Tennessee Supreme Court Reinstates Murder Conviction Stemming From Memphis Robbery Attempt

Thursday, March 06, 2014

The Tennessee Supreme Court has reinstated a Memphis man’s conviction for first-degree felony murder while clarifying Tennessee law regarding the requirements to make an arrest and when a confession can be a basis for a conviction. 

Courtney Bishop and an accomplice schemed to rob a drug dealer at gunpoint in 2008, but instead, the victim was shot and killed. When the police arrested the accomplice, he named Bishop as the shooter. Police then arrested Bishop, who confessed. He repeated his confession at the trial, testifying that he accidentally killed the victim during a botched robbery attempt. A jury convicted him of attempted aggravated robbery and first-degree felony murder.

Before the trial, Bishop had successfully sought to exclude his 2008 confession. Bishop asserted that his statement should be suppressed because it was the result of his illegal arrest. Bishop argued that his arrest was illegal because the accomplice’s statements implicating him in the shooting of Maurice Taylor did not provide the police with probable cause to arrest him. 

On appeal, the Court of Criminal Appeals dismissed Bishop’s attempted aggravated robbery conviction and granted Bishop a new trial on the modified charge of second-degree murder. 

In a unanimous opinion, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals and upheld the original convictions. 

First, the Court determined that the accomplice’s statement was reliable enough to give police probable cause to arrest Bishop. The accomplice’s identification of Bishop as the shooter was credible because the police had already gathered most of the facts in the accomplice’s statement through independent investigation. 

The Court also clarified the longstanding Tennessee rule that a person cannot be convicted based entirely on a confession that has not been corroborated by other evidence, unless that confession is given under oath in court, as was the case with Bishop. 

To read the opinion in State of Tennessee v. Courtney Bishop, authored by Justice William C. Koch, Jr., visit the Opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

Lupi's Given 3-Day Beer License Suspension At Ooltewah Unit After 1st Serving Infraction In 18 Years

The first Lupi’s restaurant in Chattanooga opened downtown in 1996. Since then three additional locations have been added in Chattanooga and one in Cleveland. In those 18 years none of the restaurants have been cited before the Chattanooga Beer Board for a violation. That clean record did not stop the board from issuing a three-day penalty to the restaurant located at 9453 Bradmore ... (click for more)

Apartment Dryer Fire Displaces 18 People

Chattanooga firefighters responded to a fire shortly before 11 a.m. on Thursday, at the Rustic Village North at 4616 Sunflower Lane. The firefighters got the fire out quickly, containing the fire to the laundry room in Apartment 304. No one was injured. Battalion Chief Jeff Eldridge said the fire started in or near the dryer and would be ruled accidental. Though the damage ... (click for more)

Black Creek TIF Decision-Who Guards The Hen House? - And Response

Citizens of Chattanooga were invited to give public comment before their own Industrial Development Board Aug. 15. They arrived to find foxes guarding their hen house.  Many thought the meeting was their opportunity to seek redress in the ill-conceived Black Creek Tax Increment Financing plan. However, they learned it was a sham orchestrated by both the past and present ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Coaches Vs. ‘Top 25’ Foes

The long-accepted measuring stick for a college football coach has been his win-loss record, with an after-glance at his win-loss record within his conference. But in Wednesday’s editions of the Wall Street Journal, writer David Everson, with the help of Stats LLC, used a much-tougher litmus test when he revealed the records of 65 major-college coaches against opponents that were ... (click for more)

East Ridge's JoJo Tillery Relies Heavily On His Football MoJo

(This is the 15th in a series of preseason stories on new high school football coaches, or veteran coaches at a different school, and top players in the Chattanooga area) The numbers don’t lie. East Ridge quarterback JoJo Tillery can be a nightmare for defensive coordinators. Do they make him run? Or do they want him throw the football? Pick your poison, fellas. ... (click for more)

UTC's Jay Hay Has Found a Football Home

“Without a doubt, I cannot think of a place I would rather be than here at UTC playing football. The veteran players welcomed me this summer as a junior college transfer with open arms.” UTC defensive back Jay Hay It’s been a crazy, at times frustrating and difficult, four-year football journey for Dade County, Fla. native Jeremiah “Jay” ... (click for more)