Roy Exum: The Rolling Stone Tragedy

Friday, July 26, 2013 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

I rarely read “Rolling Stone” magazine because I have no respect for any publication that regularly uses gutter words in its stories. In my opinion, filthy language weakens any argument and some teenager may think it’s cool and hip but it is not. Further, most of its stories hold little interest for me.

I am also no fan – at all – of the Boston Marathon bomber, Dzhokhar “Jahar” Tsarnaev, who riotously graces the August cover. If he is found guilty by a court of law for maiming hundreds at this year’s event, put me down as one who thinks he should be put to death the very next day. Yes, I still believe in the death penalty and this is an ideal instance where it should be imposed.

But, far worse, I don’t want CVS pharmacy, Walgreen’s or 7-Eleven telling me what I should read and what I should not. Jon McCain, one of America’s greatest heroes after what he endured at the Hanoi Hilton, told viewers on CNN’s “State of the Union” Sunday that Jahar on the cover was “stupid, and I thought it was inappropriate." He also noted, “Rolling Stone probably got more publicity than they've had in 20 years," he said.

The outcry is that the magazine is making our newest punk out to be a rock star and that the cover photo establishes him as some sort of folk hero. That’s ridiculous. The trouble is the very ones who deplore the magazine have not read the story and therefore fail to see that Janet Reitman’s excellent article explains why a promising, bright kid became a “monster” in almost the blink of an eye.

For the record, I don’t understand the Aurora shootings, the Sandy Hook elementary school massacre or the other senseless horrors that are happening in my lifetime. How can you learn, or explain to a child, if you don’t read and study such a deranged tragedy? I enjoyed Reitman’s article immensely. It was well-written, factual, and hardly portrayed the younger Tsarnaev as anything other than a badly-twisted kid who deeply hurt thousands of Americans and dimmed the dreams of many more.

How’s this? Jahar was nominated for the National Honor Society as a sophomore. He was so admired and liked that he was elected captain of his wrestling team as a junior. He was a stand-up teenager who was cursed by a sordid home life, an older brother who lured him into Islam, and who – in the end –fell for life’s new cop-out.

Reitman’s telling paragraph: “Why a person with an extreme or “radical” ideology may decided to commit violence is an inexact science but experts agree there must be a cognitive opening on some sort. ‘A person is angry and he needs some explanation for that angst,’ explains the Soufan’s Group’s Tom Neer. “Projected blame is a defense mechanism. Rather than say, ‘I’m lost. I’ve got a problem,’ it is must easier to find a convenient enemy or scapegoat. The justification comes later – say, U.S. Imperialism, or whatever. It’s the explanation that is key.”

So here is a kid whose parents move back to Russia after failing to find the dream, who idolized an older brother who turned rancid when a boxing career was sidelined because Tamerlin was not an America citizen, and who soon got sucked into a misguided Muslim mindset that proved lethal. In other words, it was America’s fault. And because the United States killed Muslims in Afghanistan, the Tsarnaev would seek revenge.

Less than a month before the pressure-cooker bombs went off, Jahar tweeted, “People come into your life to help you, hurt you, love you and leave you and that shapes your character and the person you were meant to be.” Two days later he added, “Evil triumphs when good men do nothing.”

About a week before three were killed and hundreds were maimed – losing limbs, eyesight and life as they once knew it – Jahar wrote, “If you have the knowledge and inspiration all that’s left is to take action.”

Although he is presumed innocent until proven otherwise, and has pleaded “not guilty” in preliminary hearings, Jahar’s downward fall is a great personal tragedy. His brother is dead. His life is ruined and America has a new scar. That said, what on earth did he accomplish? My personal belief is that we should strive to share his story and its pitfalls with would-be cowards of the same ilk.

My belief is you do not hide a story like this one, or “shoot the messenger,” but instead use it as a teaching source in schools, recreation centers and anywhere a kid may have second thoughts before he gets similarly twisted and ruins not only his life but that of his family and friends. Teach people there is no way violence will ever accomplish anything.

The Rolling Stone story told how the nurses at Beth Israel Hospital were ambivalent towards Jahar in his recovery for fear they “might like him” and that there is very much a blood lust alive for his ultimate demise. But what really is that? Hatred? Fear? The very things we deplore in others but try so hard not to admit ourselves?

In all honestly I don’t hate Tsarnaev. I think he should pay the steepest price for his crimes against mankind but none of us should allow his individual actions to categorize Muslims in the United States. A news story yesterday said that single-issue sales of Rolling Stone magazine are up 20 percent this month. And why is it that there was no out-roar when the same picture that graces the magazine cover was on the front page of the New York Times three weeks prior?

Hatred and fear must be tempered and to “boycott”  the magazine, which is certainly the right of CVS and Walgreen’s, does little to encouraging Americans like me to read the article and draw personal conclusions. Knowledge is the sharpest knife in the drawer and it is my belief that the only way to prevent Jahars in the future is to properly educate them. We must teach that shootings and violence accomplish nothing but pain and sorrow.

At one time it is very apparent Dzhokhar Tsarnaev was a good kid. His teachers and coaches adored him. He had many friends and even earned a college scholarship. When you look past your hatred and your prejudice, you’ll see that is true. What happened in Boston is tragic and only until we study and learn and try, can we stop another senseless bombing from happening again.

We must study it, learn from it, and try.

royexum@aol.com


Process

My favorite TreeHugger once commented I'm a process sort of guy. One might suppose that's true, even though there are situations in which we must lower our center of mass to keep a firm base, lean forward, put our head down, grab a cheek in each hand and, like Teddy Roosevelt, scream "Charge! (but not with credit cards)" as we move forward con mucho gusto. However, unless one is ... (click for more)

City Pension Double Standard

Re: Chattanooga City Council OKs pension plan amendment 8-26-14 The Chattanooga City Council voted Tuesday to keep future retirees who are re-employed by the city from dipping into their current retirement while contributing to a new city pension. But first council members gave an exemption to two of their colleagues and one other city employee. Councilman Moses Freeman ... (click for more)

City, County Pull The Plug On Downtown Shooting Range

City and county officials have decided to keep the police firing range at Moccasin Bend rather than building an expensive new indoor facility at the former Farmers Market property. County Mayor Jim Coppinger said Sheriff Jim Hammond and new Police Chief Fred Fletcher met recently and decided to "pull the plug" on the project. He said officers felt that the Moccasin Bend range ... (click for more)

Reception Honors County's 2nd-Longest Serving Employee

General Sessions Court Judge Clarence Shattuck, at a County Courthouse reception, asked anyone who was working at the courthouse in 1966 to raise their hand. Only Circuit Court Clerk Paula Thompson was able to do so. Judge Shattuck said he believes only Edna Camp of the Criminal Court clerk's office, has been at the courthouse longer. Ms. Thompson did not seek re-election, ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Christian Sweeps Notre Dame In 7-AA Volleyball

 It didn't matter that the Chattanooga Christian volleyball team was on the road Tuesday night.  Who cared that they were playing one of their biggest rivals in District 7-AA in a loud and spirited Jack Steiner Sr. Gymnasium at Notre Dame High School. None of those factors came into play as the Lady Chargers were ready to play and the Lady Irish were not. The results ... (click for more)

Fulghum, Walker Power Soddy-Daisy Past Cleveland

Soddy-Daisy’s Lady Trojans shook off an up-and-down performance in last weekend’s Early Bird tournament at Oak Ridge and throttled Cleveland, 3-0, in a District 5-AAA volleyball match Tuesday at Soddy-Daisy High School. The Lady Trojans (8-4, 2-1) swept the match with set scores of 25-18, 25-22 and 25-15. Abby Walker and Karigan Fulghum combined for 30 digs and 18 kills to ... (click for more)