Tennessee Supreme Court Reinstates Murder Conviction Stemming From Memphis Robbery Attempt

Thursday, March 06, 2014

The Tennessee Supreme Court has reinstated a Memphis man’s conviction for first-degree felony murder while clarifying Tennessee law regarding the requirements to make an arrest and when a confession can be a basis for a conviction. 

Courtney Bishop and an accomplice schemed to rob a drug dealer at gunpoint in 2008, but instead, the victim was shot and killed. When the police arrested the accomplice, he named Bishop as the shooter. Police then arrested Bishop, who confessed. He repeated his confession at the trial, testifying that he accidentally killed the victim during a botched robbery attempt. A jury convicted him of attempted aggravated robbery and first-degree felony murder.

Before the trial, Bishop had successfully sought to exclude his 2008 confession. Bishop asserted that his statement should be suppressed because it was the result of his illegal arrest. Bishop argued that his arrest was illegal because the accomplice’s statements implicating him in the shooting of Maurice Taylor did not provide the police with probable cause to arrest him. 

On appeal, the Court of Criminal Appeals dismissed Bishop’s attempted aggravated robbery conviction and granted Bishop a new trial on the modified charge of second-degree murder. 

In a unanimous opinion, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals and upheld the original convictions. 

First, the Court determined that the accomplice’s statement was reliable enough to give police probable cause to arrest Bishop. The accomplice’s identification of Bishop as the shooter was credible because the police had already gathered most of the facts in the accomplice’s statement through independent investigation. 

The Court also clarified the longstanding Tennessee rule that a person cannot be convicted based entirely on a confession that has not been corroborated by other evidence, unless that confession is given under oath in court, as was the case with Bishop. 

To read the opinion in State of Tennessee v. Courtney Bishop, authored by Justice William C. Koch, Jr., visit the Opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

Police Chief Fletcher Announces Picks For Top Leadership

Police Chief Fred Fletcher Wednesday made his picks for top leadership, releasing the names of 15 newly promoted individuals from within the Chattanooga Police Department. This announcement comes several weeks after Chief Fletcher was appointed.  “I am honored to announce today’s promotions," said Chief Fletcher.  "Together these individuals have served our community ... (click for more)

Corker Says Probe To Point Directly At Russia

Appearing on MSNBC’s Daily Rundown on Wednesday to discuss the missile strike on Malaysian Airlines flight MH17 over Ukraine, Senator Bob Corker said the investigation is “going to point directly at Russia.” He said there is bipartisan support for the U.S. “to act alone without Europe” in expanding existing sanctions against significant Russian entities in the energy, financial ... (click for more)

The Truth From Weston’s Sister - And Response (3)

I try not to read the negative articles and opinions about my older brother. Growing up around politics, I learned a long time ago that thick skin is not only necessary, it’s paramount. But this time, the lies and the rumors and the inaccurate information has gone too far. It’s too ridiculous for me to ignore. So let’s clear a few things up: Weston and I do not “come ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Oscar Brock’s True Passion

I don’t pay much attention to the Hamilton County School Board. Once the moon and the stars aligned behind Superintendent Rick Smith, you hear very little, if anything, from the nine-member council that oversees an annual budget of almost $400 million and employs 4,480 people. So chew this for a minute: approximately 2,000 of those people are not teachers. Yes, there are 78 principals ... (click for more)

Mocs Picked First In SoCon Polls

The Chattanooga Mocs football team is the pick of litter in the Southern Conference. Coming off its first league title since 1984, the SoCon coaches and media deemed the Mocs the team to beat in 2014.   “It means we have good players,” Head Coach  Russ Huesman  said. “There is a long way to go from now until late November (when the regular season ends). ... (click for more)

Soddy-Daisy's Wright Commits To MTSU Baseball

Soddy-Daisy’s Andy Wright, a rising senior and dual-threat player, has made a non-binding verbal commitment to play baseball at Middle Tennessee State University. Wright, a pitcher/third baseman, chose the Conference USA Blue Raiders over Belmont, Air Force, Navy, UT-Martin and Carson-Newman. “I’m glad to get this (decision) off my back so I can enjoy my senior year,” Wright ... (click for more)