Roy Exum: Ugh! Neigh To Horse Meat

Sunday, February 17, 2013 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

What began as a routine DNA inspection in Ireland a month ago has triggered what European food officials now fear is a widespread scandal -- horse meat is showing up in alarming rates in countries where it is has always been most taboo to eat the regal animals. One sample burger, it has been confirmed, contained as much as one-third of mankind's most noble steed and it is believed 28 companies in 13 countries may be involved in a massive fraud.

Since the gruesome discovery in Ireland, there were three arrests in Great Britain on Thursday and health officials believe that may just be the tip of the iceberg; one French company reportedly made profits of almost $750,000 over the past six months by substituting horse for beef to retailers.

This weekend the European Union has called for extensive DNA testing as people are shocked by what appears to be a disgusting food fraud.

Ironically, this time last year a misguided Tennessee lawmaker, Andy Holt (R-Dresden), tried to get a bill passed through the legislature to allow slaughterhouses in the state but a groundswell of fiery public opinion drowned out the farmer's efforts to keep horses from being transported to Canada, where the meat is sold to mostly Asian markets.

There are still some in Tennessee who haven't given up on the idea, especially when the state is still under worldwide scrutiny for horse abuse. The "Big Lick" faction of the Tennessee Walking Horse industry, centered in Shelbyville, has caused federal legislation to be introduced that would severely punish those who sadistically torture and maim animals for the so-called "Big Lick," an unnatural gait that brings a blue ribbon.

Yet today the loudest outcry is resounding in Europe where -- believe it or not -- eating horse is unthinkable in England while it is now sold as a delicacy at some restaurants in nearby France. The fraud, obviously, is that horse meat is being secretly ground into sausages and beef at the total surprise of the beef buyers. Cyprus, the Netherlands, Romania and other countries are finding horse meat in the groceries and -- while it is hardly toxic -- the illicit meat is now being discarded and destroyed.

In 2007 slaughtering horses was abandoned in the United States but, in November of 2011, Congress quietly lifted the ban. Today there are only a few locations where horses are slaughtered in the U.S. for what is thought to be a $100-billion global business. "There are certain communities that have considered (reviving horse slaughter,") said ASPCA spokesperson Nancy Perry, "but the vast amount of Americans -- 80 percent - oppose the practice," she told NBC News.

According to scientific experts, horse meat is actually high in protein and less fatty than beef, the taste akin to deer meat. The trouble is choking it down. Horses have played a key part in the nation's history and the immense love for the animals was most recently seen when the Tennessee Walking Horse industry was vandalized after it was revealed a segment of owners and trainers have sored and tortured the animals for over 40 years.

After World War II some U.S. citizens ate horse meat as a necessity, causing Republican detractors to label President Truman as "Horsemeat Harry" before the revolting practice was stopped. Canadian buyers are regularly seen in the Southeastern U.S., buying horses at auctions and then trucking the animals to Canada to be processed. In today's tough economy, some owners can't afford to keep their horses.

But nobody -- especially a horse owner -- wants to knowingly send their animals to slaughterhouses. When a bill was before the Tennessee Legislature last spring, Leighann McCollum of the Humane Society of the United States was quoted, "Horse slaughter plants have a very long history of polluting the environment, of animal cuelty, of devaluing property and generally running roughshod over rural communities," she told the Nashville Tennessean.

"The bill (proposed by Rep. Holt last year) is not about the horse-slaughter debate -- it's about Tennesseans' constitutional right to have access to the courthouse. This bill closes courts to everyone except the wealthy." she said.

Holt maintained he filed the bill last year to "create jobs" but now he is seeing -- along with the rest of the world -- that the European countries are furious at the tainted food that has invaded their butcher shops. Ray Ellard, an authority for food safety in Ireland, explained, "We set out to do something fairly simple" and said he had no idea the tests were "goiing to end up where it is today."

"But we're glad in one way," he told an NBS correspondent. "Systems will all improve and the potential for defrauding people will be a lot less. We're glad that has happened, but we've had a nervous few days, I can tell you."

royexum@aol.com


The Difference Between Good And Great In Education

In today’s world, we have the policymakers on one team with the educators on the other. In reality, they should both be working together on the same team.   Many educators see only what goes on in their classroom and school. If they come from an urban district, they have very little contact with others in their own district. Politicians and policymakers are influenced ... (click for more)

Send Your Opinions To Chattanoogan.com

We welcome your opinions at Chattanoogan.com. Email to news@chattanoogan.com . We require your real first and last name and contact information. There is no word limit, but if your article is too long you may lose your reader. Please focus more on issues than personal attacks. (click for more)

Work To Start Later This Year On Major Reworking Of U.S. 27 Downtown; 31 Walls To Be Erected As Cameron Hill Faces More Cuts

Work is set to start later this year on the $80 million reworking of U.S. 27 in downtown Chattanooga. TDOT's Jennifer Flynn said all of the right of way has been acquired and construction bids are tentatively scheduled to be opened in August.  The 1.4-mile project includes U.S. 27 from I-24 to south of the Olgiati Bridge.  Work was completed earlier this year ... (click for more)

3 Finalists For Criminal Court Judge Get Interviews With Governor Haslam On Monday

The three finalists for Criminal Court judge, Division II, are set to be interviewed by Governor Bill Haslam on Monday. The Governor’s Council for Judicial Appointments met on April 9, then submitted the names of Mike  Little, Leslie Longshore and Boyd Patterson. The vacancy was created when Judge Rebecca Stern announced that she was retiring prior to the end of her term. ... (click for more)

Harris Leaves Tyner For Administrative Job At Dalewood Middle

Long-time Tyner Academy boys basketball coach Gerald Harris has resigned his coaching position to accept a job as assistant principal at Dalewood Middle School. Harris, 49, was offered and accepted the administration job last Friday and met with last year’s team on Tuesday to break the news to those players. “I’ve been coaching a long time and I’ve said goodbye before,” ... (click for more)

Randy Smith: Giving With A Cheerful Heart

Recently a program was started called, "Dining Out For Life," benefitting people who are affected by HIV. Tonight  several local restaurants will be partnering with Chattanooga Cares to raise money to support the organization's nutrition assistance program. There is a big need for fresh fruit and vegetables and the funds raised this evening will go to support that need. ... (click for more)