Good Riddance Of Mayor As Trustee Of The Confederate Cemetery - And Response

Friday, February 23, 2018

After reading the news piece titled, City Files Petition to Turn Confederate Cemetery Over To Sons Of The Confederacy, and prior articles quoting Mayor Berke on the subject of the historic cemetery, it is appropriate for the city to withdraw as trustee. 

The public position statements of the mayor regarding the cemetery demonstrate that he is completely unfit to serve as trustee of this historic place. The Confederate Cemetery and the brave men laid to rest there deserve much better than politically motivated nonsense. 

The cemetery is a resting place for war veterans.  

What is the next war to be offended about, Vietnam veterans? 

So good riddance, mayor, and hopefully the hate filled political rhetoric from City Hall directed toward the brave laid to rest in the cemetery will end with the city’s removal as trustee.  Stop using these war veteran for your political nonsense. 

A trustee that possesses southern historical knowledge would be preferred over politically motivated pandering of the current trustee.  This is a welcome changing of the guard. 

Many Chattanooga families have a family member in the Confederate Cemetery. It is not a badge of shame to have family buried in the cemetery as our mayor has suggested in his comments. The civil war was not as simplistic and linear as the city's latest press release suggests in the "principles."   

The political rhetoric directed toward the brave men buried at the Confederate Cemetery, included references to the dead as racists. 

Mayor Berke stated, “Our action today makes it clear that the city of Chattanooga condemns white supremacy in every way, shape and form. While we honor our dead, we do not honor the principle for which they fought.” 

Painting all confederate soldiers as racist, really? That is a huge race baited paint brush City Hall is using. 

What was the motivation and in the hearts of a Confederate solider?   

Historians and scholars for decades have studied and written about the journals of confederate soldiers. What better source, than the soldiers themselves? 

The majority of Confederate soldiers were never slave owners or rich plantation owners. The majority were not vested in slave ownership. Most southern civil war veterans were poor dirt farmers. The confederate soldiers believed in the power as a state to self-govern as a broader issue. Not my words, the words of historians. 

Scholars report that once the South succeeded from the Union, the motivation of the average confederate solider was patriotism to the South and money to enlist. As their Southern homeland was invaded by a foreign enemy, the number one motivation was patriotism to the South. 

The slave ownership issue was a rich plantation owner’s problem, not one of the common Southerner. The broader fight was state decision making as was agreed in the formation of the Union. 

The mindset of the confederate soldier is not difficult to understand especially when southern farms, business, and lands were being invaded by war criminals called the Union Army. 

There is little discussion about the war crimes committed by the Union Army against the Southern innocents.  The Union Army committed horrific war crimes against southern women and children. Where is the City Hall chatter about this aspect of the Civil War?

Many historians and scholars write of the war crimes of the Union army against civilians, “The Hard Hand of War, sees an evolution in soldiers' thinking as the war progressed. Instead of shedding their initial ideology, as Linderman claims, Grimsley's soldiers became more ideological. Union troops became more willing to inflict 'hard war' on southern civilians.”

The Union Army did in fact inflict hard war on the innocents of the South with mass murder, rape, and theft of property in home raids. 

I tire of ill-informed political babbling from City Hall directed towards the confederate cemetery with omissions of factual and published findings. 

So, withdraw as trustee, and good riddance city of Chattanooga and mayor. These war veterans deserve better. 

For Chattanoogans with family buried in the Cemetery, this should be an opportunity to support this historic confederate cemetery financially.  I plan to donate to the preservation of history. 

Hopefully, the new trustee will provide a public support website. 

April Eidson 

* * *

Mayor, your opinion of white supremacy in the comparison of the Confederate cemetery is appalling and disgraceful to any historian. Much less a citizen of this great country. You are entitled to yo-ur opinion but the blatant disregard to American history is absolutely next to unpardonable. 

How the city of Chattanooga ever elected a official with the poorest aptitude to truth is beyond comprehension.  If you decided you didn’t want the city of Chattanooga taking care of the cemetery and the responsibility of the upkeep is one matter. But to associate the hateful and bigot white supremacy movement to the Confederate soldiers who died is weak, cheap and cowardly. 

What do you expect the results and response to this decision, and not to the decision itself but the written response of said decision to be? Are you appealing to the hateful constituency of political and social division of which you say that you as a person and mayor are against? What makes you different than any white supremacy group or Black Lives Matter or Antifa, or any hateful racist group? 

Mayor, take care of the city and the mayoral duties and leave the history to people who actually know it.

Brian Vann


Reasons To Choose Another Sewer Treatment Plant Site

Why WWTA's Plan Should Be Discarded

The Deck Is Rigged Against Howard


The Hamilton County Commission is being asked to make a tough decision when it comes to the location of the WWTA WWTP. On one side, you have a handful of people who are pro WWTP at Mahan Gap ... (click for more)

Thanks to a live feed, I was able to watch about three hours of the very important Hamilton County Commission meeting on Dec. 12 while in Alabama. This was the first time I have been able to ... (click for more)

I was more than appalled when I read the list of vocational programs per school across Hamilton County. We put a man on the moon nearly 60 years ago, yet HCDE can’t figure out how to make opportunities ... (click for more)


Opinion

Reasons To Choose Another Sewer Treatment Plant Site

The Hamilton County Commission is being asked to make a tough decision when it comes to the location of the WWTA WWTP. On one side, you have a handful of people who are pro WWTP at Mahan Gap because they want to develop northern Hamilton County and on the other hand, you have residents who want to protect the largest investment that they've made, i.e., their home and their ability ... (click for more)

Why WWTA's Plan Should Be Discarded

Thanks to a live feed, I was able to watch about three hours of the very important Hamilton County Commission meeting on Dec. 12 while in Alabama. This was the first time I have been able to hear both sides of the WWTA vs. Ooltewah Homeowners fully present their arguments. One thing we can all agree on is that they have to do something, the question is what is the best for all. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

State Dismisses All Charges Against Charles Toney In Controversial Arrest

The state on Tuesday morning dismissed all charges against aspiring rapper Charles Toney in connection with his arrest that led to a U.S. Department of Justice probe. The arrest on Dec. 3 on Donaldson Road was caught on video by a neighbor and went viral. It showed Toney being punched and kicked by an officer while he was handcuffed. District Attorney Neal Pinkston afterward ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Schools Announces New School Options And Timeline

For the 2019-2020 school year, Hamilton County Schools is opening enrollment to a select group of schools, “My Future Schools,” to which students across the district will be eligible to apply. Officials said, "Opening enrollment to these schools will provide students with a diverse range of options outside of their neighborhood zoned school. These schools will be in addition to ... (click for more)

Sports

Cleveland Boys' And Girls' Basketball Teams Involved In "Inappropriate Conduct"

Reports surfaced Monday that Cleveland’s boys’ and girls’ basketball teams broke curfew and engaged in inappropriate conduct after a basketball double-header last Friday in Oak Ridge. The Blue Raiders and Lady Blue Raiders played doubleheaders at Fulton and Oak Ridge over the weekend. On Tuesday, Russell Dyer, director of Cleveland schools, released a statement through the ... (click for more)

St. Francis Knocks Off East Hamilton, 58-53, Despite Hayes' 33-Point Effort

East Hamilton’s Lady Hurricanes fell to St. Francis (Georgia), 58-53, in their opening game Tuesday in the CresCom Bank Holiday Invitational at the Myrtle Beach Convention Center in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. Junior Madison Hayes scored a game-high 33 points on 12-of-20 shooting and also grabbed 11 rebounds for the Lady Canes (7-5), but even that wasn’t enough to overcome ... (click for more)