State Supreme Court Clarifies Procedures Governing Workers’ Compensation Settlements Approved By The Department Of Labor

Friday, February 22, 2013

The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled Friday that when the Tennessee Department of Labor approves a workers’ compensation settlement and accepts the statistical data form submitted along with the settlement, a court may not later find that the statistical data form is incomplete and set aside the settlement on that basis.  The Court also clarified the procedures for appealing a Department-approved settlement and for attempting to set aside a Department-approved settlement.

In Christopher Furlough v. Spherion Atlantic Workforce, LLC, Mr. Furlough injured his back at work on December 4, 2005.  On June 21, 2006, the Department approved a settlement awarding Mr. Furlough a lump sum payment of $11,500, corresponding to a 12.4% permanent partial disability to the body as a whole, and future medical benefits.  Almost two years later, on April 18, 2008, Mr. Furlough filed a petition to set aside the settlement.  The trial court granted the petition, relying on Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 60.02(5) and its inherent authority.  The Special Workers’ Compensation Appeals Panel affirmed, but on different grounds.  Among other things, the Panel found that the statistical data form submitted along with the settlement was not “fully completed,” and this incomplete form prevented the settlement from becoming final and effective.

In its opinion, the Supreme Court disagreed with the Panel and held that when the Department accepts a statistical data form, courts must defer to the Department’s determination that the form satisfies the statutory requirement of “fully completed.”  The Court also disagreed with the trial court’s ruling.  The Court acknowledged that Mr. Furlough could have sought relief from the Department-approved settlement either by appealing under the Uniform Administrative Procedures Act or by petitioning to set aside the settlement under Tennessee Rule of Civil Procedure 60.02.  Mr. Furlough did not timely pursue an appeal, and the Court concluded that the trial court erred in granting Mr. Furlough’s petition to set aside the settlement based on Rule 60.02.  The Court therefore reversed the judgments of the Panel and the trial court and dismissed Mr. Furlough’s petition.

To read the Christopher Furlough v. Spherion Atlantic Workforce, LLC opinion, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, visit the Opinions sections of TNCourts.gov.

 



State Supreme Court Clarifies Law When Bank Sells Loan Collateral Without Proper Notice

The Supreme Court of Tennessee issued guidance on the steps courts should follow when a creditor sells collateral used to obtain a loan, but does not provide the required notice of the sale. The case involved a bank loan that was used to purchase an airplane, with the plane itself and additional guarantors securing the transaction. When the debtor failed to maintain insurance, the ... (click for more)

October Celebrates Pro Bono Legal Services With Clinics

The face of pro bono clinics is changing as the need for legal assistance grows across communities including Chattanooga, said officials.  Legal Aid of East Tennessee has formed new partnerships with other legal aid assistance groups in an effort to bridge the gap of those who can’t get legal assistance for a variety of civil legal issues.  An estimated 1 million Tennesseans ... (click for more)

Ooltewah High's Robin Copp Is State Principal Of The Year

Ooltewah High School principal Robin Copp has been named Tennessee’s 2017-18 Principal of the Year.   Officials said of the second-year principal, "No matter the grade level, she believes in creating student-centered schools, which are first and foremost focused on teaching and learning. To support this model, Copp has instituted a professional learning framework ... (click for more)

City Has Apparently Found Buyer For Chattanoogan Hotel

The city of Chattanooga has apparently found a buyer for the Chattanoogan hotel on Broad Street. A city board will meet next Monday to consider several resolutions. One item before the Chattanooga Downtown Redevelopment Corporation is approving the hiring of the Husch Blackwell law firm "as special counsel in connection with the preparation of a sale and purchase agreement ... (click for more)

Vote No On The Rezoning For A New Landfill In Harrison - And Response (3)

County Commissioners, please consider the following facts when voting on the rezoning request for a new privately-owned C&D landfill in Harrison.  Use of this property for a landfill has been rejected by the county three times in the past (1971, 1984 and 2007).  In 1971 and 2007 the County Commissioners unanimously rejected the proposal.  In 1984 the ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: UT A 34-Point ‘Dog

I can’t remember a time in my life when a University of Tennessee football team has been a five touchdown underdog and this comes at a time when my primary-care physician tells me, “Let’s face it … you are old.” That said, even when I look at myself naked in the bathroom mirror I ain’t as ugly as what I fear will happen in Tuscaloosa this coming Saturday. I can remember the Tide ... (click for more)