked Albright’s judicial diversion after he was discharged from his sex offender treatment program for noncompliance.  Specifically, Albright had failed to take responsibility for the conduct underlying his conviction during his treatment program.  The trial court, however, allowed Albright to remain on probation, but required that he serve an additional six months on probation and complete sex offender therapy.  Albright appealed the decision of the trial court, and the Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the trial court’s decision. 

The Tennessee Supreme Court granted permission to appeal in this case to determine whether due process requires that a sex offender be informed in conjunction with the offender’s plea that judicial diversion and probation could be revoked if the offender is discharged from sex offender treatment due to refusal to admit guilt during the treatment.  The defendant argued that the “hidden” requirement that he admit his intent to solicit a minor as part of his sex offender treatment was inconsistent with his no contest guilty plea. 

In its decision, the Court refused to distinguish among the different methods by which a defendant ultimately is convicted of a crime in terms of what notice the trial court must provide regarding probation.  According to the Court, the particular fact that Albright entered a no contest guilty plea was of no consequence to the due process inquiry. Regarding the due process issue, the Court held that the trial court was not required to provide the defendant with actual notice that his sex offender treatment would require certain admissions.  In so doing, the Court overturned a case from the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals holding otherwise.  Accordingly, the Court affirmed the judgment of the trial court and the Court of Criminal Appeals in Albright’s case. 

Justice Sharon G. Lee dissented, concluding that the revocation of Albright’s diversion violated his due process rights. In her view, requiring Albright to admit responsibility for his underlying conduct during treatment is fundamentally inconsistent with a no contest plea that the trial court accepted without requiring an admission of guilt. Further, Albright had no notice that admitting criminal intent in sex offender treatment was a condition of his diversion, and he had otherwise complied with all stated conditions of his probation. 

To read the Supreme Court’s opinion in State of Tennessee v. Westley A. Albright, authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, and the dissenting opinion authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Chattanooga Chamber Holds Small Business Awards Luncheon And EXPO On Wednesday

Attorneys Fullerton And Savage Join Miller And Martin In Chattanooga

Greater Chattanooga Area Chapter Of ARMA’s Information Management Spring Seminar Set For April 11


The Chamber’s Small Business Awards recognize outstanding nonprofits and small businesses in the area. The Small Business Awards luncheon will be on Wednesday at the Chattanooga Convention ... (click for more)

Miller & Martin announces attorneys Jenna Fullerton and Stephanie Savage have joined the firm as associates in the Chattanooga office. Ms. Fullerton focuses her practice on commercial ... (click for more)

The Greater Chattanooga Area Chapter of ARMA will welcome area records and information management professionals to its Spring Seminar on April 11. The local ARMA Chapter is offering two presentations—one ... (click for more)


Business

Chattanooga Chamber Holds Small Business Awards Luncheon And EXPO On Wednesday

The Chamber’s Small Business Awards recognize outstanding nonprofits and small businesses in the area. The Small Business Awards luncheon will be on Wednesday at the Chattanooga Convention Center. The EXPO will be from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., and will be closed during the luncheon which will be 11:30 a.m.-1 p.m. Finalists and recipients are selected by an independent volunteer ... (click for more)

Attorneys Fullerton And Savage Join Miller And Martin In Chattanooga

Miller & Martin announces attorneys Jenna Fullerton and Stephanie Savage have joined the firm as associates in the Chattanooga office. Ms. Fullerton focuses her practice on commercial litigation and white-collar criminal defense. She has experience with complex litigation matters, contract disputes and negligence torts. Prior to joining Miller & Martin, Ms. Fullerton ... (click for more)

Breaking News

John Harvley Killed In 2-Car Crash Monday Evening In East Ridge

John Charles Harvley, 58, was killed in a collision on Monday evening. He resided at 1520 Merrill Street in East Ridge. On Monday at approximately 5:45 p.m., East Ridge Police responded to a traffic crash on Ringgold Road at Altamaha Street. A Dodge pickup truck was traveling west on Ringgold Road. The truck was occupied by the driver, Jacob Alexander, and his passenger, Michael ... (click for more)

Lipsey Trucking Reiterates That Executive Facing Cocaine Charges Will Have No Role With Chattanooga Firm

The Chattanooga trucking firm headed by Joseph Lipsey III, who was arrested on charges of supplying cocaine and alcohol to teens, has reiterated that he will have no management or ownership role with the firm going forward. Lipsey was arrested on serious federal felony charges along with his wife and 19-year-old son relating to teen parties at Aspen, Col. It was speculated ... (click for more)

Opinion

Chivalry Is Not Dead

On the evening of Tuesday, Feb. 26, I was driving up Lookout Mountain taking my mother home. My 2-year-old granddaughter was also along for the ride. Halfway up Ochs Highway in the middle of a blind curve, at rush hour, my car simply died. Smoke poured out from under the hood, and we were completely stranded. There was a long line of cars stuck behind us unable to go around because ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What’s Become Of Roy?

Today I must begin by telling my Chattanoogan.com readers how humbled and touched I am by the dozens of emails I have received in recent weeks, all concerning my daily disappearance from this website. I like to think my daily musings may, in some way, have a ripple effect on some of the people, the places, and the things that intrigue me. I believe I have rarely sought popularity, ... (click for more)