Score One For The Good Guys

Thursday, September 4, 2014

I had heard it all before: we have finally got everybody in a room, and we are all working on a common mission to “fix public education.” That was more or less the idea behind the State Collaborative on Reforming Education (SCORE). More precisely, they said the objective is to support Tennessee’s work to prepare students for college and the workforce. The key to that equation is defining exactly who Tennessee is. Is Tennessee the president? The governor? The federal government? Philanthropists? The Gates Foundation? The Tennessee General Assembly? The Commissioner? The Department of Education? Textbook Companies? The business community? Educators? Parents? Students? All the above? None of the above?  

What starts with good intentions may do as much harm as malevolence if understanding is lacking. As economist Timothy Taylor stated: “There is great comfort in feeling that those with whom we disagree are corrupted by politics or profit-seeking or darker motives while our own intentions are of luminescent purity.”
 
If there is a meeting or coalition to which we can add value or substance to help public education, support educators in that task, or improve student achievement, then Professional Educators of Tennessee wants to be included to represent our nearly 8,000 members. However, as I started looking around, I realized, outside of the teacher’s union, there was nobody at SCORE to represent actual public school classroom teachers. And even then, the union was out numbered 28-1. Like us, invited to the dance as long as we sat in the corner and kept our mouths shut – something that is highly unlikely when I am involved. 
 
We are not going to merely roll-over and pretend the smoke and mirrors hide our legitimate concern. We need to have an honest debate in Tennessee about public education and reforms that were ushered in by our acceptance of Race to the Top federal funding. We also need public discourse on the serious issue of growing federal involvement in our state and local school districts. That prompted me to send a fairly pointed letter to Jamie Woodson, the former state senator who directs SCORE’s efforts. 
 
In our letter to Ms. Woodson, we questioned SCORE’s lobbying effort, which may be damaging to public school educators or overshadow their voices of concern or suggestions to improve public education. We are concerned about the amount of money being spent in political campaigns in Tennessee. We fear that it is having a detrimental impact upon public education in our state. We sought clarity with a Political Action Committee, Advance Tennessee, which is a perceived front group for the SCORE organization. We also shared our trepidation about their paid Tennessee Educator Fellowship, and we asked whether SCORE intends to register these political operatives with the Tennessee Ethics Commission as lobbyists. Finally, we made an inquiry about the relevance of a daily news summary sent under the name of former Senator Bill Frist that frequently features articles that may serve more as a public relations vehicle for members of their steering committee or for issues that are not relevant to Tennessee. 
 
In asking for clarification, we also recognized that most of the people instrumental in designing our teacher evaluation systems, teacher training guidelines, and articulating the types of standards that need to be taught in our classrooms have never been teachers themselves. More importantly, they didn’t send their own children to public schools. Like Andrew Breitbart said:  “Truth isn’t mean. It’s truth.”
 
Public educators have continuing misgivings about the endless testing. We have had member reservations about the standards, namely implementation. Educators are tired of being seen as the sole reason student achievement may not meet some particular level or bearing the culpability for low performing school systems. Good intentions or not, something is terribly amiss when children are being educated chiefly to take tests. No single metric of success can accurately measure the impact of public education, and you cannot improve education by alienating the profession that carries it out. 
 
Despite political differences, both Republicans and Democrats love our state and our children. Our belief is that by working together in a non-partisan manner we can solve any educational challenges in Tennessee. It is time we stand together for integrity on behalf of public education and the hard working men and women who educate children in our state. We invite all stakeholders and policymakers to work toward that objective. That is our work, and it should be the work of all Tennesseans. 
 
We would like to rebuild our trust in SCORE at some point in the future. We will leave an open door for them. However, we genuinely hope they will contemplate the importance of engagement with actual public educators and integrity-based attributes such as treating educators well, listening to educators with differing points of view on what is best for students, and exhibiting ethical and transparent practices. 

JC Bowman, executive director of Professional Educators of Tennessee
 



Roy Exum: Sleep, Kelly’s On Watch

As the most intense week begins in President-elect Donald’s Trump’s ascent to become the most powerful man in the world, it is now strikingly obvious he has surrounded himself with the greatest collection of leaders to ever fill a Presidential cabinet. Each is a proven winner, be it in business, the military, or national affairs. Last week a confirmation hearing were heard for ... (click for more)

Shocked By Chief Robert Simpson's Replacement

After reading the article in today's TFP paper about the replacement of Chief Robert Simpson, I was shocked.  I  have had the privilege of knowing Chief Simpson for 25 years.  He is honest and a hard worker.  Reading the list of improvements made for the police department and the city's benefits from his hard work, I wonder what does the city want? We always ... (click for more)

Walker Charged With Sunday Night Murder Of Girlfriend In LaFayette

A 29-year-old Walker County man has been charged with murdering his girlfriend, also 29. Sheriff Steve Wilson said David Ryan Walker was charged in the slaying of Candace Ann Hankins. He said she was killed inside a house on Wheeler Road in LaFayette and her body was found in woods behind the house. The sheriff said Walker called relatives to express remorse about the killing. ... (click for more)

Man With Gun Runs From Police At Hamilton Place Mall; Pushes Shoppers Out Of The Way

A man who was found to be armed with a handgun was chased by police early Saturday afternoon. He pushed shoppers out of the way during the pursuit, which included racing down an escalator.   Erwin J. Rogers, 22, of 6111 Nottingham Dr., is facing multiple charges.    Around 1:50 p.m., Chattanooga Police officers working at the Hamilton Place Mall ... (click for more)

Shulman Leads McCallie Past Calhoun In MLK Hoops

The inaugural MLK King of the Court day of basketball action at UTC’s Maclellan Gym is now in the books and there were some pretty good games despite only one of the five games being relatively close. The GPS Bruisers came from behind to beat Van Buren County by a 51-45 final, but the average margin of victory for the other four games was a whopping 26.25 points. Those other ... (click for more)

Warren Replaces Martinez As Vols Secondary Coach

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. --  The Tennessee football program announced Monday that Charlton Warren  has agreed to terms to become the defensive backs coach for the Vols. Warren served as defensive backs coach at North Carolina the last two seasons and also has spent time on the Nebraska and Air Force coaching staffs. Willie Martinez  will not be returning after ... (click for more)