Supreme Court Addresses Affidavit Requirement Of Health Care Liability Pre-Suit Notice Statute

Thursday, April 24, 2014

In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court has determined that a health care liability suit can continue because a plaintiff complied fully with the requirement to provide pre-suit notice to defendants and complied substantially with the requirements to confirm the sending of the notice.

Under Tennessee law, a plaintiff in a medical malpractice suit – referred to by statute as a “health care liability action” – must serve written notice of their potential claim on all potential health care provider defendants at least 60 days before filing a complaint.

The pre-suit notice may be served by certified mail. The law states that compliance with the service requirement shall be demonstrated by, among other things, filing an affidavit with the complaint confirming that pre-suit notice was properly served.

In the case decided today, the plaintiff, Richard Thurmond, served pre-suit notice by certified mail 60 days in advance of the filing of the suit, but did not file an affidavit with his complaint confirming such service. The defendants, Mid-Cumberland Infectious Disease Consultants and Dr. Simi Vincent, asked the trial court to dismiss the case on the ground that the statute mandated filing the affidavit with the complaint. However, the defendants did not deny receiving pre-suit notice or claim prejudice from the lack of an affidavit. Believing the statute required the affidavit, the trial court “reluctantly” dismissed the lawsuit, and the Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal but characterized the result as “harsh.”

The Supreme Court reversed. Justice Cornelia A. Clark writing for the Court noted that the plaintiff satisfied “the ‘fundamental’ and essential purpose of the pre-suit notice statute” by timely providing pre-suit notice to the defendants. Because strict compliance with the affidavit requirement is not “essential to avoid prejudicing an opposing litigant,” the Court determined that the requirement may be satisfied by substantial compliance.

The Court ruled that the plaintiff had substantially complied with the affidavit requirement by stating in his complaint that pre-suit notice had been timely served, by providing a disc with images five days after filing his complaint that established that pre-suit notice had been timely served by certified mail, and by filing an affidavit less than three months after filing his complaint confirming timely service of pre-suit notice by certified mail.

The case will now return to the trial court for further proceedings.




Whitfield County Installs New Kiosk For Renewing Car Tags

A new kiosk for renewing car tags is being installed at the Walnut Avenue Kroger through the Georgia Department of Revenue and Whitfield County Tax Commissioner’s Office. That location, instead of the Cleveland Highway Kroger, was chosen after a study by the kiosk company discovered the most residents, by far, live nearby. “For several years, I’ve been trying to get the state ... (click for more)

Carolyn Hardy To Keynote The Urban League's 4th Annual Entrepreneur Power Luncheon

The Urban League of Greater Chattanooga, Comcast and UPS will bring the Fourth Annual Entrepreneur Power Luncheon to Chattanooga’s business community on Tuesday, April 26, at 11:30 a.m. at the Chattanoogan Hotel. The event will feature pioneer businesswoman Carolyn Hardy, while celebrating the Scenic City’s ongoing entrepreneurial growth. Ms. Hardy is the CEO of Chism Hardy ... (click for more)

Charges Will Not Be Filed Against Officers In Javario Eagle Case

District Attorney General Neal Pinkston said Wednesday he will not file charges against the six Chattanooga Police Department officers involved in the Dec. 12, 2015, fatal shooting of Javario Eagle.  His office said, "An investigation conducted by the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office found use of deadly force by officers Lorin Johnston, Allen Griffith, Tim McFarland, Mitchell ... (click for more)

Medal Of Honor Museum Hopes To Finally Find Permanent Home At Coolidge Park

Officials of the National Medal of Honor Museum said Wednesday they hope to finally find a permanent home at Coolidge Park. Bill Raines said it is planned to build a two-story, 6,800-square-foot domed museum on two acres at the park. It will be dedicated to Medal of Honor recipient Charles H. Coolidge, who is now 94. There will be a sculpture of Mr. Coolidge - for whom the ... (click for more)

Rick Smith Should Not Be Paid To Leave

Taxpayers of Hamilton County should take note that a majority of the members of the school board are getting ready to give Rick Smith the buyout that he wants.  Do you agree that someone should be paid for taking the coward's way out?  Rick Smith should be fired for cause. Not paid to leave.   If you don't want the board members to pay him off, call or ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Grab The Reaching Hand

Three of Tennessee’s largest four cities are now searching for school superintendents. Jesse Register retired last June and, after botching the first attempt, Nashville city leaders are intensely helping the Board of Education in a search for the best candidate. In Knoxville and Chattanooga the superintendents have resigned, both under a cloud, and now the leaders of the ‘2.0’ initiative ... (click for more)