Tennessee Supreme Court Clarifies Meaning Of “Illegal Sentence” Under Tennessee Rule Of Criminal Procedure 36.1

Friday, March 26, 2021
The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled today that a sentence imposed in accordance with a statute that is later declared unconstitutional is voidable, not illegal, within the meaning of Tennessee Rule of Criminal Procedure 36.1.

Tennessee Rule of Criminal Procedure 36.1 allows the defendant or the state to file a motion to correct an illegal sentence. The Rule defines illegal sentences as those that are not authorized by law or that directly conflict with the law. Illegal sentences can be challenged at any time through several legal avenues.
In contrast, sentences that are voidable were facially valid at the time they were imposed and may be challenged through the post-conviction process, which has a set time limit. 

In the case on appeal, the petitioner pleaded guilty to possession of cocaine with the intent to sell and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon. The firearm offense was enhanced from a Class C felony to a Class B felony pursuant to the criminal gang enhancement statute. A year after the petitioner pleaded guilty, the Court of Criminal Appeals declared the criminal gang enhancement statute unconstitutional. 

Nearly three years following the intermediate appellate court’s decision, the petitioner filed a motion to correct an illegal sentence in the trial court, arguing that the appellate court’s decision rendered his sentence illegal. The trial court denied the motion, but the Court of Criminal Appeals reversed, holding that its earlier decision declaring the enhancement statute unconstitutional rendered the petitioner’s sentence void and illegal under Rule 36.1.

In a unanimous opinion, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals and reinstated the trial court’s order denying the petitioner’s motion, holding that the petitioner’s sentence was voidable, not void and illegal within the meaning of Rule 36.1. The Court reasoned that, at the time the petitioner’s sentence was imposed, the criminal gang enhancement statute was presumptively constitutional. His sentence was authorized by law and did not directly conflict with the law. The Court additionally reaffirmed its prior holding enunciated its 1999 decision in Taylor v. State, which explicitly states that a sentence imposed in accordance with a statute in effect at the time of its imposition is not void merely because the statute is later declared unconstitutional. Instead, such a sentence is voidable. Because the petitioner’s sentence was voidable and not illegal, the Court held that the proper method for challenging his sentence was through a timely petition for post-conviction relief, not a motion to correct an illegal sentence.

The unanimous opinion in State v. Reid, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, may be read by visiting the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

Cody Sims: Why The Sudden Interest In Inflation?

City Of Dalton Begins Search For Recreation Department Director

Kairos Power And TVA To Collaborate On Low-Power Demonstration Reactor


You may have noticed that the topic of inflation is getting more attention. Those who were around in the 1970s likely still remember when rapid rises in the cost-of-living were of great concern. ... (click for more)

The City of Dalton’s Recreation Commission officially gave the green light to begin a search for a new director for the Parks and Recreation Department at its May 6th meeting. The commission ... (click for more)

The Tennessee Valley Authority and Kairos Power have announced plans to collaborate on deploying a low-power demonstration reactor at the East Tennessee Technology Park in Oak Ridge, Tennessee. ... (click for more)



Business

Cody Sims: Why The Sudden Interest In Inflation?

You may have noticed that the topic of inflation is getting more attention. Those who were around in the 1970s likely still remember when rapid rises in the cost-of-living were of great concern. But for those who are younger, the concept of an extended period of high inflation may seem strange to you as you have never experienced it. The conventional wisdom is that during periods ... (click for more)

City Of Dalton Begins Search For Recreation Department Director

The City of Dalton’s Recreation Commission officially gave the green light to begin a search for a new director for the Parks and Recreation Department at its May 6th meeting. The commission is comprised of community leaders and oversees the operations of the department. “This is a great opportunity,” said Recreation Commission Chairman Zab Mendez, noting that the department’s ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Parade And Luncheon Highlight Armed Forces Celebration

Sunny skies and perfect weather made for a crowd friendly 72nd annual Armed Forces Parade down Market Street Friday morning – although it was briefer and with fewer marching bands than in years past. And a bright future was predicted as well for America’s security by the Armed Forces celebration luncheon speaker, Congressman Mark Green of Tennessee, despite the admitted challenges ... (click for more)

Man, 39, Dies In Single-Vehicle Wreck On Germantown Road

A 39-year-old man died in a single-vehicle wreck in Brainerd on Friday morning. At approximately 11:25 a.m., the Chattanooga Police Traffic Division responded to a crash at 600 North Germantown Road. It was found that a Lexus R33 was traveling north on South Germantown Road near the intersection of Menlo Street when it failed to negotiate the curve and went off the roadway ... (click for more)

Opinion

Ron Swafford Has Had An Outstanding Career

It has been a pleasure working with Ron Swafford in City Court. Ron has done a great job and has had an outstanding career. During the pandemic Ron and his staff worked tirelessly and courageously to keep the wheels on, even while in court proceedings were cancelled. During our working relations, Ron and I have become good friends. He is a good man with a fine family. I ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

The best giggle came this week when Texas A&M football coach Jimbo Fisher – feeling his oats -- told a bunch of Aggie boosters he promised he would beat Nick Saban while Nick was still coaching football at Alabama. The media wags could hardly wait for Saban’s reaction and his calm two-word reply was so classic it is still being chiseled in granite somewhere: “In golf?” This ... (click for more)