Opinion


Roy Exum: The Way It Works

Wednesday, September 02, 2009 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

A 60-year-old man who lives in Antioch, which is actually in south Nashville, arrived home about 9:30 p.m. Saturday night and, as he talked to a friend in his car, two younger men approached the automobile where they sat. One, who is 17, had a handgun in his hand while another, age 19, stood nearby with a shotgun.

There is no doubt they intended to rob the driver of the car, but the 60-year-old immediately drew his own 38-caliber handgun and shot his 17-year-old assailant in a clear act of self-defense. The younger teenager was shot in the chest, but ran in terror.

The older would-be robber, who we have since learned was Kevin Negron, grabbed the wounded kid and they roared away in Negron’s car, going to a nearby convenience store to request assistance after saying they had just been the victims of a crime.

But the 60-year-old shooter had already called police and, with a witness present, told the officers what had really happened. He showed the police his valid “handgun carry permit,” which has since been credited for saving the older man’s life, and while he expressed remorse for shooting anyone, it was offset by the fact he wasn’t shot himself.

It is pretty obvious the 60-year-old never intended to actually shoot anyone when he obtained his “handgun carry permit.” It is also a safe bet that the incident still ruined the older man’s evening, but the fact is that he was able to successfully defend himself. That is what a handgun permit is designed to do. That is the way it works.

It turns out the 19-year-old who was holding the shotgun was already on parole for an April felony where he evaded arrest. His history also includes theft and domestic assault charges. Further, he admitted his role in the botched robbery minutes after the 17-year-old was said to be in satisfactory condition and awaiting charges, which will be filed in Davidson County Juvenile Court. (Did you get that – Juvenile Court?)

Now that’s a crummy story, something that shouldn’t happen to anybody, but the fact is it did occur and, because the intended victim had a “handgun carry permit,” the would-be robbers, who neither had permits to carry a weapon, will wind up going to jail. That is also why so many Tennesseans are now legally and lawfully carrying handguns in an effort to avoid being a victim.

Some years ago the notion that two teenagers, duly armed, would accost an older man in Antioch would have been preposterous. Last weekend it happened. And people who don’t believe the values and morals of some of our young people are being eroded are not looking where they should.

Not long ago I asked Chattanooga Police Chief Freeman Cooper if “responsible guns” that are now being carried by licensed Tennesseans pose a threat to the officers under his command and he quickly shook his head, “People who get the proper credentials are not a problem.

“Where we have our biggest headache is with guns that are illegal. We desperately need anyone who finds a weapon to turn it in to a police officer. We’ll come get the guns and take either pistols or rifles off the streets. But when those firearms wind up in ‘bad hands,’ that’s a big problem for our community as well as society at large.”

According to another story in Nashville yesterday, about 70 cities are opting away from a new law that allows firearms to be carried in parks by those who have the permits to do so. Some objectors would lead you to believe it will lead to constant shootings, but that is hardly the reason the law was created – the “bad guys” bring their weapons anyway, in much the same fashion the two Nashville teenagers did last weekend.

Yes, handguns are a huge problem, but trying to legislate against weapons has never worked. What we must do is act strongly and forcefully against criminals – despite the age or social background – to show the use of guns brings a new dimension to any misdeed and will be punished harshly.

Incidentally, two or three years added to the sentence is nothing compared to being shot in the chest.

Good people have the right to defend themselves, to protect their families and to live without fear. Say what you will, but that’s better than reading where some 60-year-old from south Nashville is dead because he didn’t have any other choice.

royexum@aol.com


Roy Exum: Susan Komen’s New Shiner

Abraham Lincoln, in a speech he once made, predicted that if America would ever fall, it would be from an enemy within. What he actually said was, “ … if (peril) ever reach us, it must spring up amongst us. It cannot come from abroad. If destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher,” but you still get the idea. That quote is all I have thought of this ... (click for more)

Look At Your Neighbors To See The Real Economic Effect

Today Obama tells the Congress to not get in his way of improving the economy.    His policies have given us a robust 8.3 percent unemployment rate.   Wow.   You have to wonder how good the number if it is improving so much how can the number of children living in poverty keep going up every year?    If the economy is great, why ... (click for more)

$750,000 Settlement Reached In Case In Which Bicyclist Was Hit By Tahoe

A $750,000 settlement has been reached in Hamilton County Circuit Court in a case in which a bicyclist was struck by a Chevrolet Tahoe and seriously injured. Sean Sanderson and his wife, Dr. Stephanie Sanderson, of Cleveland, Tn.,had filed suit against Benjamin Wilson and Oscar Wilson. At the time of the wreck, Mr. Sanderson was riding a Trek bicycle on Ooltewah-Georgetown ... (click for more)

Rep. McCormick Says Legislature May Act To Give Physicians More Say-So At Erlanger

Rep. Gerald McCormick said the Legislature may take action this session to give physicians more say-so at Erlanger Hospital. The House majority leader from Hixson said, "With the recent financial losses at Erlanger, there is a desire on the part of the medical community to have more of a role at the hospital and to have more board representation." The Hospital Authority Board ... (click for more)

Christian Brothers Tops Baylor in State Duals

While Soddy Daisy rolled into the D-I AAA semis (Saturday at 1 p.m. and Chattanooga Central won twice to make the D-I A-AA finals (Sat. 7 p.m.), it was Christian Brothers in D-II who stole the spotlight at the 25th annual TSSAA state wrestling duals and hope to make the third times the charm come true in Saturday nights final. The Purple Wave held off a Baylor ... (click for more)

Central Advances, Hixson Falls In State Duals Semifinals

FRANKLIN -- The defending A-AA champion Central Purple Pounders cruised to the championship finals of the State Duals wrestling tournament here at the Williamson County Ag Expo Center Friday night, but the Hixson Wildcats weren't so fortunate. Central may have been the most impressive team in any classification as they lost just one match total while waltzing past Page 78-3 in ... (click for more)