Reappraisal Equals Redistribution Of Wealth

Tuesday, August 8, 2017

Here’s a simple and accurate explanation of the Hamilton County property reappraisal results. 

Picture three adjacent property owners–you and your two next door neighbors. One neighbor to your left, one to your right, and you in the middle. Imagine that the county assessor gives one of your neighbors a tax break. That’s easy enough, just by juggling the new appraisals. 

Now, the reappraisal is required by state law, and it must be ‘revenue neutral’–the total amount of property tax collected after reappraisal must be the same as it was before. (Yes, it could be manipulated to produce less tax revenue than before, but we know that’s not gonna happen.) 

So, in the very personal case of you and your two neighbors, if one of them gets a tax cut then you and the other neighbor have to make up the difference. Either you, or the other neighbor, or both of you have to pay more taxes now because one neighbor will be paying less than before. 

On a larger scale, for the entire county, half of the taxpayers got a break this year. And the other half must pay for that break. You and your neighbors may all pay less this year, at someone else’s expense. Or all three of you may have to pay for the windfalls that others got. But whenever one property owner benefits, others will get a larger tax bill to cover it. 

Think about it. The people who work for the county assessor have absolute, unilateral, arbitrary and irresistible legal power to take money from one property owner and give it to another. It is the government version of robbing Peter to pay Paul. The county never loses, and Paul never complains. 

In real terms, the latest reappraisal took money away from half of Hamilton County property owners and gave that same money to the other half of them. Even if your taxes only went up $10, that $10 was taken from you by law and given to someone else as a gift. If that isn’t a redistribution of wealth, what is it? Even if it’s legal, it’s still wrong. 

Here’s an example straight from county records online: One fortunate property owner received a new appraisal of $469,500 – only $1,600 more than last year – while many others got appraisal increases of tens of thousands of dollars. The immediate effect for that one taxpayer is a $300 reduction in his county property tax this year. But the rest of us have to make up for the $300 he’s saving, and for thousands of other similar cases as well. 

Oh – guess which lucky property owner is directly associated with the Assessor’s office?  

Think about it. Half of us should be legitimately (although helplessly) angry, while the other half just smile all the way to the bank with our money. 

It’s not right. 

Larry Cloud
Chattanooga



Roy Exum: Evil This Way Comes

There is a line in Act IV of William Shakespeare's Macbeth, as some of the 20,000 students at Middle Tennessee State are taught, that reads: "By the pricking of my thumbs / Something wicked this way comes." The professors explain that in the 16 th century the “pricking of thumbs” meant an intuition of evil about to happen and every student at MTSU knows several white supremacy ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: It’s All About People

The leaders of Hamilton County’s Mental Health Court held a heart-warming open house Friday afternoon and it was announced that just since February, the creation has saved the county over $3 million in incarceration costs. But to hear County Mayor Jim Coppinger or Judge Don Poole tell it, that’s not what is important. “Soon after the court started, a kind, quiet man I’ll ... (click for more)

Chattanoogan Hotel Sold By City To Lexington, Ky., Hospitality Group For $32 Million

The city has reached agreement to sell the Chattanoogan hotel for $32 million. The buyer is Schulte Hospitality Group of Lexington, Ky. The firm has 102 hotels in 26 states. Daisy Madison, city chief financial officer, said the proceeds would be enough to pay off all the city's remaining debt for building it. She said there had been interest in buying the hotel before, ... (click for more)

Janice Raper, 69, Killed In Accident On Lee Highway

Janice Raper, 69, was killed Sunday evening in a car accident on Lee Highway. Chattanooga Police responded at 7:54 p.m. to a traffic crash at 6800 Lee Highway. A Toyota Sienna, driven by Ms. Raper, was traveling northbound, attempting to make a left turn onto Hickory Valley Road.  A Dodge Challenger, driven by Charise Nash, 26, was traveling southbound on Lee Highway, ... (click for more)

UT Coach: Tennessee Not OK Being 3-4; Butch Jones Not OK Being 3-4

Embattled Tennessee football coach Butch Jones met with members of the media on Monday, a couple of days after the Vols lost to Alabama, 45-7. It was Tennessee’s fourth loss in five games and UT is an early 5 ½-point underdog to rival Kentucky on Saturday. The Vols are 31-1 against Kentucky since 1985, with the only loss, a 10-7 defeat, coming in 2011. Tennessee leads the overall ... (click for more)

No. 3 Georgia Bulldogs Aim To Break Losing Streak Against Florida In Jacksonville Saturday

On the surface, Georgia would seem to have a lot going for it heading into Saturday’s game against Florida in Jacksonville, a site that hasn’t been too kind for the team in red and black over the last quarter of a century. The third-ranked Bulldogs enter having won its last three games by an average margin of victory of 32.3 points. Florida needs a win to avoid its third ... (click for more)