Pair Get Federal Supervised Release, $12,821 In Restitution For Taking Civil War Shell From Battle Creek

  • Friday, June 12, 2015
Hotchkiss shell
Hotchkiss shell

Two men have been sentenced to two years of supervised release and ordered to each make $12,821.83 in restitution in connection with taking a Civil War shell from the mouth of Battle Creek near the Tennessee River at South Pittsburg.

Michael Tarpley and William "Butch" Shirley appeared before Federal Judge Curtis Collier.

They pleaded guilty to excavating archaeological resources from public lands without authority in violation of federal law.

Kenneth Fagin and Terry Tate are to be sentenced on July 30.

Charges were dismissed against Victor Holmes.

Prosecutors said the defendants took a Civil War Hotchkiss shell from the site of Fort McCook. A Hotchkiss shell is a three-inch-long armament from the Civil War.

Prosecutors said the group learned of the existence of Civil War artifacts at the bottom of Battle Creek at the site of the fort as early as 2007.

The defendants did not have a permit issued under the Archaeological Resources Protection Act nor did they have authority from TVA to excavate artifacts from Battle Creek, it was stated.

 

 

 

Breaking News
Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report
  • 8/22/2025

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report. (If your case is dismissed, just email us your name and date we ran it and we will promptly take off. Email to news@chattanoogan.com ) BEARD,BRYANT ... more

2nd Student Charged In Connection To Wednesday's Arrest At East Hamilton High School
  • 8/21/2025

Following further investigation into the firearm recovered on campus during Wednesday’s incident at East Hamilton High School, a second student has been identified and charged in connection with ... more

Tennessee American Water Invests Over $5 Million In Lookout Valley River Crossing
  • 8/21/2025

Tennessee American Water is investing over $5 million in a critical infrastructure project that will install 7,200 feet of 16-inch pipe to enhance water system reliability and service in the ... more