Tennessee Supreme Court Reinstates Murder Conviction Stemming From Memphis Robbery Attempt

Thursday, March 06, 2014

The Tennessee Supreme Court has reinstated a Memphis man’s conviction for first-degree felony murder while clarifying Tennessee law regarding the requirements to make an arrest and when a confession can be a basis for a conviction. 

Courtney Bishop and an accomplice schemed to rob a drug dealer at gunpoint in 2008, but instead, the victim was shot and killed. When the police arrested the accomplice, he named Bishop as the shooter. Police then arrested Bishop, who confessed. He repeated his confession at the trial, testifying that he accidentally killed the victim during a botched robbery attempt. A jury convicted him of attempted aggravated robbery and first-degree felony murder.

Before the trial, Bishop had successfully sought to exclude his 2008 confession. Bishop asserted that his statement should be suppressed because it was the result of his illegal arrest. Bishop argued that his arrest was illegal because the accomplice’s statements implicating him in the shooting of Maurice Taylor did not provide the police with probable cause to arrest him. 

On appeal, the Court of Criminal Appeals dismissed Bishop’s attempted aggravated robbery conviction and granted Bishop a new trial on the modified charge of second-degree murder. 

In a unanimous opinion, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals and upheld the original convictions. 

First, the Court determined that the accomplice’s statement was reliable enough to give police probable cause to arrest Bishop. The accomplice’s identification of Bishop as the shooter was credible because the police had already gathered most of the facts in the accomplice’s statement through independent investigation. 

The Court also clarified the longstanding Tennessee rule that a person cannot be convicted based entirely on a confession that has not been corroborated by other evidence, unless that confession is given under oath in court, as was the case with Bishop. 

To read the opinion in State of Tennessee v. Courtney Bishop, authored by Justice William C. Koch, Jr., visit the Opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report - And Mug Shots

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: APPLEBERRY, GERALD DELANE     2460 NORTHBRIAR CIR CHATTANOOGA, 37406     44     Hamilton County          AGGRAVATED ASSAULT ARCHEY, JACOB DILLON     2060 PARIS METZ ROAD CHATTANOOGA, 37421     21    ... (click for more)

KFC Manager Arrested After Staging Fake Robbery

Police were called Sunday night after a manager of the KFC on 3rd Street staged a fake robbery in order to take money. Fellen Hayes, 24, was arrested after police say she conspired with a man named "Ira" to make her theft look like a robbery. These events occurred shortly after noon.  She initially called police saying that a tall black male had approached her and taken ... (click for more)

Curtis Adams: Beck, Mackey Should Be Considered For County Commission Leadership

Just think about this;  a person highly qualified applying for a job.  As he is just about finished filling out his papers for his interview, he sees at the bottom there is a place for him to check Democrat or Republican.  He would think, “if I mark the wrong one I may not get the job.” Being a real leader requires honesty, integrity, and, most importantly, fairness. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Mark’s 50th Anniversary Toast

In the new book that celebrates the first 50 years of baseball’s Southern League, its splendid author Mark McCarter recalls that very early in his career as a sports writer, he was riding with his boss somewhere and mentioned that if the legendary Allan Morris ever needed help covering the Chattanooga Lookouts that he’d love to help. Today, as he looks back, he ruefully adds, “I ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Football Club National Championship Match Can Be Viewed Via EPB Fiber Optics

EPB Fiber Optics is offering the community exclusive live broadcast coverage of the Chattanooga Football Club in its final battle for the National Premier Soccer League National Championship. The game between the Chattanooga FC and the New York Red Bulls-Under 23 squad is scheduled for Saturday at 9:30 p.m. from the Red Bull Arena in Harrison, New Jersey. Fi TV Bronze, Silver ... (click for more)

McCallie's Bubba Simmons Steps Down as A.D.

C.R. “Bubba” Simmons  has announced plans to step down from his position as Athletic Director at McCallie School and accept the position of principal at Gordon Lee High School. Mr. Simmons took the helm of the school’s athletic department in 2008. Over the course of his career, which includes two previous stints, Mr. Simmons has served McCallie for almost 20 years. ... (click for more)