Supreme Court Addresses Affidavit Requirement Of Health Care Liability Pre-Suit Notice Statute

Thursday, April 24, 2014

In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court has determined that a health care liability suit can continue because a plaintiff complied fully with the requirement to provide pre-suit notice to defendants and complied substantially with the requirements to confirm the sending of the notice.

Under Tennessee law, a plaintiff in a medical malpractice suit – referred to by statute as a “health care liability action” – must serve written notice of their potential claim on all potential health care provider defendants at least 60 days before filing a complaint.

The pre-suit notice may be served by certified mail. The law states that compliance with the service requirement shall be demonstrated by, among other things, filing an affidavit with the complaint confirming that pre-suit notice was properly served.

In the case decided today, the plaintiff, Richard Thurmond, served pre-suit notice by certified mail 60 days in advance of the filing of the suit, but did not file an affidavit with his complaint confirming such service. The defendants, Mid-Cumberland Infectious Disease Consultants and Dr. Simi Vincent, asked the trial court to dismiss the case on the ground that the statute mandated filing the affidavit with the complaint. However, the defendants did not deny receiving pre-suit notice or claim prejudice from the lack of an affidavit. Believing the statute required the affidavit, the trial court “reluctantly” dismissed the lawsuit, and the Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal but characterized the result as “harsh.”

The Supreme Court reversed. Justice Cornelia A. Clark writing for the Court noted that the plaintiff satisfied “the ‘fundamental’ and essential purpose of the pre-suit notice statute” by timely providing pre-suit notice to the defendants. Because strict compliance with the affidavit requirement is not “essential to avoid prejudicing an opposing litigant,” the Court determined that the requirement may be satisfied by substantial compliance.

The Court ruled that the plaintiff had substantially complied with the affidavit requirement by stating in his complaint that pre-suit notice had been timely served, by providing a disc with images five days after filing his complaint that established that pre-suit notice had been timely served by certified mail, and by filing an affidavit less than three months after filing his complaint confirming timely service of pre-suit notice by certified mail.

The case will now return to the trial court for further proceedings.




Miller And Martin Names Nashville Attorney To Head Health Care Practice Group

Miller & Martin PLLC announced that Nashville attorney David Lewis will head the health care practice group for the southeast firm, according to Jim Haley, chairman. Mr. Lewis joined Miller & Martin’s Nashville office in May after serving as the vice president and associate legal counsel at LifePoint Hospitals in Brentwood.  He will be responsible for the ongoing ... (click for more)

Michael Williams Has Law License Suspended

Michael Gregory Williams, of Hamilton County, was suspended from the practice of law on Thursday by Order of the Tennessee Supreme Court for four years.  The suspension will begin on Nov. 9. A Petition for Discipline was filed on Oct. 30, 2013, alleging that Mr. Williams had misappropriated funds from an estate for which he had been appointed administrator and had failed ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Area Under Hard Freeze Warning As Winter Comes Early

The Chattanooga area was under a freeze warning as winter rushed in early. The biting weather came as crew members were about to hit the water for the annual Head of the Hooch at Ross's Landing. Here is the warning: ...FREEZE WARNING IN EFFECT FROM 3 AM EST /2 AM CST/ TO 9 AM EST /8 AM CST/ SUNDAY ... THE NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE IN MORRISTOWN HAS ISSUED ... (click for more)

Downtown Chattanooga Apartment Complex That Brought $3 Million Profit Exempt From Most Taxes Until 2022 Under PILOT

A downtown Chattanooga apartment complex that recently was sold at a $3 million profit is exempt from most property taxes through 2022 under a PILOT (payment in lieu of taxes) agreement.   No payment of school taxes was included in the deal for Walnut Commons at Walnut Street and Aquarium Way.   The only taxes due on the property for the next eight ... (click for more)

Time To Fix The TIFs

What if Chattanooga policy makers and taxpayers used several recent business announcements as a wakeup call to learn more about how our community decides what companies get property tax breaks? If enough people accept this assignment, it just might result in the adoption of some sound policies and procedures to guide us in the future. We read in the newspapers this week that ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: My Garden In November

As the first day of November arrives today, it is cold enough in my garden to officially certify that fall has fell! There are even signs of ice on the ground but there is a bounty crop of acorns so, in keeping with our monthly tradition, some will get shiny acorns and others will get a chunk of cold ice: A SHINY ACORN for Patriots football coach Bill Belichick for scoffing at ... (click for more)