Tennessee Supreme Court Abandons Doctrine Of Abatement Ab Initio

Thursday, August 8, 2019

The Tennessee Supreme Court Thursday ruled unanimously that the Court of Criminal Appeals should no longer vacate convictions when criminal defendants die during an appeal guaranteed by law, known as an appeal as of right from the conviction. 

In the case before the Court, Mr. Hassan Falah al Mutory was found guilty of reckless homicide. He appealed his conviction but died before the Court of Criminal Appeals could rule on the matter.  Mr. Mutory’s attorney then filed a motion asking the Court of Criminal Appeals to apply the doctrine of abatement ab initio, which the Tennessee Supreme Court first adopted in 1966. This doctrine requires appellate courts to vacate a defendant’s conviction and dismiss the indictment if the defendant dies during an appeal as of right from a conviction. The State opposed this motion, arguing that the doctrine of abatement ab initio now is inconsistent with the laws and public policy of Tennessee.  The Court of Criminal Appeals rejected the State’s argument, applied abatement ab initio, vacated Mr. Mutory’s conviction, and dismissed the indictment.  

The Tennessee Supreme Court granted the State permission to appeal.  The Supreme Court unanimously concluded that, due to changes in the public policy of Tennessee in the arena of victims’ rights, the doctrine of abatement ab initio should be abandoned.  Although some states allow an appeal to continue after a defendant’s death if other interests, such as restitution or probate or legal issues of broad application are at issue, the Supreme Court, by a four-to-one vote, concluded that no party had advanced an interest that would benefit from allowing Mr. Mutory’s appeal as of right to continue.  This same four-justice majority refrained in this case from adopting a final procedure to replace abatement ab initio but reinstated Mr. Mutory’s conviction and dismissed his appeal because no interest or evidence had been presented warranting continuation of the appeal.  The Supreme Court majority referred the issue to the Advisory Commission on the Rules of Practice and Procedure for further study and, if appropriate, for a recommendation of a procedure to replace the doctrine of abatement ab initio to apply when a defendant dies during the pendency of an appeal as of right from a conviction.   

Justice Sharon G. Lee filed a separate opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part. Justice Lee agreed with the Court’s decision to abandon the doctrine of abatement ab initio.  Justice Lee, however, did not go along with the Court’s decision to dismiss Mr. Mutory’s appeal.  In Justice Lee’s view, the Court should have adopted a procedure for appellate review of convictions involving fines, fees, restitution, or civil consequences to the defendant’s family or estate.  This approach, which balances defendants’ and victims’ rights, would provide a safeguard against the injustice of a wrongful conviction and the resulting financial costs to a family or estate.  

To read the majority opinion in State v. Mutory, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, and the separate opinion, authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, go to the opinions section of tncourts.gov


TVA Board Focuses On Strengthening Tennessee Valley Public Power

CBL Properties Responds To NYSE Noncompliance Notification

Chattanooga Chamber Calendar Of Events Aug. 26-30


The Tennessee Valley Authority board of directors approved a number of forward-looking actions designed to add flexibility and stability to the public power model serving more than 10 million ... (click for more)

CBL Properties on Wedneseday announced that it received notification from the New York Stock Exchange that as of Monday, the company is no longer in compliance with NYSE continued listing criteria, ... (click for more)

Aug. 26, Introduction to Enneagram 6 to 7:30 p.m. The Chattery at Chattanooga WorkSpace 302 W. 6th St. This class will give you a broad overview of the nine Enneagram types and how ... (click for more)


Business

TVA Board Focuses On Strengthening Tennessee Valley Public Power

The Tennessee Valley Authority board of directors approved a number of forward-looking actions designed to add flexibility and stability to the public power model serving more than 10 million people in TVA’s service territory at its meeting in Knoxville, said officials. The board approved both an FY20 budget that does not increase wholesale power rates and sets a new strategic ... (click for more)

CBL Properties Responds To NYSE Noncompliance Notification

CBL Properties on Wedneseday announced that it received notification from the New York Stock Exchange that as of Monday, the company is no longer in compliance with NYSE continued listing criteria, which require listed companies to maintain an average closing share price of at least $1.00 over a consecutive 30 trading-day period. The company intends to pursue measures to cure ... (click for more)

Breaking News

State Dismisses Manslaughter Charge Against Jadarius Knox; Anguished Mother Of Victim Says "He Didn't Have To Kill Him"

The District Attorney's Office on Thursday dismissed a voluntary manslaughter charge against Jadarius Knox, saying evidence in the case in which Dakota Biddle was killed showed a self defense theory could be found to be valid. Knox was original charged with criminal homicide in the May 2018 incident on Basswood Drive, but it was reduced to voluntary manslaughter at the Grand ... (click for more)

Lookout Mountain, Ga. Town Center Work To Start Soon; Jim Sabourin Resigns From Council And Is Replaced By Kevin Leckenby

After eight years of talking and planning, Lookout Mountain, Ga., is ready to begin building a new Town Center. To begin with there will be two municipal buildings, City Hall and a fire station. The design of the area has space for private developers to build commercial buildings in the future. Adhering to design guidelines provided by the city and aiming for a cost of $2.8 ... (click for more)

Opinion

What Does The White Privilege Presentation Have To Do With Education? - And Response (5)

On Aug. 2, Hamilton County Schools held a professional development presented by motivational speaker Robert Jackson. The PD was for the teachers in the Opportunity Zone, which includes the 12 lowest-performing schools in Hamilton County where 90 percent of the students are black. During the 90-minute presentation, there was a 15-20-minute segment concerning “White Privilege”. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: A Drum Major For Peace

There have been many Christmas Seasons when I have looked high and low for Christmas Cards that included the poem, “One Solitary Life.” I came across the revered poem easily over 40 years ago during a kiddie matinee at the famed Radio City Music Hall, which is in midtown Manhattan. The Radio Music Hall is huge – it can comfortably seat 6,000 – and so awesome is the Christmas Spectacular ... (click for more)