City Council Passes Controversial Domestic Partners Ordinance On First Reading; Berke Applauds Action

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

The City Council on Tuesday night voted  5-4 in favor of a controversial domestic partners ordinance. The second and final reading will be next Tuesday night. 

In favor were council members Chris Anderson, Carol Berz, Moses Freeman, Yusuf Hakeem and Jerry Mitchell.

Opposed were council members Larry Grohn, Ken Smith, Russell Gilbert and Chip Henderson.

Mayor Andy Berke said afterward, “In the 21st century economy, we must ensure we attract talented employees and remain competitive with local, regional, and national employers. That means hiring employees based on merit and offering a benefits package that retains and recruits the very best employees possible.  City Council showed leadership tonight and I am encouraged by those who voted for the equal and fair treatment of all city employees.”

Councilman Grohn said the ordinance was "so contentious that the voters should have an opportunity to have a say on it at the ballot box." But the vote proceeded.

There was also a motion by Councilman Grohn to "divide the question" by voting separately on the domestic partner section and the anti-harassment and non-discrimination section. The vote was a similar 5-4.

The ordinance, which follows similar action by Collegedale and Knoxville, allows benefits to the partners of same-sex city employees as well as partners of unmarried opposite-sex partners in a "non-platonic" relationship.

The council voted on a separate ordinance proposed by Councilman Grohn that he said would avert a problem of an employee who considers himself or herself a member of the opposite sex coming to work cross dressed. He said it would also deal with the problem of, for example, a man who considers himself a female, using the women's restroom.

Vice Chairman Henderson said he believes the new legislation may lead to uni-sex bathrooms that are locked during each use. 

City Attorney Wade Hinton said city staff members can develop policies to deal with particular situations that arise from the ordinance.

On the qualification that relationships must be sexual in order to be partnerships, Vice Chairman Henderson said, "There may be some husbands and wives out there who do not qualify."

He noted the possibility of sisters living together in a loving relationship, but said they could not qualify because it is "non-platonic." 

The domestic partners ordinance sets out terms for defining domestic partners, including having lived together for at least the past 365 days.

Three forms of proof must be submitted to the city in applying for the benefits.

On the cost, city officials said, "Based on initial research, companies and other municipalities that have adopted a similar benefits program have experienced a financial impact of not more than one percent of their total budget."

Todd Dockery, human resources director, reiterated that the new health benefits cost to the city should not exceed $170,000. He said in cities like Indianapolis and Louisville, few have signed up for the coverage.

He affirmed that it applies to children of the partner. On that point, Councilman Gilbert said some men have 10-12 children with different women.

Councilman Freeman referred to Councilman Grohn, saying he had made some assertions that were not accurate.

Councilman Anderson said the "Tea Party and the Family Action Council" had "dropped off" some literature with council members on the eve of the vote.

Councilman Mitchell, noting the tense and somewhat acrimonious tone, said, "Everyone should just take a breath." 

Councilman Anderson said, "I am enormously proud of this ordinance. It makes this city a more competitive employer."

Councilwoman Berz thanked fellow council members "for doing the right thing though it might not be the right thing for them." She said there was a fraudulent robo call during the campaign coming out of Knoxville that started out, "Hi, this is Carol." She said, "This was wrong, fraudulent and not blessed by anybody." She said others threatened her with, "We know where you live and we'll see that you don't get re-elected."

Councilman Freeman said he was "just shocked by what I heard coming from both sides." He said he made up his mind based on the gospel of love in the Bible, "judge not that ye not be judged" and based on the Constitution. He said, "The question is simple. Shall we treat all our brothers and sisters the same?"

Councilman Gilbert said he believes that male and female marriage is sacred to God. He said, "It seems we have gotten away from marriage" and there "is more chaos" today. He said, speaking for residents of District 5, "I don't believe that we can afford this." He said, "I feel like we are going down the wrong road and we are going to be paying for it in the future."

Councilman Grohn said choices by members of the gay, lesbian and trans-sexual community are not necessarily based on birth, "but their own sexual devices." He said it is such a divisive issue that it should be decided by the voters. He said, "This ordinance is all about sex. It is a back door effort to circumvent the state of Tennessee and approve same-sex marriage."

Councilman Henderson said it is an issue of both morality and economics. He said while campaigning he did not hear any call for giving benefits to those involved in same-sex relationships. He said the ordinance "siphons taxpayer dollars" from other needed issues.

Councilman Mitchell said many throughout the district, including his two opponents, have spoken out to him on the issue and "I've got a strong pulse of what District 2 wants." He said District 2 favors the ordinance.

Councilman Smith said he believes the ordinance will be more heavily used by opposite sex beneficiaries. He said it is hard to say what the actual costs of passing the ordinance will be. He said the council was being asked to favor non-employees over current and prior employees.   

Chairman Hakeem, just prior to the vote with the tally at 4-4, said, "It appears that all that can be said has been said." He said despite the vote, "Tomorrow the sun is going to shine."

 

  

  

 

 


Former Meigs County Official Connie Allen Indicted On Theft Charge

An investigation by special agents with the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has resulted in the arrest of a former Meigs County interim finance director on theft charges. At the request of 9 th  District Attorney General Russell Johnson, TBI special agents began investigating Connie Allen on Nov. 24, 2014. TBI agents worked in conjunction with the Tennessee Comptroller ... (click for more)

Corker Expects Senate Will Pass Legislation Giving Congress Ability To Weigh In On Any Final Nuclear Deal With Iran

Appearing on CNN’s “Wolf” on Friday, Senator Bob Corker said he expects the Senate to pass his legislation requiring congressional review of any comprehensive nuclear agreement with Iran before the president can waive or suspend sanctions imposed by Congress on Iran. The Senate Foreign Relations Committee will vote on the Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act of 2015 on  April ... (click for more)

Finley Stadium Needs To Grow Up - And Response

RE:  Finley Stadium Financial Picture Rosy; Beer And Alcohol Sales Approved; AstroTurf Almost Ready and City, County Pitching In $250,000 Each For New Finley Stadium AstroTurf I read a story here five days ago about a rosy future for Finley stadium. It lead me to believe that the stadium was making money and even improvements with donations.  Then we get a short ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Hillman Of Bihar

In the year of our Lord, 1927, there was a very poor child born to a very poor family in a very poor place. His name was Dasrath Manjhi and he was a native of the Musahar community somewhere in India. We know he had no education and, as a member of the lowest Hindu scheduled castes, he didn’t have a cut dog’s chance from the very get go. But after spending considerable time in ... (click for more)

Grissom Comes Out Swinging, Silverdale Falls Hard, 18-2

(Story will be updated) Grissom played power baseball Friday afternoon and Silverdale left the ballpark battered and bruised. The Tigers, out of Huntsville, Ala., pounded out 15 hits, including five for extra bases, scored seven runs in the second inning and a season-high nine in the third and shellacked the Seahawks, 18-2, in the Pounder Classic. On Thursday, coach ... (click for more)

Tennessee Fires Basketball Coach Donnie Tyndall

KNOXVILLE, Tenn.  – Tennessee has fired men’s basketball coach Donnie Tyndall. The decision was made based on information the university received during the NCAA's investigation of another institution. The university concluded that Tyndall will likely be held responsible for serious violations of NCAA rules that occurred during his tenure as head men's basketball ... (click for more)