Alienation Grows, But Ochs Gang Study Sees Slight Role For Church - And Response

Wednesday, November 07, 2012 - by David Tulis

A southern city has a growing gang problem involving children as young as nine. Chattanooga is a prosperous town along a winding Tennessee River that flows around a scenic mountain upon which a great battle was fought in the second American war for independence. Lookout Mountain in late afternoon casts its shadow across government-run housing projects and blue-collar neighborhoods. In these, young men find their identity and pathways for life among gangs.

The Bloods hold forth in South Chattanooga. The Crips occupy East Chattanooga. Gangster Disciples politely decline to limit themselves to a given district (Comprehensive Gang Assessment, submitted to Chattanooga city government Sept. 13, p. 31). Eight in 10 gang members are black. Mostly they are male. In a four-year period through 2011 1,883 purported gang members were involved in 654 incidents in Hamilton County. Forty gangs operate in the city limits (pp. 27, 31). 

A primary cause of gang involvement is broken family life and careless parenting, says a report by Ochs Center of Metropolitan Studies and UTC. It regards Christianity, through the church, as a potential public resource in an effort to reduce the sway of gangs. 

Church — just another neighborhood club? 

According to scriptures, God has confided His oracles to the ministry of the church, to the power of the pulpit from which is faithfully preached the Word, God’s written self-revelation to man. How does the Chattanooga comprehensive gang assessment, a 162-page book, view the church in these terms? 

The academicians would have readers believe the church is of negligible consequence: “Overall, churches are working hard to change neighborhoods, yet conditions on the ground in some neighborhoods suggest that these efforts are not moving the needle.” Ministers of the gospel, ridiculously, “sometimes compete with one another for funding and publicity. This behavior does not promote an efficient allocation of resources to programs that are evidence-based; it also leads to programs that die of after the initial funding ends, furthering frustration in affected communities” (pp. 122, 123). 

The church has been entrusted from the time of the Apostles to “go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you; and lo I am with you always, even to the end of the age” (Matthew 28:19, 20). Its work is to use the propositions of the gospel to win ultimately every nation to Christ, one soul at a time. 

But sociologists consider it just another social agency, like a neighborhood association, youth club or police department. Their view shares with that of Erastianism, espoused by King Henry VIII and the Soviet Union, the view that the church is a mere department of state. Residents in gang-saturated areas share this low view of the church, whose call is to discipleship, repentance and sweet conquest by the suasive power of the Lamb of God. In surveys, people suggest ministers refocus their labors from preaching to “a more activist role *** reaching kids on the street” rather than “the traditional role of leading the flock.” 

Replacing preaching with civic activism

How do gang members view the black church? “Some gang members stated that church appeals to salvation are not strong motivators for youth. Church leaders could play a much stronger role in the streets as mediators, facilitators and violence interrupters.” The report discusses the white church as disconnected from the gang problem, but suggests wealthier white churches help their black fellows with money and volunteers. 

The report suggests gospel ministers shift some attention to social work, joining groups and police in having relationships with gang members and building neighborhood groups. 

"The critiques of black church leaders suggest that leaders could be more engaged in the community outside the walls of the church building. Church leaders could facilitate locally-based action to reclaim neighborhoods. They are well-suited to building neighborhood coalitions that are action oriented. Passive residents admonished city leaders to “do something.” Churches could  be the agents who make something happen rather than relying solely on the police, elected officials or outside organizations. 

"Engaged church leaders could also play a valuable role in educating the business and nonprofit community on community conditions. They have relationships with gang members and could arrange interviews between gang members and community leaders. Public, business, and nonprofit leaders are all aware of the statistics in gang-entrenched communities, but one-on-one dialogue with gang members might provide needed context for understanding the roots of the gang problem" (p. 123). 

Churches are involved in “community outreach and mentoring through a variety of programs” (p. 134). The report suggests ministers are ideal for arranging interview sessions with gang members to build human relationships. 

Students are generally more enlightened as to the work of the gospel ministry. Students are quoted as suggesting church people should “talk to gangs about Christianity” so members could come to “know God,” in which case the church would “spread the love [instead of] the hate” in Bible classes, prayer and other “church activities” (p. 73). 

Secularized salvation sought in community spirit 

The report alludes to a growing sense of alienation in American culture. 

"Trust in traditional institutions, from the church to Congress, continues to wane. Distrust is fueled by media saturation and increased knowledge of the perceived failures of public and private sector leaders. It is also fueled by the failure of well-intentioned programs to truly uplift struggling communities and young men. Those failures are reinforced by high incarceration rates, especially for African American males" (pp. 5, 6).   

It proposes, instead, “prosociality,” which envisions a turning away from a sense of alienation and a turning toward feelings of belonging, participation, mutuality, friendship and care of others. This vision is approximate to the equity, mercy, charity and just laws envisioned in holy writ. The mutuality inherent in Christianity is ignored as a spiritual ground for “prosociality,” but the report alludes to what suggests itself as the fruit of gospel truth lived out with noble hearts. And it seems to desire it. 

“If we are going to build neighborhoods of successful young people, it will pay to promote prosociality. But for prosociality to succeed, we need to be sure that our neighborhoods are highly nurturing and minimize stress and conflict,” the authors say, citing the Promise Neighborhoods Research Consortium (p. 5). A “community-wide strategy” is needed to eventually overcome the gang problem, the study says. 

How an unearthly authority might intervene in gang problem 

The church represents a divine jurisdiction and has a divine calling. Left to itself, mankind would not  have invented the church or devised the Bible. That library of 66 books is full of the majesty and power of God; it gives man no role in saving himself and pleasing a holy and perfect God who hates sin. In ordinary religion, man always is sovereign, and always saves himself by his will or his good deeds, whether in ritual, self-abasement or conquest. 

In contrast, the scriptures declare an alien righteousness saves sinners, a propitiatory sacrifice by the Son of God in favor of the rebel and the enemy, the autonomous one who claims captaincy of his soul but who finally yields that helm to his maker. Sinners obtain this righteousness not by their works or their persons, but by unmerited favor of God, Christianity teaches. 

The dogmas of the church are incomprehensible apart from the work of the Holy Spirit. He moves through the society of man upon oracles of faithful pulpit ministry. Until God through the Spirit brings repentance of sin, no reformation — no “prosociality” — is possible. 

Conflict, warfare, greed, competition for the dole, turf battles are the lot of man apart from in-breathed prosociality. 

The Ochs Center study proposes a reconstruction of society based on data and goodwill, and state control is implied. Certainly good intentions can do much. Just look at the federal government’s New Deal and the Great Society to see how society can be transformed by the force of new laws and taxes. But the church brings forth the means to change men from the inside. 

Insofar as the church is faithful to its calling in stewarding the Truth, it will be helpful to bring self-government to heads of households, and the young people who otherwise might end up in the grip of the Crips. 

David Tulis writes for Nooganomics.com, which covers local economy and free markets in Chattanooga and beyond.


* * * 

David Tullis wrote a wonderfully descriptive and prescriptive message that appeared in today's Chattanoogan. I want to take his thoughts and broaden the comprehensive solution to the issue of gangs here and in most cities and even small towns.  

There are compelling reasons to begin, this community, to think about how gangs affect overall society. Let me begin with the necessity and absolute need of a program that eliminates distance between agencies and individuals that want to serve. Let's make the program of intervention part of the school's efforts and put the spotlight on the center of real influence and service as the change agent. It is the schools.  So, I will start there. 

There are at least four inner city schools that serve largely minority students, ie those that are on free and reduced lunch programs. These could be the targeted schools. Each school would have at least one professional interventionist employed by the community to serve and wear many hats of responsibility. 

Let me cite just a few of those. A child enters school for the first time in either a pre-K or 1st grade. Since most gang members are boys I will talk only about boys here. This newly enrolled boy may show some problems with first request issues, ie, please return to your seats, please be quiet, teacher is talking or worse,  physical overtures toward others or still, academic difficulties with tasks appropriate to the grade level. All of these factors and the home situation can and do affect child performance and behavior.  

The teacher recognizes that there are problems and contacts the interventionist. She/he make many observations part of the background information. Appropriate and necessary contacts of other staff members within  the school is part of the interventionist position. When certain criteria are available to the interventionist she/he will initiate a conference with the parent either in the school setting or the home setting. Both are important  but if I were to rank order the most important and effective visit it would be in the home. More about that later.

The parent of the very young child has,  I have observed, some feeling of good will towards the child. After all, that five-year-old is kinda cute and cuddly and therefore, maybe a supportive parent and one that can be helped with the next function of the interventionist.  Within the boundaries of the school there should be on-going parent training and parent involvement both coincidentally operating at the same time. The school will be open in the evenings for community events and for support of the parent model. The school's mission, then, is not just to educate but to help socialize the fragmented community of the inner city child's world. The schools would operate as central clearing agency for the community served. 

There is a book read by millions written by Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton. It's title, It Takes a Village, is a perfect segue to a description of what is really needed to both address and solve the gang problem in Chattanooga or elsewhere. As I said earlier the school will serve as a clearing agency and be able to refer individual student families to the most appropriate of these many service providers.  

The church is included as are recreation centers, stores in the community, agencies that serve the masses, neighbors, friends and other family members. Let me cite an example. A student, age five is diagnosed with learning issues and needs further testing. The child is referred to a free-standing institution in the community for this service. Testing is conducted and conclusions rendered. The child is now returning to his school with helpful diagnostic information for the staff at that school to remediate. Said child is then referred to a specially trained volunteer/college student for remedial activities. In this interim period his parent is advised and meetings established to help parent facilitate the remediation. She is encouraged all along the process and never left "alone."   

The role of the recreation centers for this young child will also play a part as will the church. Each of those facilities should have outreach capabilities and be cognizant of this child and his problems. An afterschool program would serve multiple, parties ie., mom, family members, community would be enriched and the school would be serving in it's real purpose. 

The philosophy of the school's mission has been neglected for many many years. The school used to be the "hub" of a community and the spokes of that hub (wheel) were the churches, community agencies, families, neighbors..etc. In other words, it does take a village to  both raise a child and strengthen the community. The disparate delivery of needed services to the needy confuse both the providers and the ultimate good of said services. If I, as a professional, have the tools to effectively work with the troubled student I can far deliver better service and guarantee a better outcome.  

Schools will need to provide funding for these positions and the local universities can  and should be involved on multiple levels of service. Let me cite just two.. One is the research arm of any program to determine effectiveness and to recommend the plus and minus of the programs efforts. The second is the student availability of these young people that want to study education. Why not enrich them with a multiple layer of rich experiences thus broadening their pre employment experience base.  They could and should serve in multiple ways within the school day and during the open evening hours. 

I would be most honored to be helpful in anyway I could to facilitate this level of change in Chattanooga. Lincoln once said it take a thousand voices. I am one of the thousand. 

Robert J. Brooks
Chattanooga 


Why Sabrena Turner Is The Better Candidate - And Response

Chess is a complicated game which requires the player to make the best move from a sometimes large number of seemingly good choices. Each possible choice must be examined thoroughly and discarded until the best move is determined. Hopefully, the voters throughout Hamilton County will, as I did, use a similar process regarding their choice for the Hamilton County Commission District ... (click for more)

Charter Gives Little Solace If Chattanooga Sued Over Gay Ordinance

Today opponents of Chattanooga's domestic partner benefits ordinance are launching their campaign to convince city voters to overturn the rule in an August plebiscite. Residents seeking to give council member Chris Anderson the boot are rallying this week for signatures to put his ouster on the ballot. They have less than two weeks to obtain 1,600 signatures.   But there's ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Chamber Taps Bill Kilbride As Next CEO

The Chattanooga Area Chamber of Commerce has tapped retiring Mohawk Industries executive Bill Kilbride as president-elect to succeed Ron Harr as president and CEO on a schedule to be announced later. According to Howard Levine, chairman of the chamber board, Mr. Harr will continue as CEO for several more months. “We were disappointed that health concerns have made it necessary ... (click for more)

NAACP Recommends Staying Away From Planned Protest By Neo-Nazi Group

The president of the Chattanooga Chapter of the NAACP, urged local residents to stay away from a planned rally here by the Nationalist Socialist Movement in August. James R. Mapp said the group seeks to provoke incidents and said counter-protests could lead to problems. Mr. Mapp said, "On April 8th, 2014, reports surfaced throughout the Chattanooga-Hamilton County region that ... (click for more)

Owls' Fugate Fires Two-Hit Shutout In 2-0 Win Over Blue Raiders

Ooltewah was on the verge of a District 5-AAA double-header sweep against Cleveland. But the Blue Raiders’ hot-hitting catcher Hunter Oliver had other ideas. The Owls rode Logan Fugate’s brilliant two-hit shutout and two first-inning runs to a 2-0 win over Cleveland in the first game at A.C. Bud Ball Field on Wednesday. “Logan is an absolute warrior,” Owls coach Brian Hitchcox ... (click for more)

Bucs' Willingham Strikes Out School-Record 17 In 5-A Win

Boyd-Buchanan’s Brandon Willingham threw a three-hit, complete-game gem and set a school record with 17 strikeouts in the Bucs’ 7-1 victory over Copper Basin on Wednesday. Willingham, a sophomore, improved his record to 6-0 on the season while the Bucs went to 14-9 overall and 5-0 in District 5-A. Willingham threw 101 pitches with 73 strikes in dominating the Cougars. Willingham ... (click for more)