Federal Jury In Chattanooga Awards $22.26 Million In Malpractice Case

Saturday, March 13, 2010

A federal jury in Chattanooga has awarded a couple from Franklin, Tn., $22,266,261.31 in a medical malpractice case.

The verdict was in favor of Ben and Bette Donathan.

Mrs. Donathan, 62, was left paralyzed from the waist down after problems developed during surgery for a broken leg.

The jury awarded $19,266,261.31 in favor of Mrs. Donathan against Delores K. White, D.O., Ronald Gordon, M.D., Christopher A. Will, C.R.N.A. and Cumberland Healthcare Group.

It awarded Mr. Donathan $3 million against the same defendants.

The suit was filed in April 2007.

Judge Sandy Mattice presided over the trial.

The couple was represented by the Nashville law firm of Kinnard, Clayton & Beveridge.


State Board of Education Reduces Penalties For 5 Signal Mountain Educators

The State Board of Education has agreed to reduce penalties against five Signal Mountain High School educators after county school officials met last Friday with state officials and provided additional information. The state initially flagged the contracts of guidance counselors Dr. LeAnn Welch, Dr. Anne Cushing and Leslie Sharpe, assistant principal Jason McKinney and boys ... (click for more)

Petition Drive Started To Rescind Suspension Of Principal Tom McCullough

An online petition drive has been launched to ask county school officials to rescind the decision of Supt. Rick Smith to suspend Signal Mountain High School Principal Tom McCullough for the remainder of the school year. By Wednesday afternoon, there were 186 signing on, including many with ties to Signal Mountain High/Middle. Dr. McCullough is retiring at the end of this year. ... (click for more)

Debates Don't Decide Leadership Ability

I've watched how some in the media have attacked Scottie Mayfield for not debating. I've never been to a debate, and I am not going to vote for someone because they are able to remember and recite from memory, the well crafted answers they came up with the night before.   Often times, candidates focus on attacking each other instead of influencing undecided voters on any ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Two Horse Owners Write

As Jackie McConnell was being told he now faces up to five years in prison and a multitude of other penalties after pleading guilty to just one of 48 counts in violation of the Horse Protection Act on Tuesday, the outcry from Tennessee Walking Horse owners was incredible and there is a groundswell of support growing to either clean up a very crooked industry or actually ban it. ... (click for more)

Reynolds, Nunley Power Soddy-Daisy Into Winners Bracket Final

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. -- While reporters and players were mingling after Soddy-Daisy's state softball victory Wednesday over Munford, Lady Trojan assistant coach Lamar Lasley came through with a classic one-liner. "Dont' anybody touch Haley Reynolds because she is on fire,'' Lasley said. And he was so right. Reynolds, a sophomore first-baseman, was 4-for-4 as Soddy-Daisy ... (click for more)

Notre Dame - State Tennis Champs

MURFREESBORO - 5/23/12 --In the 1950s and 60s, the Irish leprechaun danced across the parquet floor of old Boston Garden as legends Russell, Cousy, Havlicek, Heinsohn and the Jones duo won world titles. Today the leprechaun came South to dance across the hard courts at Old Fort Park as young ladies - Dorris, Voges, McIntyre, Ross and  the Joyce sisters - ... (click for more)