A former city police officer who was fired for his actions in trying to get an inmate into custody at a Salvation Army halfway house denied Thursday that his actions were excessive.
Sean Emmer told an administrative law judge that he was following his police training in trying to get Adam Tatum into custody on June 14, 2012.
Emmer and Adam Cooley were fired by Police Chief Bobby Dodd in the incident that was caught on video and audio. They are asking Kim Summers of Nashville to give them their jobs back. She has 15 days in which to rule after the close of the hearing at City Hall.
Former officer Emmer said he never encountered a suspect who was so resistant to police orders or who was so strong. He could be heard asking Tatum, "What are you on, man?" near the end of the video.
He said he was summoned to the facility on McCallie Avenue and found Tatum kicking on a door and holding another inmate by the shirt. He said there was a group of inmates nearby in a weight room watching his interaction with Tatum. He said if they had spilled over into the room they likely could have overcome himself and officer Chip Smith.
The former officer said soon after he began struggling with Tatum he saw a knife fall to the floor. He said he was able to get possession of the knife, but he said he was taught that "where there is one weapon there is two."
He said he began striking Tatum in the legs with his baton when he refused to roll over and be handcuffed. He hit the inmate some 40 times.
He told the hearing officer that after officer Smith tased Tatum he pulled the prongs out, got up and ran across the room. "I had never seen anyone do that," he said.
Also, he said Tatum was able to get out from under himself and Smith - a total of about 500 pounds. And he said it took five officers to finally handcuff Tatum.
Attorney Stevie Phillips pointed out that the Hamilton County Grand Jury refused to indict former officer Emmer, though he was not there to defend himself. She said federal authorities looked into the matter and sent a letter saying he would not be prosecuted.
The former officer said he believed that Chief Dodd had his mind made up to fire him before his disciplinary hearing began. "I could tell that the second I walked in," he said.
He said he was not provided material he asked for to prepare for the hearing.
The hearing will resume next Wednesday.