Supreme Court Clarifies Procedures For Inmates Disputing Parole Eligibility

Friday, May 25, 2012

In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court clarified the procedures an inmate must follow to dispute the determination of parole eligibility for consecutive sentences. 

The case arose when Danny A. Stewart was convicted in 2002 of multiple drug-related offenses and received an aggregate sentence of 42 years at 30 percent. The Tennessee Department of Correction (TDOC) calculated his release eligibility date as March 8, 2010. After the Tennessee Board of Probation and Parole (BOPP) denied him parole, Stewart filed a petition for common law writ of certiorari naming TDOC and BOPP, among others.

He argued that BOPP should have conducted custodial parole hearings and that TDOC should have assigned a release eligibility date to each of his sentences, rather than a single release eligibility date for the aggregate sentence.

Today, the Tennessee Supreme Court clarified that TDOC and BOPP are separate entities with distinct roles. TDOC is responsible for calculating release eligibility dates, and BOPP decides whether to release inmates on parole. Inmates may obtain judicial review of these decisions, but the procedure differs.

To gain review of TDOC’s decision, an inmate must first seek a declaratory order from TDOC before filing an action in court. An inmate may challenge BOPP’s decision in court by filing a petition for a common law writ of certiorari, but the court’s review will be very limited.

Stewart was denied relief on his claim against TDOC because he filed in court before seeking a declaratory order, and his claim against BOPP was dismissed because he failed to allege grounds for relief under the common law writ of certiorari.

To read the Danny A. Stewart v. Derrick D. Schofield, Commissioner, Tennessee Dept. of Corrections opinion authored by Chief Justice Cornelia A. Clark, visit http://www.tncourts.gov/sites/default/files/stewartd_opn.pdf.


Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report - And Mug Shots

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ALTMAN, KENNETH MARCUS     605 AUTUMN HARVEST LANE KODAK, 37764     43     Hamilton County          CONTEMPT OF COURT (NON SUPPORT) BALL, CHRISTINA JEAN     12475 DAYTON PIKE SALE CREEK, 37373     29 ... (click for more)

Sweeney On Trial In Federal Court For Alleged Sexually Explicit Facebook Messages With 13-Year-Old Girl

During the trial of a man accused of having sexually explicit Facebook conversations with a 13-year-old girl, it was revealed he told police, "I don't know any 13-year-old girl," but "a 17-year-old girl I might talk to." The trial is taking place in the courtroom of Federal Judge Sandy Mattice. Randy Sweeney, 49, was arrested after the young girl's mother called police. ... (click for more)

Dirt Decision At Camp Jordan May Come Back To Haunt East Ridge Councilmen

Wow. I thought the arrival of Bass Pro Shop would help bring East Ridge back to a position of prominence in the Chattanooga area, but the Council proved otherwise last night.  To the council - There is a reason that the developers want that dirt: It's valuable . You currently own it and the developer wants it. Bass Pro has already agreed to set up shop. They were going ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: I’m Certainly No Expert

Sometime on Monday night, after I had written a piece on getting swatted with a switch as a kid, I got an email from ESPN Canada asking if I would be a televised guest on “Off the Record,” the most watched daily sports show in Canada. The subject: corporal punishment in America. Are you kidding me? I am hardly an expert. All weekend my world of sports and its excitement was warped ... (click for more)

Boyd-Buchanan Whips Silverdale, 3-0, In 5-A Volleyball

The effects of losing six straight matches – a league loss to Grace Baptist and five in the Tennessee Tandem tournament – were still bothering Silverdale Baptist Academy in a District 5-A volleyball match at Boyd-Buchanan. But not nearly as much as the Lady Bucs’ sterling play. Boyd-Buchanan (23-13, 5-1 District 5-A), which also lost to Grace last Thursday, gained momentum ... (click for more)