To Exercise Form Of Marriage No Gay Can Enjoy, Cross Border To Alabama

Friday, May 11, 2012

President Obama’s endorsement of what the media calls “gay marriage” puts a spotlight on a caprice of the modern state. Namely, its asserted authority to redefine words and concepts and to make things that are evil a good and accepted practice.  

Tennessee has taken control of marriage through Title 36 of its Tennessee Code Annotated, and has created a statutory system in which Tennesseans exercise their rights to form marital unions. But some states, such as Alabama, have been more careful not to offend the rights of the people. Alabama has not refused to recognize its people’s right to marry under common law, under their creational rights. Tennessee, for its part, refuses recognition of such unions. Despite its hubris in purporting to monopolize and control marriage, Tennessee recognizes common law marriages contracted elsewhere.

The only sort of marriage a homosexual can contract is under statutory law. 

Let that sink in. The only sort of law system a homosexual couple can enter into is that written by a state legislature. 

American common law, which in many areas has been set aside by states’ writing their own codes, envisions marriage only as between a man and a woman. No homosexual can marry under common law. Only men and women can enjoy the fruits of marriage, exercised as a right, under common law and its North Carolinian, English, ancient and biblical precedents.

President Obama drew national attention Wednesday in an interview in which he went public with his support of homosexuals on the marriage bed. "I've been going through an evolution on this issue. I've always been adamant that gay and lesbian Americans should be treated fairly and equally," Mr. Obama told ABC. "At a certain point I've just concluded that, for me personally, it is important for me to go ahead and affirm that I think same-sex couples should be able to get married." 

TENNESSEE HAS SEIZED MARRIAGE

Tennessee’s law provides a control of parties entering marriage. It prohibits marriage to one who is drunk, insane or an imbecile. It requires a waiting period for some under license. It relates duties of the clerk. It holds marriage to be the exclusive provenance of a man and woman. As statute puts it: 

“Tennessee's marriage licensing laws reinforce, carry forward, and make explicit the long-standing public policy of this state to recognize the family as essential to social and economic order and the common good and as the fundamental building block of our society. To that end, it is further the public policy of this state that the historical institution and legal contract solemnizing the relationship of one (1) man and one (1) woman shall be the only legally recognized marital contract in this state in order to provide the unique and exclusive rights and privileges to marriage.” (TCA 36-3-113)

The statute reflects the people’s 2004 amendment to the constitution (section 18) that makes “void and unenforceable” a marital contract between, say, two men in New York who move to Tennessee. 

State law doesn’t seem rigorous in the details. Any number of people are allowed to “solemnize” a marriage, from judge to county mayor. The rules require capacity and consent of the parties. They require no formula of words for a couple other than that they “shall respectively declare, in the presence of the minister or officer, that they accept each other as husband and/or wife.” The minister or officer is required to return the license after the ceremony, signed. 

The first iteration of Tennessee’s marriage licensing regime was in 1741. A second was in 1858 when the General Assembly abrogated the common law for marriage and created a protocol to regulate marriages among races at a time with race-mixing was deemed a public evil. The Tennessee constitution once forbade racial intermarriage, but that provision is repealed.

MARRIAGE IS PART OF CREATION 

Marriage is part of the human order of creation, with Adam having been given Eve as his lawful wife without any witnesses or any ceremony. The scriptures discuss marriage, its duties and joys, and protect it under the seventh commandment requiring sexual purity (“Thou shalt not commit adultery.”) The confessions of Christendom have consistently held the marriage is a covenant made before God by man and woman, and that it is for life. Jesus Christ allowed for divorce because of the hardness of his listeners’ hearts, but insists God doesn’t mean for that to be.

A marriage license, according to the 1968 edition of Black’s Law Dictionary, gives permission for people to “intermarry.” The more establishmentarian 2004 edition of Black’s says a marriage license “grants a couple permission to marry.” Whenever a state creates a regulatory and licensing apparatus for any ostensible public benefit, it declares illegal and unlawful by default the activity it proposes to regulate, such as marriage. It affords petitioners a privilege of being able to perform that illegal act. By general definition, a license is permission to do that which is otherwise unlawful or illegal. In the marriage question, the state arrogates to itself the authority to make all unions illegal. It does so inexplicably and by sleight of hand. And then, suddenly, it makes them legal again, but under permission. 

All 50 states have licensing regimes, though at least 10 states, including Alabama, recognize couples’ exercise of the covenant of marriage as a fundamental right.

Tennessee claimed a great power by taking ownership of marriage in the first place, though its power has been made more wholesome by the marriage amendment revision that refuses recognition of any homosexual right to wed. 

Is it fair to say that Tennessee forbids common law marriage, or simply does not recognize it? The U.S Supreme Court in Meister v. Moore 96 US 76 (1877) held that, "As before remarked, the statutes are held merely directory; because marriage is a thing of common right *** " [emphasis added]

The word “directory” refers to a provision of a law or rule that is merely directive, or instructive and of no obligatory force and involving no invalidating consequence for its disregard, according to Black’s. In Meister, the court dealt with statues in Massachusetts and Michigan that purported to render invalid marriages not entered into under the terms of statute. 

You and your children have a God-given right to marry, one that preceded the federal government and the state of Tennessee perhaps by 6,000 years. It is fair to say marriage is beyond their authority or purview to infringe upon fundamental rights. Marriage belongs to your sons and daughters by common right. Tennessee doesn’t say a common law marriage is illegal, unlawful or a crime. It is just not recognized.

I won’t discuss today an important reservation I have about statutory marriage that very possibly affects your jurisdiction over the issue of such marriage, namely the fruit, the offspring. Marrying under statute creates a three-party union, with the state the most powerful party, as it is the moving party, the enabling party bringing man and woman together. Licensure puts the union into commerce. The Times Free Press recognizes this suggestion by publishing marriage licenses in the business section every week. Children of such unions may emerge under a legal cloud, a sort of lien on their persons, their estates and their labor. In statutory marriage, only the state can dissolve the union through divorce proceedings, as the union is its property. I leave this matter aside for now. 

COMMON LAW MARRIAGE — STRIKINGLY ORDINARY 

I realize most people reading this essay might agree I have a good idea, but that marriage at common law seems impractical and might cause administrative headaches for the young couple.  

But pretend for a moment you might want to marry at common law. What are some considerations for Tennesseans?  

The families must solemnize the contract on freer soil. Alabama is friendly to such aims.  

It could be a parking lot of a convenience store or a Piggly Wiggly. But you want a cultivated event, with class. So you could inquire at the first church south of the state line in Bridgeport, Ala., the Rocky Springs Church of Christ on County Road 574 (I was not been able to reach anyone there by phone today, but have sent a letter of inquiry about the fellowship’s requirements for rental of facilities). You could inquire of others of our own choosing.  

Solemnization is a public event where the parties declare themselves before witnesses. Solemnization isn’t strictly required, but it helps establish intent to wed, a legally crucial element in a lawful marriage. Have witnesses, have a video made of the vows, sign a brief marital contract written up and signed before two or three witnesses before or just after the nuptials. A notary’s stamp on that document wouldn’t hurt. 

The person solemnizing the event doesn’t have to be a religious person; it could be anyone. But if you’re a Christian, make a Christian event out of your rite with your minister officiating. Now is the best part. Consummation and cohabitation. A man must live with his mate and love her and enjoy her — and she him. Make a point of letting your friends, neighbors, fellow church members and family members know you are married to this woman. Such “holding forth” and other points are legally requisite for enjoying marriage as a right, and not as a privilege. 

President Obama and the homosexual lobby are fighting, and partly winning, a battle for homosexual “marriage.” The states suppose it possible for two men to marry, or two women to marry. They adjust their statutes accordingly. But common law marriage, despite it being widely misunderstood and bad-mouthed by the ignorant, is something a free people should at consider for themselves and their marriage-aged children.

Sources: Tennessee Jurisprudence; http://www.originalintent.org/edu/marriage.php ;
Tennessee took on common law when it was carved out of North Carolina. Tennessee’s common law heritage rises from English law and American colonial law during and prior to the first war for independence.
I may be going too far in this claim. According to TennJur, Sanders v. Altmeyer 58, F Supp. 67 (W.D. Tenn., 1944) says common law contracted in Tennessee marriage is illegal, but I couldn’t get to reading the case today.
My wife, Jeannette, and I married in Huntsville, Ala., under statute. I had researched this issue sufficiently convinced I wanted to marry her at common law in that state, but we had already arranged to have the Revs. Peter Doyle and Peter Leithart preach the ceremony, and one of them said he was not open to my proposal to dodge a state entanglement. To avoid roiling family and creating controversy, I elected to proceed under statute, despite misgivings. 

David Tulis
www.nooganomics.com


David Carroll: Touched By Alzheimer’s, A Thanksgiving Love Story

I want to share a Thanksgiving love story. Those smiles belong to Jim and Andi Erwin of Collegedale, now married 45 years. Jim is 68, Andi is 63.  I met them last summer, and fell in love immediately. Andi is a talker. Full of life, with energy to spare. Jim used to be a talker, an award-winning one. In his youth he was a teacher and pastor, very well-educated. Simply put, ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: ‘Pretty’ Seeking ‘Rich’

The story has been around for a while, long enough for the fact-checking Snopes.com to classify it as a “legend,” which means “great story but lacks validity,” so as we hope Tennessee’s football team can somehow beat 19 th -ranked Missouri in a rough-and-tumble game at Neyland Stadium tonight, allow me to share this because it is delightful just the same. The following is what ... (click for more)

Grote Hall At UTC Campus Closed Due To Sinkhole

A sinkhole has prompted UTC officials to close off access to Grote Hall. Grote Hall employees have been told they do not need to report to work on Monday. Classes that are held in Grote Hall are called off for Monday. All other classes and campus activities are on for Monday. (click for more)

Bradley County Police Investigating Shooting; Victim Dies

The Bradley County Sheriff’s Office is investigating a shooting that occurred in the area of Georgetown Road. The sheriff's office said Sunday night that the victim had died. The victim's name has not yet been released.  A BCSO officer was waved down at the intersection of 25 th Street and Peerless Road by the driver of a vehicle who told the officer a gunshot victim ... (click for more)

Football Mocs Receive No. 8 Seed For FCS Playoffs

The hugs, high fives and first pumps by the Tennessee at Chattanooga football players late Sunday morning let everyone know in Moc Nation that the Blue and Gold had received a highy-coveted seed and would be hosting a second round NCAA FCS playoff game Dec 6 at Finley Stadium at 1 p.m. "When the television announcers called our name as the No.8 seed (out of eight ... (click for more)

Missouri Hangs On, Turns Back Tennessee, 29-21

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. – Missouri pin-pricked Joshua Dobbs’ bubble of invincibility Saturday night at Neyland Stadium. The nationally ranked Tigers drove a stake in Tennessee’s heart with Maty Mauk’s 73-yard touchdown pass to Jimmie Hunt in the fourth quarter, held Dobbs in check most of the game and beat the Vols, 29-21, before 95,821 fans on a chilly night on the banks of the Tennessee ... (click for more)