Federal Jury Hears Testimony In Case Involving Alleged Rape Of Sewanee Freshman

Tuesday, August 23, 2011 - by Dennis Norwood

Attorneys for a former University of the South student identified only as John Doe told a Federal Court jury on Tuesday that he did not receive adequate "due process" prior to being kicked out of school following a rape allegation by a female student.

The case, being heard by Judge Sandy Mattice, stems from a civil finding of rape against the former student.

A Faculty Disciplinary Committee found the then-freshman male guilty of a category one sexual infraction in the rape of a fellow freshman student, known as “AB.”



The act took place in the early morning hours of Aug. 30, 2008, in the male student’s dorm room on the campus of the Sewanee, Tn., campus.

The crux of the civil trial is an alleged breach of contract between the school and Doe. It springs from the purported mishandling of Doe’s rights under the university’s policies on sexual harassment. Doe charges he was denied sufficient due process, as well as charging the school with negligence in his case.

According to Judge Mattice, the issues before the jury of two men and seven women in the breach of contract matter are was there a valid contract, was there a breach by the defendant, was it a material breach and did it cause damage to the defendant. Under the negligence aspect the plaintiff must prove that he was owed care by the school and that the school fell below published standards of due process fairness. The jury must also consider whether injury or loss incurred, whether the university's conduct contributed to that loss, and whether the university was the legal cause of any damage.

Doe also claims the school was guilty of negligent distress as well as several other charges.

The case revolves around the actions Dean of Students Eric Hartman took after being notified by “AB” that she had been the victim of rape by Doe. According to Doe’s attorney, Charles Wayne of DLA Piper, LLC of Washington, D.C., Dean Hartman failed to follow the university’s policies and held Doe’s hearings within three days of the incident. He received the results the next day, Friday, and was kicked off campus that Saturday. It was said that Doe only saw “AB’s” statement one hour before his hearing.

The defense’s expert witness, Brett Sokolow of Philadelphia, testified that, “The university did not satisfy the standard of care” towards Doe. Mr. Sokolow will return to the stand when court resumes on Wednesday at 9 a.m.

The university is being represented by Rosemarie Bryan of Chambliss, Bahner and Stophel.

Ms. Bryan told the jurors that they would hear two sides to the story. She read part of “AB’s” statement to the jury which pointed out that the young girl had previously been a virgin and had never engaged in activities such as she had that night. She alleged that she had been drunk and on prescription pills and was not capable of consenting to the sexual behavior.

The defense pointed out that following his leaving Sewanee, Doe moved to California and is currently enrolled ay Auburn University.

Stating that he was not as upset as he purported himself to be, Ms. Bryan pointed out that the plaintiff had since qualified for his sailing license and that his tuition had been covered out of a trust fund set up by his grandfather.

The trial is expected to run into the middle of next week.

(Dennis Norwood is a staff writer for Chattanoogan.com. He can be contacted at dennis.norwood@att.com.)


Clayton Brock Indicted For Selling Heroin

The Hamilton County Grand Jury has indicted Clayton Michael Brock on a charge of selling heroin. The indictment cites an incident on April 22. Brock, 24, of 1925 Wilkes Ave., Soddy Daisy, is facing three heroin-selling counts, possession of a controlled substance and possession of drug paraphernalia. (click for more)

Dwight Roper Indicted For Attempted Second-Degree Murder

The Hamilton County Grand Jury has indicted Dwight Effrem Roper for attempted second-degree murder. The indictment says he tried to kill Veronica Bradford in an incident on March 22. He was also indicted for taking property valued between $1,000 and $2,500 from Christy Meeks on March 22. Roper, 58, is a resident of 2641 Long St. (click for more)

Scrutinizing Defense And Other Public Spending Is Right Thing To Do

I saw in the news today where U.S. senators were investigating and scrutinizing an Army "debacle," which has already spent $6 billion on a communications system developed by a defense contractor (WIN-T) that is virtually ineffective in use.   This is on top of a recent Navy scandal (Fat Leonard Scandal) where several current and former Navy admirals were sentenced to prison ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Suicide Letter

Two weeks ago there were five suicides and a fatal drug overdose in the same Chattanooga community. That absolutely tears me up inside because I am assured almost every day there is a better answer. I make no secret I struggle with depression and it is real. I want others to see if I can get through the valleys to climb the mountain, they can too. I take medicine every day that ... (click for more)

Meigs Co. Stays Alive With 8-2 Win Over Summertown

MURFREESBORO, Tenn.  – The Meigs County Lady Tigers aren’t used to having to come from behind, but that was the case here at the Starplex Field No. 4 Friday morning. The defending Class A state champs had dropped a tough 2-1 loss to Forrest in the winners bracket semifinal on Thursday, but the Lady Tigers came back later that day with a 7-1 victory over Jackson Christian. ... (click for more)

Lennex Walker Wins Four Events For CSAS In State Track

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – There were no team championships to celebrate in the TSSAA Girls State Track Meet here at Dean A Hayes Track & Soccer Stadium Thursday, but there were a whole bunch of individuals who came through with sterling performances and positive results to finish another season with. Perhaps the most sensational performance came from Lennex Walker, that talented ... (click for more)