Complaint Filed Says TVA Ignored Sunshine Law Requirements

Monday, November 12, 2012

Garry Morgan, a member of Bellefonte Efficiency & Sustainability Team, has filed a complaint with the TVA Inspector General’s Office noting that Tennessee Valley Authority Board’s appointment of Bill Johnson as the new CEO is invalid.  According to the complaint, TVA, a public agency, did not follow the requirements of the Federal Sunshine Act.   That act states that TVA shall make a public announcement of the time, place, and subject matter of each meeting, whether it is to be open or closed to the public, and the name and telephone number of a TVA official who can respond to requests for information about the meeting. 

Mr. Morgan writes in the complaint, “If the Board of Directors are allowed to conduct business in such a manner that promotes secrecy instead of openness, the public's faith and trust will be seriously diminished in the TVA. I am not asking for the board to disclose personal, confidential information about the candidates for the TVA CEO position, but I am asking the TVA Board of Directors to comply with the notice requirements of the Sunshine Act concerning when they meet, regardless of the manner of the meeting as required by the Sunshine Law. 

In response to an inquiry regarding the process, TVA ombudsman Wilson Taylor, responded by e-mail on Nov. 7 and states, “The board members voted to approve the appointment of Bill Johnson through a notational process, without holding a meeting. This approach maintains the confidentiality of the candidates and provides clear adherence to the governance guidelines.  No further vote of the board is required."   

“The TVA may call it whatever they want, it does not reduce their responsibility to follow the law,” asserts Mr. Morgan, BEST member. He adds, “The TVA did not notify the public as to place or time of the meeting/decision as required by law; they are required to make a public announcement of the time, place, and subject matter of each meeting whether it is to be open or closed to the public, and the name and telephone number of a TVA official who can respond to requests for information about the meeting.”

BEST points out that the selection of the TVA CEO did not comply with the Criteria for Notational Approvals policy and that using that process does not remove the legal requirement for the TVA Board to comply with the Federal Sunshine Act. The criteria for using a notational process require the issue to be both time sensitive and confidential, but neither appear valid in this instance, they maintain. A Board Practices Resolution passed by the TVA Board in 2006 states “This notational approval process must be carried out in a way that is fully consistent with the Board’s responsibility to exercise careful and prudent oversight and their ability to lead TVA with integrity and open and transparent accountability.”  The final vote and announcement should have been conducted in an open and transparent way during the TVA Board meeting after public notification of the ongoing process, BEST officials said.   

The next TVA Board meeting is scheduled for Thursday in Rainsville, Ala.  The meeting is open to the public.  

BEST/MATRR is a chapter of the Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, a 501(C)3 non-profit organization.


Tennessee American Water And Chambliss Center For Children Kick-Off Summer At Annual Pool Party

Tennessee American Water and Chambliss Center for Children kicked-off the summer season with a pool party for the children participating in the summer program. Tennessee American Water filled up the more than 35,000-gallon pool at no cost to Chambliss Center for Children. “Clean and reliable water is an essential life resource. We are committed to providing high quality water ... (click for more)

Hixson Dentist Awarded Tennessee Dental Association Fellowship

Dr. Michael R. Johnson, a Hixson dentist, received the prestigious Tennessee Dental Association (TDA) Fellowship Award during the recent Music City Dental Conference held in Nashville, the 149th annual meeting of the TDA. The Fellowship Award is presented to no more than twelve deserving Tennessee dentists each year who make noteworthy contributions of their time and talent toward ... (click for more)

CBL & Associates Stockholder Accuses Chattanooga-Based Mall Owner Of Security Fraud; CBL Denies Any Wrongdoing

A stockholder of CBL & Associates is suing the Chattanooga-based mall owner in Chattanooga Federal Court, claiming its officials artificially inflated the value of the company's stock. Tommy French, of Baton Rouge, La., brought the action against CBL, President Stephen Lebovitz and Vice President Farzana Mitchell. He claims that CBL officials made false and misleading ... (click for more)

Carmody Found Guilty Of First-Degree Felony Murder; Sentenced To Life In Prison

Patrick Carmody was sentenced to life in prison after being found guilty of first-degree felony murder and especially aggravated robbery in Judge Barry Steelman’s courtroom on Friday. He was charged with the slaying of 21-year-old Chance LeCroy on Sept. 9, 2010. The state’s account of the incident claimed that Carmody, Ronald Pittman, and Billy Bob Partin traveled ... (click for more)

Case Handled Like Any Other? - And Response

It is interesting that Chief Fletcher would deem the handling of the Mayor's encounter as typical or normal. Is the Chief asking the public to believe that all misdemeanor domestic violence arrests include a 4-hour taped interrogation, and delayed reporting after a visit to the Chief’s house. Of course, we believe that Chief Fletcher. April Eidson * * *  I ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Best Speech This Year

Just 24 hours after Donovan Livingston gave The Student’s Speech at Harvard University’s Graduate School of Education convocation on Wednesday, it had been viewed over 3 million times and shared 75,000 times on Facebook. It is already considered, far and away, as the freshest view on race and education in ages and its viral journey is burning across the Internet. His talk was ... (click for more)