MTAS Attorney Says He Overlooked Section In His Recall Opinion

Friday, September 3, 2010

An attorney for the Municipal Technical Assistance Service (MTAS) who earlier said state law trumps the city of Chattanooga charter on recall matters ackownledged he overlooked a key factor in his decision.

Sidney Hemsley, senior law consultant, said in a letter today to election office attorney Chris Clem, "I do agree that the re-enactment of the city of Chattanooga charter after July 1, 1997, satisfies the 'contrary charter provision' requirement contained in TCA 2-5-151 with respect to the number of signatures required on the recall petition."

Attorney Hemley, in an earlier eight-page opinion, said those carrying out the recall in Chattanooga needed to follow the more stringent state law.

That would have required them to collect 15 percent of the signatures of registered voters instead of the city's standard of at least 50 percent of those who voted for mayor in the last general election. It would have meant about 15,000 names in the recall of Mayor Ron Littlefield as opposed to fewer than 9,000 under the city charter.

The opinion was requested by Council Chairman Manny Rico, who is one of the recall targets.

Attorney Hemsley also said in the letter to attorney Clem, "I relied on the historical citations contained at the end of the recall provision in Section 3.18 of the Chattanooga city charter without further ensuring that there had been no re-enactments of that charter since 1997, a mistake worse in view of the fact that I had the Chattanooga Municipal Code in front of me, which contained the charter and information regarding updates to the charter since Brown v. Board of Commissioners, a case with which I was already familiar.

"I apologize for any consternation my opinion caused to the government and people of Chattanooga and the Hamilton County Election Commission with respect to the mathematical requirements for the recall petition, and I do appreciate your calling the charter re-enactment to my attention."


Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ABERNATHY, COREY CORTEZ  2422 SHADY LN CHATTANOOGA, 37406  Age at Arrest: 38 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga BURGLARY (GENERAL CATEGORY) RESISTING ARREST OR OBSTRUCTION OF LEGAL PROCESS --- BENFIELD, MARY KANDIZA  246 HENDERSON ROAD EVANSVILLE, 37332  Age at Arrest: 39 years ... (click for more)

Demetrius Buchanan, 20, Shot Tuesday Evening

The Chattanooga Police Department is   investigating a shooting near 2101 McCallie Ave. Demetrius Buchanan, 20,  arrived at a local hospital via personal vehicle suffering from a single non-life-threatening injury. Officers and Investigators are working to determine the facts surrounding the incident.  No suspect information is available at this time. (click for more)

On The News Tonight: A Reflection On A Horrifying Crash And Its Aftermath

On the news tonight,  on the news tonight. The unobtrusive tones on the news tonight. It's just make-believe You can't believe everything you see So baby, close your eyes to the lullabies On the news tonight.   "The News" by Jack Johnson On Journalism On Thursday I was in Jackson, Tennessee playing music. I was a minimum of four hours away ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: My Garden This July

As the month of July dawns this morning, a walk through my garden shows some flowers blooming, my marigolds dying, and the grass is greener than I thought it would be. But as I look for what’s good and what’s bad, let’s remember that some firecrackers pop while others fizzle. Here we go… A BANG to career criminal Whitely Bulger, the 85-year-old master criminal who in a recent ... (click for more)

Ooltewah Stays In Blue Following Win Over Fairyland

The Fairyland Flash may not have the best team in the Chattanooga Area Swim League this summer, but there’s no doubt they have the most scenic and picturesque view of any team in the Tennessee Valley. The Flash swam their final dual meet of the season on Tuesday night, a makeup meet with the Ooltewah Tidal Waves.   Both teams entered the meet with one win apiece, meaning ... (click for more)

Madison Hayes To Compete In National Pitch, Hit and Run Compitition

    Ooltewah's Madison Hayes is one of 24 national finalists for the 2015 Major League Baseball Pitch, Hit & Run program presented by Scotts, the official youth skills competition of Major League Baseball, were announced Monday live on MLB  Tonight  on MLB Network. These 24 boys and girls will compete at the National Finals and participate in ... (click for more)