Federal Appeals Court Upholds Sentences For Fillers, Mathis In SCT Asbestos Case

Monday, December 23, 2013

The U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld sentences against Donald Fillers and James Mathis in the Standard-Coosa-Thatcher plant asbestos case.

Federal Judge Curtis Collier in October 2012 gave Fillers a four-year prison term for his part in what his own attorney described as the "horrible debacle" on Watkins Street in Ridgedale.

Mathis, demolition firm owner, got 18 months in connection with an inadequate abatement of asbestos that resulted in a major governmental cleanup involving the EPA and others in 2005.

Foreman David Wood was given 20 months in prison. 

The judge also handed down fines and restitution in the case. The restitution amount was set at $27,899.10 each, including against the Watkins Street Project LLC. 

Fillers, 64 when he was sentenced, was also assessed fines of $20,000, $2,220 and $2,224. The corporation that he and his late brother, Gary Fillers, set up to buy the old yarn plant, was fined $30,000, $2,220 and $2,224.

Prosecutor Matthew Morrison of Knoxville had asked for "significant periods of incarceration to send out the message that this can't happen. People cannot just put jobs and profits over human health."

He said the deterrent effect of the sentence was important because he said inspectors are only able to go to about 25 percent of the demolition sites where there is asbestos and others "are on the honor system." The SCT site was discovered when inspector John Schultz of the Chattanooga Hamilton County Air Pollution Control Bureau happened by.

Click here to read the opinion.





Bibbs Gets 33-Month Federal Sentence On Gun Charge

A youth who police said was involved in a gang shooting while out on bond on a first-degree murder charge has been sentenced to serve 33 months in federal prison. Demetrius Demond Bibbs, identified as a member of the Black P Stone Bloods, appeared before Judge Curtis Collier. Bibbs earlier pleaded guilty to being a felon in possession of a weapon. Chattanooga Police last ... (click for more)

TBI Makes Arrests During Human Trafficking Crackdown

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation announced results of a week-long operation to better understand and combat human trafficking in Tennessee, including a number of arrests. With the partnership of the Brentwood Police Department, the Clarksville Police Department, and End Slavery Tennessee, TBI Agents embarked on an undercover operation to identify potential victims of trafficking, ... (click for more)

Shame On The Housing Authority

With Chattanooga and other cities around the nation struggling to find solutions to chronic homelessness it's cruel to evict families likely with children over a fight.   When you evict the adults you're also evicting any and all children in the household.  Intelligence would dictate looking for a root cause. Compassion would dictate looking for alternatives. Both ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: A Great Orthopedic Success

Mark Freeman, the chief of orthopedic surgery at Erlanger Hospital, shared a dazzling look at our area’s Level One Trauma Center Friday morning. Yet, as he described the dramatic changes that have occurred in just the past 12 months, the promise of what will happen within the next year was even more appealing. Believe this, our flagship hospital is getting well in a hurry. “If ... (click for more)

Baylor Beats GPS 6-4 For D-II Softball Title

MURFREESBORO – Oh, what a difference a year makes. The GPS Bruisers came through the losers bracket a year ago and beat Baylor twice after losing the first five times they played, but those two were the biggest as it gave the team in blue a state D-II softball championship. The situation was similar a year later, but the results a bit different as the Lady Red Raiders beat ... (click for more)

Dickson County Ousts Ooltewah, 6-5, In Epic 12-Inning Thriller

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – For Ooltewah, more heartbreak followed heartbreak. After a tough loss to Wilson Central on Thursday, the Lady Owls fought furiously with Dickson County in an epic 12-inning marathon Friday before the Lady Cougars’ Keely Buchanan laced a game-winning single up the middle to end  the game and Ooltewah's masterful season. Second-ranked Dickson County, ... (click for more)