A Word Against Nathan Bedford Forrest

Friday, December 29, 2017

On Dec. 20, the infamous statue of Nathan Bedford Forrest was removed from Memphis’s Health Science Park (formerly known as Nathan Bedford Forrest Park). On the night of Dec. 26, the Forrest statue off I-65 was vandalized.  

Tennessee is confronting its Confederate past from many angles and to many different ends. We struggle with how to interpret our past as we struggle with how to treat one another in uncertain times. Nathan Bedford Forrest’s centrality to this discourse about identity should not be surprising. There are few figures whose historical memories have benefited more from Lost Cause revisionist history than Forrest. 

There are also few men who relished as greatly in violence and despotism as him. Forrest would say “war means fighting and fighting means killing” and killing was Forrest’s greatest talent.  

The work of remembering our history can be to determine how the actions and the values of past Tennesseans resonate with us, Tennesseans of the present. After all, we say we celebrate our heritage. We say that old times here are not forgotten.  

I think Thomas Latham, the Memphis coal-mining baron, knew this when he paid for the construction of the Memphis statue in 1904. I think Jack Kershaw, famed white nationalist attorney of Dr. Martin Luther King’s murderer, knew this when he designed the I-65 statue in 1998.  

What values do we see in Nathan Bedford Forrest that we allow these statues to stand?  

Much has been written about Nathan Bedford Forrest as a slaver. He was one of the wealthiest men in Tennessee because he traded black Southerners as chattel. Much has been written about Nathan Bedford Forrest as Klan Grand Wizard. We have the words of Ku Klux co-founders and Forrest’s own coy interviews with journalists in 1868 for those arguments. There are other, less discussed moments in Forrest’s life. He murdered two men in an extrajudicial assassination in 1841. In 1871, Forrest reopened one of his plantations as a convict-lease farm, a system that would be abolished for its brutality in 1893.  

But when I think of the man, I remember his killing. What values do we see in the man who oversaw the murder of surrendering United States soldiers at Fort Pillow? In April of 1864, black and white Tennesseans, men who had chosen to fight for their liberty, lay dead along a Mississippi River “dyed with the blood of the slaughtered for 200 yards”. The massacre of 6th U.S. Artillery (Colored), Bradford’s Battalion, Tennessee Cavalry, and the 2nd U.S. Artillery (Colored) is recounted in the testimonies of Tennessee soldiers at the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War and in the words of Forrest’s own soldiers.  

In a personal letter to his sister, Sgt. Achilles V. Clark of the Confederate 20th Tennessee recounts that “The slaughter was awful. Words cannot describe the scene. The poor, deluded Negroes would run up to our men, fall upon their knees , and uplifted hands scream for mercy but they were ordered to their feet and shot down… I with several others tried to stop the butchery… but Gen. Forrest ordered them shot down like dogs and the carnage continued.”  

The violence was motivated by race. A reporter from a Confederate newspaper recounted that “the whites received quarter, but the Negroes were shown no mercy”.  

Private George Shaw, one of the black Tennesseans who survived the massacre, testified “I said. ‘Don’t shoot me.’ One of them said, ‘Go out and hold my horse.’ I made a step or two and he said ‘Turn around: I will hold my horse, and shoot you, too’… than he shot me in the face. I feel down as if I was dead. He shot me again, and hit my arm, not my head.” 

Forrest later said, “It is hoped that these facts will demonstrate to the Northern people that Negro soldiers cannot cope with Southerners.”  

Few Forrest apologists would rationalize the slaughter of U.S. soldiers in any other context. Why, then, is Forrest an exception? Why does he deserve to be memorialized in our cities and in our State Capitol when he murdered Tennessee men who were fighting for their own liberty?  

The massacre at Fort Pillow is a moment for which Forrest was never repentant. Even in his famous Pole-Bearers speech in 1875, Forrest never repents his slaving, his crimes, or his reopening of plantations in the form of convict-leasing. He simply accepted the new reality and hoped that his crimes would be ignored. 

Thomas Latham and Jack Kershaw ignored the crimes, depicting a gallant Forrest on horseback and ready for war and for killing. The killing that happened at Fort Pillow was criminal. What values do we hold that we ignore that too? 

Jefferson Hodge


Jeff Styles Tainting The Jury Pool - And Response

I have not participated in the poll or gone to the Jeff Styles blog / website to hear all about what happened as he believes it happened. I have seen the initial reporting and other news reports. I agree with several that have written in suggesting to Jeff that he shut up and listen to his lawyers.  But I have heard Jeff when he was on the radio and being quiet is not in his ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

I have to admit I am still laughing over the fact over 350 newspapers ganged up against President Trump’s stance on Thursday that the media is biased towards his administration. In a concerted effort these newspaper editors proved Trump to be exactly right. How in the name of common sense could any man, event, or natural phenomena cause every newspaper to unite is such a laughable ... (click for more)

Authorities Say Hixson Man Shot And Killed His 15-Year-Old Son On Saturday Night; Also Killed Family Dog

Authorities said a Hixson man shot and killed his 15-year-old son on Saturday night. A report says Mike McElrath, who was found naked at a neighbor's house, also killed the family dog. County deputies responded at 10:24 p.m. to 1846 Cotter Road. The residents said there was a man on their front porch who said he was "butt naked" and said "there's blood everywhere." They ... (click for more)

Wall Collapses At Home On Bradford Place Drive

Chattanooga firefighters were dispatched to a structural collapse call shortly after  10 a.m. on Saturday .   When firefighters arrived at 307 Bradford Place Drive, a large hole could be seen on one side of the house. Battalion Chief Don Bowman said an exterior wall collapsed into the basement. There was some initial concern that an elderly resident might ... (click for more)

Host Baylor 3-0 In Invitational Soccer Tournament

The Baylor girls soccer team won three games this past weekend in their own invitational tournament.   On Friday, Baylor beat Independence 2-0 in a game that was suspended due to lightning at the half.   Allya Cooper scored off an assist from Ara Rhodes and Mya McGee scored off an assist from Cambell Green.   Peyton Randolph earned the shutout ... (click for more)

CCS Wins Hixson Volleyball Tournament

The CCS volleyball team improved to 7-0 on the season winning the Hixson tournament.   CCS beat Red Bank, East Ridge and Rhea County in pool play and then beat host Hixson 25-11, 25-15 in the semifinals. In the championship game CCS beat Upperman 25-22, 25-16.    AJ Johnson and Savannah Ricketts led the team with 25 kills each.  Rachel Kay had 52 assists ... (click for more)