Federal Judge Dismisses Lawsuit In Police Shooting Of Alonzo Heyward

Collier Says Officers Did Not Violate Constitutional Rights Through Use Of Excessive Force

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Federal Judge Curtis Collier has dismissed a lawsuit brought by the family of a rifle-wielding man who was shot on July 18, 2009, by six city police officers.

Alonzo Heyward had 43 bullet wounds, but Judge Collier said he refused to comply with commands to stop and give up the gun, he started to walk in a house with the weapon, and he turned the rifle toward the officers after he was tased.

Judge Collier said, "Because a reasonable fact-finder, viewing the facts in the light most favorable to plaintiffs, could not find the officers violated Heyward's constitutional rights through excessive use of force, it is unnecessary to consider whether any alleged violated right was 'firmly established.'"

The judge said the six officers had a duty to stop Heyward from going into the house with the rifle and "had manifest probable cause to believe Heyward posed an immediate serious threat of physical harm to themselves and others."

Attorney Bryan Hoss, who represented five of the officers along with attorney Lee Davis, said, "This has taken two years, but we have said from day one the officers had a reason for what they did and they are finally vindicated.ydid an autopsy report shows."

He added, "These are great officers. Five of the six are still on the streets patrolling for the citizens of Chattanooga."

Attorney Hoss said the case had been set to go to trial on July 25 and was expected to last two weeks. The defense had over 250 exhibits and over 20 witnesses ready to go.

Attorney Johnny Houston represented officer Deborah Dennison, who married, moved to Alabama and is in another line of work.

The city was also sued and was represented by Phil Noblette and Crystal Freiberg of the city attorney's office.

Police said the officers fired a total of 59 shots.

Officers Dennison, Lauren Bacha, Zachery Moody, George Romero, William Salyers and Bryan Wood were initially placed on paid leave according to Chattanooga Police Department policy.

Police confronted Heyward on the porch of a house at 4316A 7th Ave. after first finding him on Rossville Boulevard.

Read Judge Collier's judgment order below:

Judgment Order of Judge Collier



AUDIO: County Commission Meeting 6/28/17

Sign Up To Get The Latest News, Opinions From Chattanoogan.com In Real Time; Win Set Of Chattanooga Photo Books

Sign up for our Facebook and Twitter feeds and you will get the  local news in "real time." You will also be entered for a chance to win the complete set of the Chattanooga Photo Books published by Chattanoogan.com. We will give away three sets of The Remarkable Stokes Collection, Railroads In and Around Chattanooga and Paul Hiener's Historic Chattanooga to our new Facebook ... (click for more)

CPS Should Have A Manned 24/7 Presence In Every County

This week something became abundantly clear to me. The Department of Child Protective Services in the state of Tennessee, or at least in Hamilton County, are asleep at the wheel.   Early yesterday afternoon local news stations broke the news: "Animals Removed from Soddy Daisy Home."  What the news station either didn't know, or didn't report, was that the children of ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Heroes Gather On July 14

Oliver North, whose journey as American patriot has not been an easy one, never lost hope. He once admitted he lied to Congress under oath, was found guilty of three felony counts after he followed the direct orders of his superiors, and then endured the wrath of the ignorant before the ACLU – of all sources – had the charges vacated. The former Lt. Colonel in the Marine Corps ... (click for more)

Chattanooga FC Hosts Memphis City FC Wednesday

 What a week it's been for CFC. After starting the season scoring only six goals in eight games, the boys in blue have racked up 12 goals in the last three matches, most recently shutting down FC Carolina United 5-0 this past Saturday.  Chattanooga FC returns to the pitch this Wednesday to take on interstate rival Memphis City FC in a must win game for both teams  ... (click for more)

30 Mocs On Academic All-Southern Conference Team

The University of Tennessee at Chattanooga put 30 student-athletes on the 2017 Spring Academic All-Southern Conference Team, the league office announced this week.  Junior women's golfer Megan Woods and sophomore women's tennis player Sydney Patton led the way with perfect 4.0 grade-point-averages.  The spring squad consists of representatives from the following ... (click for more)