Tennessee Supreme Court Determines Banks Not Protected From Liability After Removing Joint Tenant’s Name From Account Without Consent

Wednesday, March 20, 2019
The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled today a bank that removed an individual from an account held as a joint tenant with right of survivorship without the individual’s permission was not protected from liability. The Court found the plaintiff had sufficiently alleged claims for relief against the bank by asserting that the bank removed his name from the accounts without his consent and breached its duty to him as a co-owner of the accounts by accepting forged signature cards to remove him from the accounts.  As a result, the Supreme Court reversed the trial court and Court of Appeals decisions, which had dismissed the lawsuit. 
 
Although no proof has yet been presented, in his complaint initiating the lawsuit, Mr.
Daniel Haire alleged that he began managing his parents’ affairs in 2005.  When his father passed away in 2008, he was listed along with his mother, Mrs. Ella Haire, as a joint tenant with right of survivorship on a checking account and a savings account at First Tennessee Bank. For the next four years, Mr. Haire served as his mother’s primary caretaker and managed her financial affairs. 
 
In 2012, after a disagreement with his sister, he relinquished those duties to his sister and brother. Mr. Haire did not sign any paperwork removing his name from the checking or savings accounts. Over the next 18 to 20 months, multiple new signature cards were completed on the checking and savings accounts, never listing Mr. Haire and often listing the brother or sister in some capacity. When Mrs. Haire passed away in November 2013, First Tennessee paid the $129,000 in the savings account to the sister and the $11,500 in the checking account to the brother and sister. Mr. Haire only learned around that time that he was no longer listed as a joint tenant with right of survivorship on the account and sued the bank for removing him.
 
The trial court dismissed Mr. Haire’s case, finding that, under Tennessee law, a bank is not liable when one party removes funds from a joint account. The Court of Appeals affirmed, and Mr. Haire appealed to the Supreme Court. 
 
In its ruling, the Supreme Court found that a joint tenant with right of survivorship is an owner of a joint tenancy bank account and possesses an ownership interest in account funds, which is presumptively equal to that of other joint tenants.  The Supreme Court stated a contractual relationship arises between a bank and joint tenants when an account is created and that this contract cannot be modified without the consent of the parties.  
 
The Supreme Court emphasized that the Tennessee law the trial court and Court of Appeals relied upon to dismiss the lawsuit only protects banks from liability for paying funds from a joint account to a party on the account.  In this case, the funds were not removed from the account, but one of the joint parties was taken off the account without consent. 
 
The Supreme Court found that no Tennessee law expressly protects banks from liability for removing a joint tenant’s name from a multiple party account without the joint tenant’s consent.  The Supreme Court, therefore, reversed the lower court decisions dismissing Mr. Haire’s lawsuit and sent the case back for further proceedings.  The Supreme Court noted that when the case returns to the trial court the bank will have an opportunity to overcome Mr. Haire’s presumption of equal ownership of the account funds by showing that he did not contribute equally to the account. 

To read the unanimous opinion in Estate of Ella Mae Haire et al v. Shelby J. Webster et al., authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Local Attorney Elected To Regional Leadership Position, Brings Conference To Chattanooga

Chattanooga Chamber Calendar Of Events For June 18-21


Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: A+ QUALITY CONSTRUCTION LLC ADRIANA P HERNANDEZ 4 CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTOR 1106 S. SEMINOLE DR. EAST RIDGE TN 37412 ABSOLUTELY ... (click for more)

Brittany Thomas Faith, of the law firm of Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison, P.C., has been elected by her peers as chair of the American Immigration Lawyers Association Mid-South Chapter and ... (click for more)

June 18, Red Bank/Signal Mountain Chamber Council Meeting 11:45 a.m. to 1 p.m. Red Bank Community Center: Tom Weathers Dr., behind Erlanger Speaker: Vince Butler, Director of Development, ... (click for more)


Business

New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: A+ QUALITY CONSTRUCTION LLC ADRIANA P HERNANDEZ 4 CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTOR 1106 S. SEMINOLE DR. EAST RIDGE TN 37412 ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS INTERIOR NANCY ARELLANO 3 INTERIOR HOME IMPROVEMENT 1035 MT. CREEK RD STE 117 CHATTANOOGA TN 37405 ACTION SERVICE, LLC CHUCK HALLORAN 3 HANDYMAN SERVICES 605 MARLBORO ... (click for more)

Local Attorney Elected To Regional Leadership Position, Brings Conference To Chattanooga

Brittany Thomas Faith, of the law firm of Grant, Konvalinka & Harrison, P.C., has been elected by her peers as chair of the American Immigration Lawyers Association Mid-South Chapter and the Association’s Executive Committee. The Mid-South chapter is a sub-chapter of the national Association that consists of lawyers in Tennessee, Arkansas, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Kentucky. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Acquisition Expands Sequatchie Cave State Natural Area From 12 To 137 Acres

The Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC) has acquired 125 acres in Marion County as an addition to the Sequatchie Cave State Natural Area, a step that will increase the size of the natural area by 1,000 percent. The state purchased the land from Drs. Jim and Sherry Turner of Hattiesburg, Miss., with transactional support and assistance from The Land ... (click for more)

5 Alabama Residents Charged With TennCare Fraud

Five residents of Alabama are each charged in separate indictments with TennCare fraud. The Office of Inspector General today announced the indictments, which accuse the five of claiming to live in Tennessee when in fact they were residing in Alabama which would have disqualified them for enrollment healthcare insurance benefits through the program. “Providing false ... (click for more)

Opinion

Earl Freudenberg: Remembering 3 Friends (Glenn Draper, Marshall Roberson And Betsy Anderson)

Waking up this Sunday morning (Father's Day), I learned of the passing of three friends who had an impact on my life - Glenn Draper, Marshall Roberson and Betsy Anderson. Glenn was a guest on my radio program many times. He and his musicians represented Chattanooga around the world. In the 50's, Glenn had a national weekly radio program on NBC. He recorded several dozen CD's ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What The Indians Knew

‘Flea’ Chambliss, who was a hale-and-hearty friend for my entire life, died at the age of 81 last week and, when the funeral is held at Lookout Mountain’s Church of the Good Shepherd this coming Tuesday (3:30 p.m.), you can bet some glorious stories will be told. After all, ‘Flea’ was indeed a Chambliss – their family Bible proclaiming he was regally known as John Alexander Chambliss ... (click for more)