Hagerty vs. Sethi - Who To Vote For?

Friday, July 10, 2020
Once again election season is upon us.  While America is already deeply divided between blue and red, democrats and republicans, Trump and non-Trumpers, these various factions are finding themselves even further divided as they squabble over who to vote for in the upcoming the primaries. 

As has been the case for more than a decade, I’ve been getting asked about who I might recommend in some of the races.  In the past, I tended to have strong opinions about who was the “better” or “right” candidate and I was never hesitant to share when asked.  This year is different, for a number of reasons.  But that’s for a separate and upcoming post.

In Tennessee there are a couple men who are running to replace Senator Lamar Alexander:  Bill Hagerty and Manni Sethi.  I have many good friends who are staunch Hagerty supporters.
And perhaps an equal number of vocal supporters for Sethi.  There are no doubt points that each group of supporters could make to elevate their guy and throw stones at his opponent.  

When I see people do this though, I’m completely turned off.  So many politicians, and their supporters as well, act as if the only way to win is to trash not only the other guy, but they also must lob bombs at the supporters of the guy as well.  We’ve all heard the saying that we should disagree without being disagreeable.  If there was a time when we need to show mercy and grace to others, it’s today.

In most primaries, while the candidates may attempt to illustrate the differences between themselves, at the end of the day, when they go to Washington, it’s unlikely they will vote that much differently from each other, particularly these days.  As the battle lines have drawn deeper and deeper in our nation, and between democrats and republicans, we have seen that both parties more often than not vote as a bloc.  It’s as if there is little to no individuality.  

Washington is basically just two big machines.  A blue one.  And a red one.  And those machines gobble up the members of their party, demanding absolute fidelity.  

So, if you are listening to the policy differences of Hagerty and Sethi, it’s unlikely anything they say will matter, since the party will ultimately dictate how they vote.  I know even as I write this that many will want to take issue with my perspective here.  And if so, that’s fine.  This is the conclusion I have come to after a couple of decades of political activism and engagement.  Of course there are exceptions, but as a rule, this is the case.  

So, if you’re asking me who you should vote for, Hagerty or Sethi, my answer may surprise you.  I have personal feelings about both men, and have found myself leaning in one direction.  But at the end of the day, and after much study and writing on the topic of voting, there is a greater principle at play than simply who I will vote for.  While you and I may vote for a candidate, there is a greater Power who holds the final sway in who will win.  Yes, God ultimately will determine who will win, since His Word is clear in passage after passage, and story and story, that God:

“... controls the course of world events; he removes kings and sets up other kings.” Daniel 2:21

Interestingly enough, Jesus affirmed this same principle moments before His crucifixion when He declared to Pilate, the appointed Roman ruler, that:

“You would have no power over me at all unless it were given to you from above.” John 19:11

Notice that Jesus said that Pilate’s power, his position, was not given to him by Rome, but rather from above.  So likewise, while you may think that your vote is effectively electing the next Senator of Tennessee, there is a greater One who holds sway over the outcome.  While you and I may not fully understand this concept, it is true nonetheless.  

So you may ask, then what’s the use in voting if God’s going to decide?  I believe there are several reasons we should vote, which I intend to answer before the November election via a separate article. But one reason is simply because we are called to be stewards of the resources God gives us.  So when you vote, it’s not about electing someone, but it’s about honoring God and trusting Him with the outcome.  Truthfully, if you fully understand and embrace this Truth, it will totally free and transform your mind, and you’ll no longer fret over the outcome of an election. 

So vote your conscience.  Vote for the guy you feel led to.  But respect the other guy who will vote for your guy’s opponent.  And don’t sweat the outcome.  There’s Someone who can see the heart of both men, He knows the end from the beginning, and every day in between, and He knows the right guy to elevate at this time.  Trust Him, even when you may not understand, or agree, with Him.

Live Free... vote free 

Mark West

The Trump 2020 Election

God Is Giving Us A Little Space To Cry Out To Him

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies


For the last few days, I have felt like I had been kicked in the stomach. After I got over that, I realized that this election is not over. It has just begun. Donald Trump didn't get to be a ... (click for more)

“Then they cried unto the Lord in their trouble, and he saved them out of their distresses.” –Psalm 107:13 This election is not over. But it holds disaster for the good and decent people of ... (click for more)

A wonderful group of loyalists to The Saturday Funnies sent a covey of wonderful jokes during a week when the most convoluted election in our nation’s history leaves all of us in need of something ... (click for more)



Opinion

The Trump 2020 Election

For the last few days, I have felt like I had been kicked in the stomach. After I got over that, I realized that this election is not over. It has just begun. Donald Trump didn't get to be a billionaire, being stupid. He has done more for this country than any President in my lifetime and I am 68 years old. Do you remember the phrase we used to yell out at our playmates, "cheaters ... (click for more)

God Is Giving Us A Little Space To Cry Out To Him

“Then they cried unto the Lord in their trouble, and he saved them out of their distresses.” –Psalm 107:13 This election is not over. But it holds disaster for the good and decent people of our nation. The army that is arrayed against President Trump’s re-election is great--too great for man’s solution. I do not see any hope but for God to give Donald Trump re-election. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Woman In Critical Condition After Being Shot Early Sunday Morning At Extended Stay Near Airport

A woman is in critical condition after being shot early Sunday morning in the vicinity of the Chattanooga Airport. It happened around 6:30 a.m. at an extended stay at 6240 Airpark Dr. Police said the woman has life-threatening injuries. . (click for more)

Tennessee Has Over 5,000 New COVID Cases; Hamilton County Has 3 More Deaths

Tennessee had 5,071 new coronavirus cases on Saturday, bringing the total to 378,215, state Health Department officials said. There were 49 new deaths from the virus, including three in Hamilton County. The new totals are 3,590 in the state and 117 in Hamilton County. Hamilton County has 136 new cases, compared to 161 on Friday, bringing the total to 13,510. The state currently ... (click for more)

Sports

Vols Lose 4th Straight As Arkansas Has Big 3rd Quarter

The reeling Tennessee Vols lost their fourth straight in Fayetteville, Ark., on Saturday night. Arkansas had a big third quarter to win 24-13. Tennessee, playing Arkansas for the first time since 2015, scored a field goal in the first quarter and a TD and field goal in the second to lead 13-0 at halftime. The field goal came on the opening drive with Brent Cimaglia nailing ... (click for more)

Crowd At Tennessee Basketball To Be Capped At 4,000

To align with state and local social-distancing guidelines for public gatherings, Tennessee Athletics has finalized its adjusted seating model for the 2020-21 basketball season at Thompson-Boling Arena. Pending the status of the pandemic, our hope is that this plan is only required for one season and that Thompson-Boling Arena can return to its traditional seating model next year. ... (click for more)