Tennessee Supreme Court Rules On Required Notice For Enhanced Sentence

Thursday, November 30, 2017

The Tennessee Supreme Court reinstated a life sentence without the possibility of parole that defendant Kevin Patterson received under Tennessee’s three strikes law for his conviction of attempted second degree murder. The defendant argued the State did not provide him with the required pre-trial notice that it planned to use his prior convictions to obtain an enhanced sentence. The Supreme Court held while the notice was imperfect, the defendant was not prejudiced by the errors.  

The defendant’s most recent convictions were based on an incident that occurred in Coffee County in 2013, during which the defendant shot a man and struck the man’s girlfriend.  The incident was apparently a continuation of an earlier argument the defendant had with the couple.  

The State gave the defendant pre-trial notice of its intent to ask the trial court to sentence him as a repeat violent offender and listed a number of the defendant’s prior convictions, including two prior convictions that were the basis of the repeat violent offender sentencing enhancement.  However, the State’s notice failed to specify which of the defendant’s prior convictions qualified him for sentencing as a repeat violent offender, and it misidentified the date of the defendant’s prior conviction of facilitation of second degree murder and the county of origin of the defendant’s prior second degree murder conviction.   

The defendant did not challenge the sufficiency of the State’s notice in the trial court and actually stipulated to the accuracy of his prior criminal record in the trial court.  The trial court agreed that the defendant qualified as a repeat violent offender and imposed a life sentence. The defendant did not challenge the sufficiency of the State’s notice on appeal, but the Court of Criminal Appeals on its own initiative set aside the defendant’s life sentence. The majority concluded that the State’s notice was so defective that it did not count as notice at all.  The dissenting judge would have held that, although imperfect, the notice sufficiently apprised the defendant of the State’s intent to seek enhanced sentencing and that the defendant had not been prejudiced by the deficiencies.  The Supreme Court agreed with the dissenting judge.  

The Supreme Court reiterated that Tennessee law requires the State to provide pre-trial notice of its intent to seek enhanced sentencing and precludes the State from doing so if it fails entirely to provide the defendant with notice. The Supreme Court emphasized that the State actually had provided pre-trial notice of its intent to seek enhanced sentencing in this case, even though the notice was deficient in some respects.  The Supreme Court concluded the defendant was not entitled to relief under the plain error doctrine because he had failed to establish any prejudice resulting from the deficient notice and actually had stipulated to the accuracy of his criminal record.  The Supreme Court reinstated the trial court’s judgment sentencing the defendant to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. 

To read the unanimous opinion in State v. Patterson, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.



TBI Releases Annual Statewide Crime Study, Revealing Increases Across Tennessee

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation released its 2017 ‘Crime in Tennessee’ report on Friday, revealing a slight overall increase in reported instances of crime in the most recent reporting year. The annual study compiles data reported from each law enforcement agency in the state through the Tennessee Incident Based Reporting System (TIBRS). The TBI’s sophisticated crime ... (click for more)

Reliance Partners Announces New V.P. Of Risk Services, John Seidl

Reliance Partners announced the addition of John Seidl as V.P. of Risk Services. Mr. Seidl is recognized as a leading expert in DOT commercial transportation compliance.   As a former Wisconsin State Motor Carrier Trooper and FMCSA investigator with more than 20 years of experience in risk services, Mr. Seidl is well-versed in the transportation insurance space. He ... (click for more)

Robert Gillisse Was Pilot Killed In Plane Crash At Collegedale Airport

The pilot who was killed in a plane crash on the runway of the Collegedale Airport on Friday evening has been identified as Robert Gillisse, 62, of Ooltewah . Charles Swain, who is the director of the airport, said the plane was a total loss. It was a single-occupant plane. He said the plane was taking off when it crashed. He said Mr. Gillisse frequently had flown out of ... (click for more)

East Ridge To Build Open-Air Pavilion Near City Hall

East Ridge plans to construct an open-air pavilion that will include restrooms and a concession area near City Hall and the old McBrien School.  It will be part of a Town Center for East Ridge at the Tombras Avenue property. The city is also applying for a $500,000 grant to help convert Pioneer Park into a refurbished park with a splash pad. The firm of Hefferlin and ... (click for more)

A Tribute For My Brother – Sgt. Jonathan Gardner, U.S. Army

Seven years ago today, my family and I found out that my brother, Sgt. Jonathan D. Gardner, was seriously injured by a roadside bomb, (explosively formed penetrator - EFP), while on a mission in Kuwait. The EFP went through the bottom of his seat and put a softball size hole in his upper thigh. The doctors said that if the bomb had entered the Humvee an inch to the right, he ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

All of us who marvel at the sound of bagpipes at a funeral realize the majesty that people like piper Scottie Maclellan can lend to any “homecoming” and for years there has been a wonderful tale out of Nova Scotia that leads this week’s parade of The  Saturday  Funnies. Mind you, I do not write these stories, as many who have followed man’s laughter down through the ... (click for more)