Isn't That Special: Notre Dame Knocks Off Knox Grace 32-29 In Playoffs

Irish Score On Kickoff Return, Blocked Punt, Interception Return

Friday, November 10, 2017 - by Larry Fleming
A leaping Trea Johnson (25) and Caleb Edwards (8) celebrate after Johnson blocked a Grace Christian punt that teammate Monroe Beard recovered in the end zone for a second-quarter touchdown Friday night. The Irish won 32-29.
A leaping Trea Johnson (25) and Caleb Edwards (8) celebrate after Johnson blocked a Grace Christian punt that teammate Monroe Beard recovered in the end zone for a second-quarter touchdown Friday night. The Irish won 32-29.
- photo by Dennis Norwood

Notre Dame’s offense struggled to find the end zone Friday night against Grace Christian of Knoxville.

Thank goodness the Irish special teams and defense played lights out.

Cameron Wynn returned a kickoff 82 yards. Touchdown.

Trea Johnson blocked a punt and Monroe Beard recovered in the end zone.


Justyn Baker had a 63-yard interception return. Touchdown.

Hunter Hill kicked a 29-yard field goal that turned into the winnings points.

Those big plays enabled Notre Dame (10-1) to beat the visiting Rams 32-29 at Jim Eberle Field in a TSSAA Division II-2A quarterfinal showdown.

“Once again, our kids were resilient and made the plays they needed to make and we just held on,” Irish coach Charles Fant said. “That was playoff football at its finest between two great teams.”

Notre Dame wound up with three picks, one each by Beard, Baker and Kolby McGowan. Beard and Wynn had sure interceptions slip through their fingers.

Jeffery Watkins scored on a 1-yard run for the Irish offense’s only TD.

The Irish, who beat the Rams 35-27 during the regular season, advanced to the semifinals next week and will host Christ Presbyterian Academy (10-2), which defeated Knoxville Webb 22-7.

The other semifinal showdown pits Lausanne (11-0) and Battle Ground Academy (11-1).

While Notre Dame is 6-8 all-time in the quarterfinal round, it has yet to win in five previous tries in the semifinals.

The five previous trips to the semifinals have proven futile for Notre Dame. The Irish lost to Maryville 21-14 in 1978; lost to Briarcrest 42-20 in 2004; dropped a 48-34 shootout against Livingston Academy in 2005 and then lost to Alcoa  28-19 (2014) and 42-2 (2015).

The Irish, who have won nine straight games since losing to Baylor, 42-21, in the season opener, is hoping a sixth try at a semifinal win may finally unlock the door to the championship game.

Special team play paid dividends with Notre Dame’s first TD midway through the second quarter. The Irish forced a punt from the Rams’ 31. Johnson took advantage of a path-clearing block by teammate Jalen Derrick, broke though the protection, stuck his arm up and blocked Ryan Medders’ kick.

The ball bounded into the touchdown and in a mad scramble in a gridiron scrum Beard came up with the football, giving the Irish the early lead.

“We practiced our punt block during the week and called it ‘Gracey,’ ” Beard said. “Jalen pushed his guy to the left and cleared the way and I had a clean shot and I recovered the ball in the end zone.”

The Rams retaliated with an 81-yard, seven-play drive that was capped by Jonah Duggins’ catch on a 30-yard pass from Luke Kirby.

Fourteen seconds later, Wynn crossed the goal line after zipping through the entire Rams coverage unit for a TD that gave the lead back to the Irish at 15-6 with 3:05 left in the first half.

An Irish drive to start the second half ended when Caleb Edward fumbled after a short gain and Grace Christian’s Jackson Daniel recovered at Notre Dame’s 43.

On the next play, Baker stepped in front of a Rams receiver, snagged the interception and bolted 63 yards, extending the Irish lead to 22-6.

“We were playing zone against their strong passing game,” Baker said. “We dropped back in coverage and a safety over the top made my job a whole lot easier. The quarterback stared down the receiver, I got underneath the route, made the catch and got some blocks. House call.”

Back came the Rams, unleashing an 80-yard, 10-play march. Kirby connected on a 20-yard TD strike to Eli Nordhorn and that same duo converted the two-point try. The Rams trailed 22-15.

The Notre Dame offense finally got in on the scoring parade.

The Irish, aided by a personal foul (targeting) penalty, went 60 yards in seven plays and Watkins punched it in from 1 yard out. Notre Dame again had breathing room at 29-14.

As the game flipped into the fourth quarter, Notre Dame, who will be making their third semifinal appearance since 2014, quickly moved 58 yards, but the drive stalled. On fourth down, Hunter Hill kicked a crucial field goal to push the margin to 32-18.

The Rams immediately struck back, thanks to a 52-yard Kirby-to-Nordhorn. Cody Estep scored on the next play, a 4-yard burst into the end zone. That cut the Irish’s lead to32-22.

The next Notre Dame drive fizzled at the Rams 47 and Grace Christian blocked a punt and took over at its own 42. That opportunity went out the window on McGowan’s interception.

Grace’s final possession started on the Irish 33 with 59.4 seconds remaining.

Benefitting from an unsportsmanlike penalty on the Irish, the Rams quickly scored on Kirby’s short toss to Estep. The point-after kick pulled Grace to within three points with 17.6 seconds left.

The late penalty could have turned into a disaster.

“Absolutely,” Fant said. “We talk about keeping your composure, we preach those things. We know emotions run high in games like this and they’re kids. They made bone-headed mistakes. We’ve got to keep working on those things.”

When Johnson came up with his grab on the pooch kick, the Irish were able to breathe easy for the first time all night.

“We didn’t want our season to end,” Johnson said, “especially for our 16 seniors. We’re trying to keep this thing going.”


Grace Christian                   0 6 8 15 – 29

Notre Dame                          0 15 14 3 – 32

Second Quarter

ND – Monroe Beard recovered block punt in end zone (Cameron Wynn run), 6:02

GC – Jonah Duggins 30 pass from Luke Kirby (pass failed), 3:19

ND – Wynn 82 kickoff return (Hunter Hill kick), 3:05

Third Quarter

ND – Justyn Baker 63 interception return (Hill kick), 8:31

GC – Eli Nordhorn 20 pass from Kirby (Nordhorn pass from Kirby), 4:30

ND – Jeffery Watkins 1 run (Hill kick), 3:15

Fourth Quarter

ND – FG Hill 29, 8:17

GC – Cody Estep 9 run (Kirby run), 7:29

GC – Estep 19 pass from Kirby (Luke Smith kick), 17.6

(Contact Larry Fleming at and on Twitter @larryfleming44)

Alex Flemister (53) of Notre Dame congratulates Justyn Baker (6) following Baker's 3-yard 63-yard interception return for a touchdown in a 32-29 TSSAA quarterfinal playoff victory over Grace Christian at Jim Eberle Field.
Alex Flemister (53) of Notre Dame congratulates Justyn Baker (6) following Baker's 3-yard 63-yard interception return for a touchdown in a 32-29 TSSAA quarterfinal playoff victory over Grace Christian at Jim Eberle Field.
- Photo2 by Dennis Norwood

John Shearer: Remembering The 1977 Baylor Football Team, Part 2 – Becoming State Bound

Forty years ago this fall, my Baylor School teammates and I were determined to help the Red Raiders return to a top position in Chattanooga high school football after a disappointing season of 5-5 in 1976.   Beginning in seventh grade, many of us had not only witnessed and cheered on some outstanding Baylor varsity teams under coach E.B. “Red” Etter from the stands, but ... (click for more)

Boykin, Carr Win Black Knight Wrestling Invite Titles

Seniors Scottie Boykin and Bryce Carr bounced back from losses in Friday’s dual against No. 8 Virginia Tech by posting impressive wins at the Black Knight Invite in West Point, N.Y., today.  The Mocs had 12 of their 15 entries place in the tournament hosted by Army West Point.   Boykin improved to 8-1 with two decision and an 8-0 major over Binghampton’s Mark Tracy ... (click for more)

Spring Creek Elementary Closed Monday And Tuesday Due To Fire In Boiler Room

There was a fire early Monday around  4 a.m.  in the boiler room at Spring Creek Elementary School causing the school to be closed Monday and Tuesday.    Damage from the fire was contained to the boiler room but the utilities to the building are also in the damaged boiler area which left the school without power, heat and other necessities to have ... (click for more)

Tony Williams, 26, Shot On Dodson Avenue Late Sunday Night

Tony Williams, 26, was shot late Sunday night on Dodson Avenue. Chattanooga Police responded at 11:50 p.m.,  to the 900 block of Dodson Avenue on a shooting.   Upon arrival, police located the victim who was suffering from a non-life threatening gunshot wound. HCEMS responded and transported the victim to a nearby hospital. The victim advised police that the ... (click for more)

Pollution For Profit?

Why should Chattanooga allow special interests to boost sediment pollution in our South Chickamauga Creek? To pad their profit margin and pass that cost on to city taxpayers? If your city council votes to reduce the storm water regulations – that is the result we can expect. Special interest homebuilders profit, but citizens pay.  More sediment pollution and paid for with ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: America’s ‘Shush’ Fund

Michael Reagan, the son of one of our nation’s greatest presidents, wrote a wonderful op-ed piece on Sunday that explained why he believes the women who have stepped forward to allege they were once abused by Judge Roy Moore. He wrote that when he, a political consultant, is asked why the women waited 40 years to bring up the charges, “I tell them I didn’t reveal my sexual abuse ... (click for more)