Reservations About The Signal Mountain School Split

Monday, December 4, 2017

The first time most of us were aware that there was an effort to split Signal schools off from HCDE, and gain control of the buildings, was after the last election.  It’s possible that if it had been known, other candidates would have come forward.  Apparently only a small segment of the population was “in the know.” 

It should come as no surprise that there are many up here who have grave reservations about this idea. The idea of running a parallel investigation into the economic viability of an independent school system, separate from the Signal School Viability Committee, was floated by one councilmember, Dan Landrum.  He received no support from the other four council members.  The purpose of the parallel group would have been to challenge numbers and assumptions made by the SSVC.  Given the financial obligations an independent school system would put on this very small town, there’s no such thing as too much information. Given the impact on students and teachers, there’s no such thing as too much information. Given the impact on taxpayers, there’s no such thing as too much information. 

So, a group of dedicated citizens stepped in on their own time and on their own dimes to investigate this proposal and to fill a much needed void. This is in the best tradition of citizen engagement. Why would they do it? The bigger question is why wouldn’t they?  Why accept second hand conversations, held away from public scrutiny, as gospel?  Why not do what they have done and contact municipal, county, and state officials for answers to questions – straight from the horse’s mouth?  Signal’s organizational chart places citizens at the top of the chart – same thing goes for every level of government in the state.  We can, and ought to pick up the phone from time to time and make our own calls.  Send our own emails or heck, drive to county offices, or even Nashville, to state offices. 

The group of citizens who are checking numbers and relevant material are doing so knowing that they risk marginalization and retaliation.  I’ve personally heard a member of the SSVC, a volunteer, disparaged in public meetings for scrutinizing information that the SSVC was including in their report.  That member was not present to defend his statements.  This is something I’ve never heard before in all my years of attending town and county meetings.  It is odd that the majority of our town government would not welcome testing of their viability report.   

I’m still waiting for answers to questions that have been asked in public meetings.  It seems to me that questions have been answered – just not the questions that were being asked.  This may be the way of politics these days, but we should continue to reject any reply that isn’t straightforward.  
Again, it is unfortunate that this issue was not brought up during the past two campaign seasons.  The citizens of our small town are just now trying to play catch up and get a grasp on this situation.  Kudos to those who are doing their dead level best to keep the record straight.   

Melissa Cantrell


Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

How To Do Open Enrollment In Hamilton County Schools

The Problems With Becoming A Red Flag Law State


With this the first Saturday of December, my dear friend Larry sends along a most appropriate tale to start off the season for The Saturday Funnies. By now you know I don’t write the funnies ... (click for more)

This is a great idea and will help many students in the system. There are a few things that must be required before a student is allowed to change schools out of their zone. The following must ... (click for more)

ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat In a surprise turn of events last week, Tennessee State Senator Steve Dickerson (R) wrote a guest column for the Tennessean where he outlined ... (click for more)


Opinion

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

With this the first Saturday of December, my dear friend Larry sends along a most appropriate tale to start off the season for The Saturday Funnies. By now you know I don’t write the funnies and not a word is one of mine. I just gather up the stuff that people send me during the week and my sole intent is to share laughter. Larry claims this traditional-holiday-sounding event ... (click for more)

How To Do Open Enrollment In Hamilton County Schools

This is a great idea and will help many students in the system. There are a few things that must be required before a student is allowed to change schools out of their zone. The following must be required, otherwise, there will be chaos. A form must be developed with the following for each student wanting to transfer. 1. A student may not transfer if they have major discipline ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Heavy Rains Continue For Chattanooga, While It's Not Cold Enough For Snow

Heavy rains continued in Chattanooga on Sunday, but temperatures did not drop low enough for the heavy snow that areas to the north and east received. The rain was bringing some minor flooding, especially in the Trenton and New England, Ga., areas and along Lookout Creek. South Chickamauga Creek was also rising, and was expected to exceed flood stage by late Sunday afternoon. ... (click for more)

County Schools Won't Give Information On Ooltewah High Rape Settlement, Attorney Charges

Hamilton County School officials say they won't give any information about the amount of money paid out to settle two lawsuits brought in Federal Court by students who were injured in the Ooltewah High rape incident. They also said they would not release the amount the county schools had to pay in legal expenses for defending the cases. Chattanoogan.com filed an Open Records ... (click for more)

Sports

Baylor Nips Cleveland For Duals Championship

CLEVELAND, Tenn. – The Al Miller Cleveland Duals has become one of the most competitive wrestling duals tournament in the Southeast in recent years and that tradition continued on Saturday at Cleveland High School’s Raider Arena. So it’s probably really appropriate that the two best high school teams in the state of Tennessee squared off in the championship finals. The host ... (click for more)

Bearettes Stump Arlington In East-Classic Battle Of Once-Beaten Powers

CLEVELAND, Tenn. – Arlington’s girls tried to join Houston as the headline teams in the second East-West Classic on Saturday night at Bradley Central High School. Houston walloped East Hamilton, 76-49, in convincing fashion as coach Ben Moore continued to mold the Lady Mustangs into a perennial state championship contender. In the second-to-next-last game on a seven-game card, ... (click for more)