4 Pilot Employees Involved In Fraud Get Probation

Wednesday, January 23, 2019

Four Pilot Travel Center employees involved in a massive fraud against trucking companies were granted probation at Federal Court in Chattanooga on Wednesday afternoon.

They included Katy Bibee, who found she had cancer two weeks after the FBI came calling on her front porch, and Kevin Clark, who lost a son to cancer last March. 

The government had classified the foursome as the least culpable in the scheme.

They will be on probation for three years. Ms. Bibee, Chris Andrews and Michael Scott Fenwick must perform 200 hours of community service and Clark perform 150 hours.

Fenwick was ordered to pay a $4,000 fine and Clark $3,000.

At the start of the hearing, before credits were given, Andrews and Ms. Bibee were facing 24-30 months, Fenwick 18-24 months and Clark 12-18 months. 

Judge Curtis Collier noted that the four defendants had cooperated with the government early and all but Fenwick testified at the trial of Pilot president Mark Hazelwood and three others. The attorney for Fenwick said he had been in Salt Lake City ready to go, but never got the call.

Judge Collier said the case was "a remarkable story - it ought to be put in a book or perhaps a movie to make our citizens aware of the importance of making right decisions."

He said, "There were massive losses in the tens of millions."

Ms. Bibee said, "I'm sorry for the customers I lied to. I've learned a hard lesson."

She said she was on Cloud 9 when at a young age she joined "the most revered company in Knoxville." She said, "That it operated at a fast pace was quickly revealed to me. Every email was marked Urgent or ASAP."

Ms. Bibee said the message was "never stop adding travel centers and giving back to the community. It seemed like enough was never enough."

She  told the judge, "It often felt like we were playing with Monopoly money. At times I felt uneasy and I rationalized. Then it snowballed." She said she still asks herself, "Why did I not speak up?"

She stated, "Now I know that I have three beautiful children and a husband and all we need are each other." She said she now concentrates on "living a life of honesty and standing up for what is right - even if it is hard."

Her attorney said Ms. Bibee spends much of her time with PTA work and with mentoring young women who also get cancer diagnoses. A number of those she has helped were in the packed courtroom.

All of the defendants expressed remorse, saying they were especially ashamed of cheating their customers. The attorney for Andrews said he had tried to get a job in the corporate world, but he was never hired because of his involvement in the Pilot case. Andrews said he and his second wife had twin daughters and had started their own murder mystery dinner theater business. It has grown to six theaters.

Andrews said, "I lied and cheated and caused real harm. I am so ashamed."

Fenwick told of "the sorrow and shame I have felt for the past five years." He said, Now you can trust me to do the right thing each and every day."

Clark told the judge, "I am truly sorry for the harm I caused - especially to my customers." He said he and his wife have started a pet fencing business. 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

The Father Of Samuel Williams Spied Out One Of The Most Beautiful Vistas In The South (2nd In A Series)

East Lake Home Damaged By Fire Friday Afternoon; Theresa Umbreit, 45, Charged With Arson


Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ANGLEA, CHEYENNE ASHLEY 959 COUNTY 20 ROAD CALHOUN, 37340 Age at Arrest: 25 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga DISORDERLY ... (click for more)

It was the father of Samuel Williams who spied out one of the most beautiful vistas in the South on the Tennessee River near the future Chattanooga. As spelled out in the old Williams lawsuit ... (click for more)

An East Lake home was severely damaged by fire on Friday afternoon, and Theresa Umbreit, 45, was arrested for arson. Chattanooga firefighters were dispatched to the house fire at ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ANGLEA, CHEYENNE ASHLEY 959 COUNTY 20 ROAD CALHOUN, 37340 Age at Arrest: 25 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga DISORDERLY CONDUCT PUBLIC INTOXICATION --- BAILEY, CHARLES FRANKLIN 6309 POTTS RD APT B CHATTANOOGA, 37416 Age at Arrest: 39 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County VIOLATION ... (click for more)

The Father Of Samuel Williams Spied Out One Of The Most Beautiful Vistas In The South (2nd In A Series)

It was the father of Samuel Williams who spied out one of the most beautiful vistas in the South on the Tennessee River near the future Chattanooga. As spelled out in the old Williams lawsuit that was found last March, George Washington Williams had come first to Hamilton County from the pleasant narrow valley at Paint Rock, Ala. He had left some of his grown children, including ... (click for more)

Opinion

Bill Passes Senate That Preserves Tennessee's Natural Beauty And Historical Sites

This week, the U.S. Senate passed sweeping legislation that will preserve Tennessee’s natural beauty and protect our historical sites. I have seen first-hand how a popular park or museum can provide a recreation or educational experience for Tennesseans. But these sites can also help local economies by attracting tourism, which brings with it jobs and tax dollars to Tennessee. ... (click for more)

How Do We Progress With This President? - And Response (2)

I try so hard to not say things detrimental to our government, I love my country but I am so ashamed by the president we now tolerate. When is it going to be said enough is enough? Today, he declared an emergency declaration to move billions of dollars of possible worthy endeavors in our countries budget to fight illegal immigration to build his wall. I will compare 20 to 1 the ... (click for more)

Sports

Cleveland Wrestlers Lock Up AAA State Title Again

The longest day of the traditional state wrestling tournament is now over and it’s time for the best to stand up and do their thing for all the marbles Saturday night. There was a whole lot of action in all three divisions here at the Williamson County Agricultural Expo Park in Franklin and it’s really no surprise which teams are standing tall at the top of the list. The defending ... (click for more)

Bradley Boys, McMinn Girls Roll Into Semifinals With District 5-3A Tourney Wins

There’s an old saying in golf: “It’s not how you drive, but how you arrive.” A long drive is fine. A flubbed approach to the green can ruin everything. It’s been said in basketball that, “It’s not always how you start, but how you finish.” Bradley Central and Ooltewah both started slowly Friday night in their District 5-3A tournament game at Soddy-Daisy High School. However, ... (click for more)