Reappraisal Equals Redistribution Of Wealth

Monday, February 17, 2020

Here’s a simple and accurate explanation of the Hamilton County property reappraisal results.

Picture three adjacent property owners–you and your two next door neighbors. One neighbor to your left, one to your right, and you in the middle. Imagine that the county assessor gives one of your neighbors a tax break. That’s easy enough, just by juggling the new appraisals.

Now, the reappraisal is required by state law, and it must be ‘revenue neutral’–the total amount of property tax collected after reappraisal must be the same as it was before. (Yes, it could be manipulated to produce less tax revenue than before, but we know that’s not gonna happen.)

So in the very personal case of you and your two neighbors, if one of them gets a tax cut then you and the other neighbor have to make up the difference. Either you, or the other neighbor, or both of you have to pay more taxes now because one neighbor will be paying less than before.

On a larger scale, for the entire county, half of the taxpayers got a break this year. And the other half must pay for that break. You and your neighbors may all pay less this year, at someone else’s expense. Or all three of you may have to pay for the windfalls that others got. But whenever one property owner benefits, others will get a larger tax bill to cover it.

Think about it. The people who work for the county assessor have absolute, unilateral, arbitrary and irresistible legal power to take money from one property owner and give it to another. It is the government version of robbing Peter to pay Paul. The county never loses, and Paul never complains.

In real terms, the latest reappraisal took money away from half of Hamilton County property owners and gave that same money to the other half of them. Even if your taxes only went up $10, that $10 was taken from you by law and given to someone else as a gift. If that isn’t a redistribution of wealth, what is it? Even if it’s legal, it’s still wrong.

Here’s an example straight from county records online: One fortunate property owner received a new appraisal of $469,500 – only $1,600 more than last year – while many others got appraisal increases of tens of thousands. The immediate effect for that one taxpayer is a $300 reduction in his county property tax this year. But the rest of us have to make up for the $300 he’s saving, and for thousands of other similar cases as well.

Oh – guess which lucky property owner is directly associated with the assessor’s office?

Think about it! Half of us should be legitimately (although helplessly) angry, while the other half just smile all the way to the bank with our money.

It’s not right!

Larry Cloud


Roy Exum: My Garden This April

Roy Exum: What Is ‘Essential’?

Roy Exum: More Suicides Than Virus


The lush green of the trees and the bushes, the beautiful birds so full of song, my rose bush coming alive, and the fact that today it is not raining cannot dull my heavy heart as I stay in prayer ... (click for more)

There is no question that Tennessee Governor Bill Lee’s order to close all non-essential businesses in the state on Monday will inconvenience all of us, but what is being inconvenienced in the ... (click for more)

In a week where six Tennesseans died of the coronavirus, it is disheartening indeed to learn more people in our state died of suicide last week. While the actual number of those who took their ... (click for more)




Opinion

Roy Exum: My Garden This April

The lush green of the trees and the bushes, the beautiful birds so full of song, my rose bush coming alive, and the fact that today it is not raining cannot dull my heavy heart as I stay in prayer for all of us in the midst of our world’s pandemic. Already there is no one who hasn’t been affected in some way by the fiercest storm any of us have ever known, and already I know we ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What Is ‘Essential’?

There is no question that Tennessee Governor Bill Lee’s order to close all non-essential businesses in the state on Monday will inconvenience all of us, but what is being inconvenienced in the face of deterring a coronavirus that could cost many Tennesseans their lives? I wish the governor had done so sooner but hardly blame him for exhibiting another great Tennessean's motto: Davy ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Child Under 5 Dies From Coronavirus At Chattanooga Hospital; Tennessee Death Toll Reaches 24; Bradley County Up To 14 Cases

A child under five has died of coronavirus in a Chattanooga hospital, county officials said Wednesday. Becky Barnes, Health Department administrator, said the child had underlying illnesses. “It is our deepest regret to share with you today our first COVID-19-related pediatric death,” said Ms. Barnes, “As we mourn with the family, we also take this opportunity to urgently ... (click for more)

Georgia Increases From 125 To 154 Coronavirus Deaths; Cases Go From 4,117 To 4,748; Walker County Has 2nd Case

Georgia state health officials said Wednesday that 154 people in the state have died of the coronavirus - up from 125 the day before. The cases have spiraled to 4,748 - up from the Tuesday report of 4,117. Officials said 1,013 have been hospitalized in Georgia with the deadly virus. Whitfield County is up to 14 cases with one death. Walker County, which long resisted ... (click for more)

Sports

Noted Chattanooga Golfer, Operator Of Moccasin Bend Golf Course Wes Brown Dies At 91

Noted golfer and longtime operator of the Moccasin Bend Golf Course Wesley G. Brown Sr. has died at 91. Born in Chattanooga on September 11, 1929, to Mr. and Mrs. Edward E. Brown, Sr., he attended Normal Park Elementary and McCallie School, as a standout athlete and leader. At Washington Lee University, he was captain of the golf team and played defensive back on the football ... (click for more)

Wildcats' Rhyne Howard One Of Five Wooden All-Americans

LEXINGTON, Ky. – For the third time this postseason, University of Kentucky women’s basketball sophomore guard Rhyne Howard has been tabbed a first-team All-America selection as the Wooden Award named the star to its All-America team Wednesday night live on ESPN’s SportsCenter. In March, Howard was named one of 15 players nationally to the Wooden Award National Ballot ... (click for more)