Attorneys Step In "Pro Bono" To Help Judge Steelman As Public Defender Garth Continues Recusal Motions

Friday, August 24, 2012
Attorney Mitch Carter volunteers to take case for Judge Barry Steelman
Attorney Mitch Carter volunteers to take case for Judge Barry Steelman

Criminal Court Judge Barry Steelman, whose cases have been piling up since Public Defender Ardena Garth began filing recusal motions en masse, got some help Friday.

It was arraignment day in which a large new batch of public defender cases were on the docket.

Ms. Garth was in the courtroom continuing to step aside on all new cases, saying in an earlier motion that Judge Steelman has been "venomous" toward her office.

Attorney Bill Speek said he lined up a group of lawyers willing to handle the cases without charge.

He said, "I just didn't want people sitting in jail for another 28 days before they would get another attorney appointed."

Attorney Speek said he handled a couple of Steelman public defender cases, including one "who was just charged with misdemeanors. I was able to set his cases quickly."

Those on the Speek list included his partner Gerald Webb, Christy Mincy, Stan Lanzo, Mary Sullivan Moore, Keith Black, Lloyd Levitt, Clancy Covert and Mike West.

When the list was announced, several other attorneys in the courtroom stood up and said they wanted to be included also.

During the arraignment, other attorneys approached the bench from time to time and told Judge Steelman they would work "pro bono" as well.

The judge began taking advantage of the multiple offers and began parceling out indigent cases to the volunteers.

Judge Steelman has set a hearing for Monday afternoon on the recusal motions.

Public Defender Ardena Garth at defense table
Public Defender Ardena Garth at defense table

PHOTOS: Dedication Of U.S. 27 Reconstruction

Mobley To Go Free In Brainerd Road Murder Case

The state will not retry Stephen Mobley in the case in which Gregory Watkins was shot nine times at a Brainerd Road convenience store. The murder charge was dismissed in the courtroom of Judge Barry Steelman on motion of the prosecution. A jury recently could not come to a unanimous decision in the case and a mistrial was declared. A defense witness had told the jury he ... (click for more)

School Vouchers Are Unfair - And Response

A school voucher is a publicly funded credit or certificate whereby a student may be enrolled in a private school and apply the credit to tuition.   So, why should Tennessee taxpayers care? 1.      Vouchers use your money to help pay for a student to go to a private school that answers to private administrators and not you the taxpayer. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: America’s Newest Darling

Minutes after I read a letter on Rebekah Gregory’s Facebook page yesterday, I was mere seconds from summoning the marching band, our prancing elephants, and the flag-bearers so we could rightfully induct this dazzling survivor of the Boston Marathon blast into my personal Hall of Fame. I do that, you know, when I see everyday people display courage, kindness, guts, brilliance, ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Women Advance To SoCon Championship, Defeat Furman 68-55

University of Tennessee at Chattanooga sophomore Jasmine Joyner (Southaven, Miss.) strung together her third straight double-double in a dominant performance, leading the Mocs to a 68-55 win over Furman in the semifinals of the Southern Conference Tournament at the U.S. Cellular Center. The 17 th -ranked Mocs will take on ETSU in the Championship game Sunday at 1 p.m. Joyner ... (click for more)

Top Twins Prospects Headed To 2015 Lookouts

Now that the ownership of the Chattanooga Lookouts has been passed on from Frank Burke to the Lookouts Capital group, it is time to get a quick glance at the young men who will be starting the season with the Double-A team of the Minnesota Twins. The Dodgers are no longer affiliated with the Lookouts where AT&T Field has been home to several Dodgers' prospects, including ... (click for more)