The High Cost Of The Unnecessary County District Expansion

Tuesday, December 7, 2021

The cost of redistricting to 11 County Commission seats, and potentially 11 school board members, should have been disclosed to the public prior to approval.  Now that the redistricting plan is approved, the public is learning about the real costs. The redistricting plan for Hamilton County turned out to be much more costly than the public was aware of, and, to add insult to injury, here comes state Senator Todd Gardenhire to enrich the political class with even more taxpayer cash.

 

Isn’t that fun, the political class giving the political class a big fat raise. 

 

On Nov.

2 of this year, the Hamilton County Commission voted in majority to increase the number of elected district representatives from 9 to 11, adding two additional elected county representatives.  The basis used by the county commissioners was the census data that cites the county has increased in population.  Historical census data for Hamilton County shows that nine districts have been adequate for many decades, with similar growth.  I realize that new population does not occur uniformly across districts, so adjustments in the existing district boundaries would have been required, but not sweeping growth in the political class.

 

Y’all, there is no real basis to grow the number of districts and the political class.

 

1970      254,236                              6.9%

1980      287,740                              13.2%

1990      285,536                              -0.8%

2000      307,896                              7.8%

2010      336,463                              9.3%

2020      366,207                              8.8%

 

A redistricting measure this substantial and sweeping should have been by referendum; let the voters decide.  Only after the redistricting plan passes do we learn the actual costs of adding two new districts to Hamilton County.  You can bet the school board will follow eventually and add two new school board seats, as well.

 

The cost of growing a larger political class in Hamilton County is not limited to the salary. I remember a time when elected service was actually service without a salary of  $2,100 a month, plus, health insurance, retirement, and a host of other perks.  Elected service is now a heavily compensated part time job. The cost of health insurance and retirement benefits is significant, and for estimation let's assume 35 percent of salary, which I believe to be low given health insurance costs.

 

2 New County Commissioners

$25,394 X 2 New Commissioners = $50,788

Benefits Est $50,788 X 1.35 = $68,564

 

2 New School Board Members

$12,365 X 2 New School Board Members = $24,730

Benefits Est $24,730 X 1.35 = $33,386

 

But wait, Senator Gardenhire is sponsoring a bill to double the school board members' pay. So, assuming the Gardenhire bill passes, the taxpayers will incur additional costs that will potentially be $68,564 X 2 = $137,128.  Yep, $137,128 more cost to the taxpayers, providing about $2,100 in direct pay a month to the elected to work part time.

 

Then, another cost associated with the 11-district plan raised its head this month. It is assumed that each new district will require new precincts, plus additional sites for early voting.  What is that cost?  It is somewhat unclear, although the Election Commission sought additional funds of $259,000 for three new early voting sites.  It is believed that the new districts will require additional resources from the Election Commission. 

 

What is the cost to the Election Commission for two additional county districts?  Does anyone know?

 

If Gardenhire’s bill to double school board compensation passes, the cost of the 11 redistricting will be:

 

2 New Commission Seats= $68,564                       

2 New School Board Seats = $68,564

New Precincts Election Commission = Unknown at this time

 

We can see what the bill costs after the bill is passed.  I believe that all associated expenses from the 11 redistricting plan should have been disclosed prior to adoption.

 

As County Commissioner Warren Mackey has pointed out, "It does demand some answer in the sense - did we grow government just now?"

 

Yes, Commissioner Mackey, the Republicans on the County Commission grew government. 

 

In closing, the 11-district plan is a farce, as nine districts have been doable in similar historic growth. 

 

April Eidson


How Pelosi’s Visit Proves Everyone Has A Stake In The US-Taiwan Partnership

Honoring Claude Ramsey And Dalton Roberts Is Long Overdue

Is Chattanooga Running Out Of Ideas?


Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s decision to go to Taiwan wasn’t crazy or foolish. There’s a reason that 26 Republican senators reached across the aisle to show support for someone long-considered their ... (click for more)

I am so grateful that County Attorney Rheubin Taylor and others are honoring our former County Mayors Claude Ramsey and Dalton Roberts. It goes without saying that this is long overdue. I have ... (click for more)

It seems every time we need an anchor for a new area added to the RiverCity footprint, we move a stadium. Is Chattanooga running out of ideas? The baffling unanimity of the city council on the ... (click for more)



Opinion

How Pelosi’s Visit Proves Everyone Has A Stake In The US-Taiwan Partnership

Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s decision to go to Taiwan wasn’t crazy or foolish. There’s a reason that 26 Republican senators reached across the aisle to show support for someone long-considered their political adversary. Pelosi’s visit highlights that it’s more than just principles on the line--it’s the entire global order. Pelosi stated there were three main pillars to this US-Taiwan ... (click for more)

Honoring Claude Ramsey And Dalton Roberts Is Long Overdue

I am so grateful that County Attorney Rheubin Taylor and others are honoring our former County Mayors Claude Ramsey and Dalton Roberts. It goes without saying that this is long overdue. I have seen the Bredesen-Ramsey interchange near Volkswagen Drive, but Claude certainly deserves additional recognition for his contributions to our county. As for Dalton, I have pushed for years ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Couple Shot In Hixson As They Lay In Bed Early Thursday Morning

Chattanooga Police said two people were shot early Thursday morning as they lay in bed at their residence in Hixson. At 1:30 a.m., Chattanooga Police responded to a shooting at 4900 Lavender Trail. Police were advised that two people suffering from non-life threatening injuries had driven themselves to a local hospital for treatment. They were a man 22 and a woman 26. ... (click for more)

Biden Administration Announces $25 Million for Wilcox Bridge, $14.6 Milllion To Dunlap For Highway 127 Intersection Improvement

U.S. Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg on Thursday announced that the Biden-Harris Administration has awarded $63 million to support three projects in Tennessee from the Rebuilding American Infrastructure with Sustainability and Equity (RAISE) program to help move forward on projects that modernize roads, bridges, transit, rail, ports, and intermodal transportation and ... (click for more)

Sports

WindStone Chosen As Host Site For 2022 National Car Rental PGA Jr. League Regional

Twelve golf facilities across the nation, including WindStone in Ringgold, Ga., have been named host sites for the 2022 National Car Rental PGA Jr. League Regionals taking place in September. Nearly 200 teams of junior golfers ages 10-17 will enjoy two days of competition. Through PGA Jr. League, kids ages 17 and under learn and play golf on co-ed teams, wear numbered jerseys ... (click for more)

UTC Football Fall Practice Preview

Palpable excitement filled the air this past Tuesday evening at Finley Stadium. As players in various states of undress poured out from a pair of school buses and into the locker room, equipment managers and assistant coaches scurried to set up equipment. The hits of Drake, Future, and other rap stars began to play from the stadium’s loudspeakers as players, now uniformly outfitted ... (click for more)