Man Facing DUI Charge Says Officer "Made An Honest Mistake"; Officer Says He Got The Right Man

Monday, June 10, 2019 - by Joseph Dycus
James D. Mathis
James D. Mathis

A Chattanooga man on Monday contested his DUI charge in front of the police officer who charged him, with his attorney saying that the officer may have “made an honest mistake.”

On Aug. 26, 2017 on Shallowford Road, James D. Mathis, 34, was pulled over by officer Ryan Lynn after allegedly driving far above the speed limit. According to Officer Lynn, he needed to drive 80 miles per hour on the 40 mile per hour road to catch up to Mathis’ vehicle.

After failing the sobriety test, Mathis was charged with reckless driving and driving under the influence.

The case centered around whether or not the officer pursued the correct man. Dashcam footage was presented to the court, and several details appeared to be unclear.

Despite officer Lynn stating that he could see the color of the vehicle, the footage showed it was very difficult to tell due to how dark it was at the time.

When the defendant’s attorney, Robin Flores, questioned him on this, Officer Lynn stated “My eyesight reads better than this video.”

“So are you saying you have eagle eyes,” asked attorney Flores.

“I don’t know what eagle eyes look like, sir,” responded the officer. 

According to Officer Lynn, there was only one vehicle in between him and Mathis’ vehicle. Because the other vehicle possessed a third brake light, he also used that detail to distinguish between the two vehicles. The video corroborated this part of his testimony.

There was also evidence of Officer Lynn asking another officer what to charge him with, and whether this chase qualified as a pursuit. Officer Lynn claimed it was not a pursuit because Mathis was not aware he was being followed or pursued. Attorney Flores countered by asking how Officer Lynn could know what Mathis was thinking.

Judge Don Poole said he would need some time to review the testimony and dashcam video before ruling on it.


Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Water Distribution Site Locations Set For Sunday

Change In Water Distribution Site Locations Made To Accommodate Neighborhoods With Greater Need


Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: BEARDEN, WENDY LEE 4811 HAL DR CHATTANOOGA, 37416 Age at Arrest: 44 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga THEFT UNDER $1,000 ---- ... (click for more)

The City of Chattanooga, Chattanooga Fire and Police Departments continue to provide services, alongside our county and regional partners and Tennessee American Water, to those without water. ... (click for more)

As some neighborhoods in Chattanooga’s lower elevations continue to regain adequate water pressure, the Chattanooga Police Department and the Youth & Family Development Centers will be reallocating ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: BEARDEN, WENDY LEE 4811 HAL DR CHATTANOOGA, 37416 Age at Arrest: 44 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga THEFT UNDER $1,000 ---- BRADFORD, JOSHUA LEE 8741 CRESTBROOK CIRCLE CHATTANOOGA, 37421 Age at Arrest: 33 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County FUGITIVE (ARREST FOR CRIME IN DADE CO, GA) ---- BURTON, ... (click for more)

Water Distribution Site Locations Set For Sunday

The City of Chattanooga, Chattanooga Fire and Police Departments continue to provide services, alongside our county and regional partners and Tennessee American Water, to those without water. Additionally, partners at Tri-State Mutual Aid Association continue to provide fire suppression for Hamilton County until water is returned to those residences. While pressure maps ... (click for more)

Opinion

We Remember Sept. 11th

Our nation was attacked on Sept. 11, 2001 and our world changed. Muslim terrorists called al-Qaeda, with training camps all around the world were responsible for the death of the more than 3,000 victims. This is an enemy unlike any we have ever faced. There are multiple countries, multiple fronts and multiple threats. This enemy is committed to the absolute destruction of the ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Country Music’s Top 98

It was in the late ‘80s, not long before Auburn and Tennessee would play early in the year to set the early pace in the annual SEC race. I needed Auburn football coach Pat Dye to help me understand the early-season strategy of what the loser of the game between Tennessee and Auburn would need to do to stay viable in the home stretch of SEC play that year; it affected bowl invitations ... (click for more)

Sports

UT Manhandles Mocs 45-0

The Chattanooga Mocs made the short trip up I-75 falling 45-0 at Tennessee. The Vols took advantage of early struggles to put the game away early. A big return on the opening kickoff set Tennessee up with a short field. It took six plays to go 41 yards with the initial tally coming on a 13-yard Ty Chandler run. The next score came less than two minutes later with Brandon Johnson ... (click for more)

UTC's Gerdes Leads Mocs In Chattanooga Collegiate Clay Court Championships

University of Tennessee at Chattanooga junior Niklas Gerdes led the Mocs men’s tennis team on the second day of the Chattanooga Collegiate Clay Court Championships at Manker Patten. The Geestland, Germany, native advanced to the finals of the doubles draw and the singles semifinals with wins today. Gerdes started the morning session with a 6-0 doubles win with sophomore Tomas ... (click for more)