Tennessee Supreme Court Abandons Doctrine Of Abatement Ab Initio

Thursday, August 8, 2019

The Tennessee Supreme Court Thursday ruled unanimously that the Court of Criminal Appeals should no longer vacate convictions when criminal defendants die during an appeal guaranteed by law, known as an appeal as of right from the conviction. 

In the case before the Court, Mr. Hassan Falah al Mutory was found guilty of reckless homicide. He appealed his conviction but died before the Court of Criminal Appeals could rule on the matter.  Mr. Mutory’s attorney then filed a motion asking the Court of Criminal Appeals to apply the doctrine of abatement ab initio, which the Tennessee Supreme Court first adopted in 1966. This doctrine requires appellate courts to vacate a defendant’s conviction and dismiss the indictment if the defendant dies during an appeal as of right from a conviction. The State opposed this motion, arguing that the doctrine of abatement ab initio now is inconsistent with the laws and public policy of Tennessee.  The Court of Criminal Appeals rejected the State’s argument, applied abatement ab initio, vacated Mr. Mutory’s conviction, and dismissed the indictment.  

The Tennessee Supreme Court granted the State permission to appeal.  The Supreme Court unanimously concluded that, due to changes in the public policy of Tennessee in the arena of victims’ rights, the doctrine of abatement ab initio should be abandoned.  Although some states allow an appeal to continue after a defendant’s death if other interests, such as restitution or probate or legal issues of broad application are at issue, the Supreme Court, by a four-to-one vote, concluded that no party had advanced an interest that would benefit from allowing Mr. Mutory’s appeal as of right to continue.  This same four-justice majority refrained in this case from adopting a final procedure to replace abatement ab initio but reinstated Mr. Mutory’s conviction and dismissed his appeal because no interest or evidence had been presented warranting continuation of the appeal.  The Supreme Court majority referred the issue to the Advisory Commission on the Rules of Practice and Procedure for further study and, if appropriate, for a recommendation of a procedure to replace the doctrine of abatement ab initio to apply when a defendant dies during the pendency of an appeal as of right from a conviction.   

Justice Sharon G. Lee filed a separate opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part. Justice Lee agreed with the Court’s decision to abandon the doctrine of abatement ab initio.  Justice Lee, however, did not go along with the Court’s decision to dismiss Mr. Mutory’s appeal.  In Justice Lee’s view, the Court should have adopted a procedure for appellate review of convictions involving fines, fees, restitution, or civil consequences to the defendant’s family or estate.  This approach, which balances defendants’ and victims’ rights, would provide a safeguard against the injustice of a wrongful conviction and the resulting financial costs to a family or estate.  

To read the majority opinion in State v. Mutory, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, and the separate opinion, authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, go to the opinions section of tncourts.gov


Allie Weiss Named As Baker Donelson's Pro Bono Committee Office Chairwoman For Chattanooga

Yoga Landing Celebrates green|light Certification With Exemplary Green Business Practices

Online Personalized License Plate Application Now Available


Baker Donelson has appointed Allie Weiss to serve as Pro Bono Committee Office chairwoman for the firm's Chattanooga office. As the Chattanooga Pro Bono Committee Office Chair, Ms. Weiss ... (click for more)

Yoga Landing on East Broad Street, a boutique yoga studio welcoming all walks of life and supporting many paths of yoga, has received its green|light certification. green|light focuses on locally-owned ... (click for more)

The Department of Revenue is offering Tennesseans the ability to apply for a personalized license plate online, rather than through a paper application. The online application, available at ... (click for more)


Business

Allie Weiss Named As Baker Donelson's Pro Bono Committee Office Chairwoman For Chattanooga

Baker Donelson has appointed Allie Weiss to serve as Pro Bono Committee Office chairwoman for the firm's Chattanooga office. As the Chattanooga Pro Bono Committee Office Chair, Ms. Weiss will work to identify and address local pro bono needs while coordinating with Baker Donelson Pro Bono Shareholder Samuel T. Bowman for global pro bono initiatives. "Meeting the specific ... (click for more)

Yoga Landing Celebrates green|light Certification With Exemplary Green Business Practices

Yoga Landing on East Broad Street, a boutique yoga studio welcoming all walks of life and supporting many paths of yoga, has received its green|light certification. green|light focuses on locally-owned small to large organizations throughout Chattanooga and the surrounding area who are interested in improving their social and environmental impacts. The program is an independently-verified ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Tivoli Theatre Foundation Acquires Tivoli Center Building Next Door To Tivoli Theatre

The Tivoli Theatre Foundation has purchased the property adjacent to the Theatre and plans to continue the restoration of the venue as well as renovating the new property., officials said. The investment will include the creation of a performing arts center for Chattanooga. “Since its inception, the Tivoli Foundation has reinvigorated the performance arts venues in Chattanooga,” ... (click for more)

Lookout Mountain, Ga., Council Chooses Builder For Town Center; To Issue RFP For Commercial Portion; Trail Named For Super Volunteer Campbell

The Lookout Mountain, Ga., Town Council on Thursday night selected a builder for the long-awaited Town Center and also moved to issue an RFP for a developer for the planned commercial part of the center. Mayor David Bennett, saying next year will be a banner one for the town, said the Town Center, 12 years in the making, is on schedule to be built during the year. Ground breaking ... (click for more)

Opinion

Abuse To Animals Is Intolerable

In a recent article titled “McKamey Animal Services Seeks Information Pertaining to Dog Fight Victim”, McKamey Animal Center is urging people to share any information regarding a recent dog fight victim that was left abandoned with multiple serious injuries. Abuse to animals is something that I cannot tolerate in the slightest. My heart goes out to the precious little dog that ... (click for more)

Sister Says Leg Surgery For Roy Exum Is A Success

The leg surgery for Roy Exum on Friday afternoon was a success, his sister, Ellen, said she was told by the physician. Mr. Exum, the long-time columnist in this spot for Chattanoogan.com, has suffered for a lengthy time with a badly infected leg following surgery on an arthritic knee. He was told this week that the leg was so damaged that it would have to be amputated or risk ... (click for more)