State Supreme Court Rules Insurance Companies Cannot Depreciate Labor Costs In Insurance Payments For Property Damage

Monday, April 15, 2019

Tennessee Supreme Court addressed a certified question from the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee regarding whether an insurance company can depreciate the cost of labor when calculating actual cash value payments for property damage claims. 

The homeowners in this case had home insurance policies with Auto-Owners (Mutual) Insurance Company and suffered damage to their properties.  Under both of the policies presented in the lawsuit, the insurance company calculated the actual cash value of the damaged property by first calculating the replacement cost of the damaged property and then adjusting that number by depreciating both labor and material costs.  The homeowners filed suit and argued that the insurance company’s practice of depreciating labor costs was a breach of their contracts.  The insurance company countered that labor costs are depreciable under the terms of the policies. 

The Supreme Court determined that the language of the policies was ambiguous, that is, susceptible to two or more reasonable interpretations, regarding whether labor costs could be depreciated.  Under Tennessee law, when an insurance policy is ambiguous, the policy is construed against the insurance company as the author of the policy.  Consequently, the ambiguous policy language in this case had to be interpreted in favor of the homeowners, meaning that labor costs could not be depreciated when calculating actual cash value.

To read the unanimous opinion in Lammert, et al. v. Auto-Owners (Mutual) Insurance Company, authored by Justice Roger A. Page, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.



NRC Schedules Open House To Discuss Watts Bar Nuclear Power Plant Performance

New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Jelks Law Adds Women’s Advocate And Attorney Emily Ahlquist O’Donnell To Growing Practice


The Nuclear Regulatory Commission staff has scheduled an open house for May 9 to provide information and answer questions regarding the safety performance of the Watts Bar nuclear power plant, ... (click for more)

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: 1ST CLASS FLOORING LLC ANTHONY VECCHIO 4 FLOORING CONTRACTOR 705 MCCARTER RD LAFAYETTE GA 30728 A-Z INVESTMENTS,LLC ... (click for more)

Jelk’s Law, PLLC has tapped women’s advocate and attorney, Emily Ahlquist O’Donnell, as their fourth hire in just as many years. Ms. O’Donnell joins the growing Chattanooga-based boutique firm ... (click for more)


Business

NRC Schedules Open House To Discuss Watts Bar Nuclear Power Plant Performance

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission staff has scheduled an open house for May 9 to provide information and answer questions regarding the safety performance of the Watts Bar nuclear power plant, including the recent annual assessment letter covering all of 2018. The open house will run from 5-6 p.m. in the Spring City Municipal Building, 229 Front St., Spring City, Tn. NRC employees ... (click for more)

New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: 1ST CLASS FLOORING LLC ANTHONY VECCHIO 4 FLOORING CONTRACTOR 705 MCCARTER RD LAFAYETTE GA 30728 A-Z INVESTMENTS,LLC ALEC ANDERSON 3 PURCHASE DISTRESSED REAL ESTATE TO FLIP 106 FRAWLEY RD EAST RIDGE TN 37412 ADL POOLS LLC 4 POOL CONTRACTOR, CONSTRUCTION 3301 BRAINERD RD CHATTANOOGA TN 37411 AFTER ... (click for more)

Breaking News

SoCon Freshman Of The Year Who Left UTC Will Play For TCU

Kevin Easley, who announced he was leaving UTC after being named the Southern Conference Freshman of the Year, said he will be transferring to Texas Christian University. Easley will be eligible to play in the 2020-2021 season. He made the announcement on his personal Twitter account. Easley, at 6'6" and 223 pounds, was the first Chattanooga men's basketball student-athlete ... (click for more)

Dalton Police Department Seeks Suspects In Car Break-Ins

The Dalton Police Department is seeking help from the public to identify two men who broke into three vehicles parked at the Planet Fitness gym on Walnut Avenue. There have been several car break-ins in this parking lot over the past year because people using the gym often leave valuables inside of their cars instead of taking them inside. The suspects in these three break-ins ... (click for more)

Opinion

Why Does Walden Need A Large Grocery Store? - And Response (2)

The town of Walden has a population of 2,118 people. What do those citizens need with a 49,000 square foot grocery store? Or with 10,000 square feet of commercial office space? Or a fuel island? Or increased tractor trailer traffic with proportional damage to the road up and down the mountain? Or multiple traffic lights at the “W” Road intersection and at Timesville Road? When ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: This Ain’t Gonna’ Work

When Governor Bill Lee talks about education, or the lack of it, I’ll listen. He’s the guy who, when he found his newly-hired employees were wanting, his thriving Lee Company in Nashville started its own vocational school and paid them to learn. The investment was brilliant and the outcome obvious. But now comes the bigger gamble, vouchers for some and, for others, charter schools ... (click for more)