Judge Returns Opioid Lawsuit To Tennessee State Court

Friday, May 24, 2019

A ruling issued Wednesday in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee has helped clear the way for a 19-county lawsuit against major opioid producers and distributors to move forward in state court.

The ruling, issued by Judge Aleta A. Trauger, denied a motion by McKesson, a pharmaceutical distributor and defendant in the case, to remove the case to federal court. Judge Trauger also denied a joint motion by the defendants to stay proceedings. The case has now been returned to the Circuit Court of Cumberland County where it awaits trial.

Plaintiffs bringing suit against a number of opioid producers and distributors include the district attorneys general of Tennessee’s Thirteenth, Sixteenth, Seventeenth, Twenty-Second and Thirty-First Judicial Districts. Included in that group is lead district attorney for the case, Bryant C. Dunaway, who represents Tennessee’s Thirteenth Judicial District.

“We are very pleased with Judge Trauger’s decision to deny removal of the case to federal court,” says Mr. Dunaway. “We continue to work toward our goal of holding the defendants accountable for the deliberate and illegal distribution of Schedule II narcotics in our state, and the damage they have brought to our region as a result. We look forward to trying this case on behalf of Baby Doe and the communities we represent.” 

The 2018 suit brings two causes of action under the Tennessee Drug Dealer Liability Act against producer defendants Purdue Pharma L.P.; Purdue Pharma Inc.; The Purdue Frederick Company; Endo Health Solutions Inc.; Endo Pharmaceuticals Inc.; and Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc.; along with pill mills and drug dealers. Count I is brought on behalf of plaintiff Baby Doe, while Count II is brought by the district attorneys general on behalf of their respective districts and the 19 counties they represent. The suit demands judgment against the defendants for damages, seeks restitution for the plaintiffs and an injunction to stop the flood of opioids to the region.

“We applaud today’s ruling that ‘when a state such as Tennessee has crafted an independent response to opioid abuse that does not rely on federal law to impose liability, the appropriate forum for such causes of action are state courts,’” says Gerard Stranch, managing partner for Branstetter, Stranch & Jennings (BS&J) PLLC of Nashville. “In this case the defendants failed to establish a recognized basis for federal jurisdiction, and we’re very pleased that the way has been cleared for this complaint to move to trial.”

This week’s memorandum and order followed a Cumberland County Circuit Court ruling last February denying the defendants’ motion to dismiss the case and declaring that the lawsuit could move forward in litigation.

Visit www.tnbabydoe.com for additional facts, resources and documentation surrounding this issue.


Tennessee Supreme Court Holds Evidence Not Enough To Hold Man Liable For Woman's Suicide

Green Is The Future Of Airports

Chattanooga Airport Completes Final Phase Of Solar Farm


The Tennessee Supreme Court today, in a divided opinion, dismissed a negligence lawsuit filed by the estate of a woman who committed suicide. In 2011, the defendant, Dr. Jerry Scott Wilson, ... (click for more)

Aviation has an august history of firsts. You may know many of their stories — Wright, Earhart, Armstrong and Naylor. Wait…Naylor? John Naylor is an Air Force veteran and aviation pioneer ... (click for more)

The Chattanooga Airport, along with elected officials, TVA, EPB and community leaders, on Wednesday celebrated completion of the final phase of its solar farm, located along Jubilee Drive. The ... (click for more)


Business

Tennessee Supreme Court Holds Evidence Not Enough To Hold Man Liable For Woman's Suicide

The Tennessee Supreme Court today, in a divided opinion, dismissed a negligence lawsuit filed by the estate of a woman who committed suicide. In 2011, the defendant, Dr. Jerry Scott Wilson, a psychiatrist, and the decedent, Christina Marie Cotten, a registered nurse who worked with him, embarked on an affair. Dr. Wilson was single, but Ms. Cotten was married and had a young ... (click for more)

Green Is The Future Of Airports

Aviation has an august history of firsts. You may know many of their stories — Wright, Earhart, Armstrong and Naylor. Wait…Naylor? John Naylor is an Air Force veteran and aviation pioneer you may not know. His dream is to revolutionize aviation by making airports more sustainable. As the Chattanooga Airport Authority vice president of Airport Planning, Mr. Naylor was in ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Storm Destroys Home In Falling Water Thursday Morning Trapping 6 Adults, 3 Children Inside

Strong storms rolled through Hamilton County Thursday morning destroying a mobile home in the Falling Water area. At 8:15 a.m., the residents made a 911 call reporting a tree had fallen on their mobile home and they were trapped inside. Dallas Bay Volunteer Fire Department responded to 728 Roberts Mills Road and reported a large tree on top of the mobile home. Firefighters ... (click for more)

Judge Gives Extra Time To Chattanooga Man Who Made Vulgar, Threatening Calls To U.S. Rep. Diane Black

Federal Judge Curtis Collier on Wednesday rejected an agreed sentence for a Chattanooga man who pleaded guilty to making vulgar, threatening calls to former U.S. Rep. Diane Black., who was in the courtroom and gave a statement. Judge Collier called it "a crime against all citizens," saying such threats could lead some people to forego running for public office. The judge said, ... (click for more)

Opinion

Thank You, Commissioners Smedley, Bankston, Fairbanks And Boyd

County Chairwoman Sabrena Smedley and Commissioners Chester Bankston, Randy Fairbanks, and Tim Boyd are all the right stuff that Republicans and conservatives are made of. It is a beautiful thing when our elected unite to do the right thing. We have some real leaders in this group. These county commissioners are representing the majority of property owners in Hamilton County, ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Yes, We Still Eat Dogs

As one who is richly blessed by the humor that arrives at my email address, a couple of years ago I started collecting some of the funny ones and that is how “The Saturday Funnies” began to appear on Chattanoogan.com. The Funnies are extremely popular and, throughout the week, I’ll often have too many because I get them by the dozens most days. The big search engines like Google, ... (click for more)