Supreme Court Rules On Admissibility Of Evidence

Obtained Pursuant To A Parole Search

Tuesday, August 7, 2018

The Tennessee Supreme Court has reversed part of a Court of Criminal Appeals’ decision suppressing evidence in a case involving individuals on supervised release and has affirmed the suppression of evidence against a third party who resided with them.    

Janet Stanfield, who was serving a community corrections sentence, Tony Winsett, who was on parole, and Janet Stanfield’s adult son, Justin Stanfield, lived together in a residence in Union City, Tennessee.  Justin Stanfield was not on any form of supervised release.  Acting upon information received from a confidential informant, law enforcement officers conducted a warrantless parole search of the residence based on Winsett’s parolee status.  Officers were aware that both Janet and Justin Stanfield resided with him. 

When officers arrived at the residence, they knocked on two doors, but the knocks went unanswered. Based upon observations made at the residence, officers entered through the front door of the residence, where they immediately detected a “very strong odor of marijuana.”  Officers noted three bedrooms with open doors and quickly ascertained which of the bedrooms belonged to whom.  Officers seized a weapon, ammunition, drug paraphernalia, and methamphetamine from the bedroom shared by Winsett and Janet Stanfield.  In Justin Stanfield’s bedroom, an officer found a jar that contained marijuana concealed inside a wooden television stand, as well as a weapon and ammunition. 

Meanwhile, officers noticed Justin Stanfield’s vehicle drive past the residence, and they left to conduct a traffic stop of his car.  At that time, Justin Stanfield provided information that led officers to another location to conduct an undercover narcotics transaction.  During the ensuing narcotics operation, Winsett and Janet Stanfield drove past.  Officers pursued the vehicle, and after a chase, the driver, Winsett, finally stopped.  A search of Janet Stanfield yielded four alprazolam tablets and currency. 

An Obion County Grand Jury jointly indicted Winsett and Janet Stanfield for drug and weapons offenses.  Winsett was indicted for attempting to elude a law enforcement officer.  Janet Stanfield and Justin Stanfield were separately indicted for drug offenses.  Prior to trial, defendants filed motions to suppress the evidence obtained as a result of the warrantless search.  The trial court suppressed the evidence against all three defendants and dismissed the indictments.   The State appealed to the Court of Criminal Appeals, which affirmed the rulings of the trial court.

The Tennessee Supreme Court granted the State’s application for permission to appeal in this case to consider the relative expectations of privacy enjoyed by individuals granted supervised release from incarceration—including those on parole, probation, community corrections, or someone residing with such an individual.    

The Court held that the parole search of Winsett was a “status” search based on his status as a parolee and was therefore permissible, notwithstanding a finding of probable cause or reasonable suspicion.  The fact that Winsett was not home at the time did not affect the constitutionality of the search.  Second, the search of Winsett’s/Janet Stanfield’s bedroom, including items that clearly belonged to her, was permissible pursuant to the doctrine of common authority, which represents an expansion of this doctrine to apply to status searches. 

Finally, also applying common authority, the Court held that the search of Justin Stanfield’s private bedroom was not encompassed by the doctrine, absent a showing of common access and usage by the other residents of the household.  Therefore, the Court reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals’ suppression of evidence against Winsett and Janet Stanfield and affirmed the suppression of evidence against Justin Stanfield. 

Justice Sharon G. Lee filed a separate opinion dissenting in part and concurring in the judgment of the Court. In her view, Mr. Winsett’s parolee status should not subject him, Ms. Stanfield, and her son, Justin Stanfield, to a warrantless and suspicionless search. Rather, she contends, Article I, section 7 of the Tennessee constitution requires the police to have reasonable suspicion before searching a parolee without a warrant. After reviewing the facts, Justice Lee concluded that the police did not have reasonable suspicion to search the Winsett/Stanfield home. Therefore, the evidence from the search should have been suppressed based on the violation of Mr. Winsett, Ms. Stanfield, and her son’s constitutional rights.

To read the majority opinion in State of Tennessee v. Janet Stanfield, authored by Justice Roger A. Page, and Justice Sharon G. Lee’s separate concurring and dissenting opinion, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


World Leader In Sales And Sales Leadership Unites With World Leader In Higher Education

Hundreds Of TVA Employees Volunteer At Day Of Serving Events

Startup Spectruss Sees Record Growth


Sales training methodologies developed by Sandler Training has been incorporated into Harvard Business School’s leadership curriculum. David Mattson, CEO of Sandler Training, has worked closely ... (click for more)

Nearly 400 TVA employees are volunteering to help local community organizations in the Chattanooga area as part of the TVA Employee Volunteer Program’s Day of Serving on Friday. TVA launched ... (click for more)

Spectruss, a full-service marketing agency based in the Chattanooga area continues rapid growth through its virtual CMO service that provides clients direct access to the expertise of an in-house ... (click for more)


Business

World Leader In Sales And Sales Leadership Unites With World Leader In Higher Education

Sales training methodologies developed by Sandler Training has been incorporated into Harvard Business School’s leadership curriculum. David Mattson, CEO of Sandler Training, has worked closely with Frank V. Cespedes, faculty chair for the Aligning Strategy and Sales executive program at Harvard Business School (HBS) as well as Mark Roberge, senior lecturer in the Entrepreneurial ... (click for more)

Hundreds Of TVA Employees Volunteer At Day Of Serving Events

Nearly 400 TVA employees are volunteering to help local community organizations in the Chattanooga area as part of the TVA Employee Volunteer Program’s Day of Serving on Friday. TVA launched a new Employee Volunteer Program this year in which employees can earn recognition certificates and corporate contributions to eligible charities for hours volunteered. On this Day of ... (click for more)

Breaking News

WWTA Releases Timetable That Would Have Ooltewah Sewage Treatment Plant In Operation By 2025; Public Meetings Set At Central High

The Hamilton County Water and Wastewater Treatment Authority has released a timetable that would have a new sewage treatment plant in Ooltewah in operation by 2025. A request for a site at Mahan Gap Road goes before the Planning Commission at Nov. 12 at 1 p.m. It goes to the County Commission Zoning Committee on Dec. 12 and the full commission on Dec. 19. The WWTA also ... (click for more)

Downtown Post Office Finally Getting Handicap Ramp

Chattanooga's Downtown Post Office, after some lawsuits and numerous complaints over the years, is finally getting a handicap ramp. Federal Judge Sandy Mattice said the complaints had increased in recent months and the General Services Administration agreed to fund the project at the historic building on Georgia Avenue. The judge said, "It's a beautiful building, but it's ... (click for more)

Opinion

Too Many Questions

First it was about 2,000, then we were told it’s up to 4,000. We have no way of knowing who’s coming or what their purpose is. NBC and CNN assure us they are seeking sanctuary but how can we know? Neither Honduras or our subjective media in America have been honest with us in the past. So, how do we know why that many people are marching across Central America? Then this morning ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: An Answer For Amy

Amy Schumer, whose cousin is Senate Minority leader Chuck Schumer, is said to be a very successful comedian and an activist of note. You may remember her most recent appearance was when she was arrested at the U.S. Capitol three weeks ago. She was part of a disgraceful mob who unlawfully protested the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh and the hunch is Amy wanted to get arrested so she ... (click for more)