Roy Exum: They Aren't Criminals

Tuesday, January 30, 2018 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum
We’ve tried it the old way, telling our most desperate to get their lives straightened out, to get into a church, and then we’ll figure out where they can stay. There ain’t a chance that will ever work with those who suffer from mental illness, who are homeless, or struggle with addictions. Failure, along with a hell you wouldn’t wish anyone, is guaranteed I know. I have seen it and it is still on vivid display at our county jail.
But you know what does work? Housing first -- once we get our strugglers secure, and clean and warm and with food, it is far easier to get them back on the prescribed medicines, coordinated with social workers, and gentle supervision.
That’s when these people can get their lives “straightened out” in a community that cares.
It is going to happen in Chattanooga. Last week a team from the Corporation for Supportive Housing was in here at the behest of Sheriff Jim Hammond and we are now one of 30 pilot programs across the country that is earnest in an effort remember our forgotten.
Forgotten? Yes, how else do you describe our police officers and sheriff’s deputies stacking tons of people nobody wants any part of; sufferers whose only port of call is the county jail because there is no other option. How’s that? Is that who we’ve become? Don’t you see, our society offers no other choice - yet? Mental illness is a sickness. In more cases than not, it lapses over into the homeless. Addiction is also treatable but not one of these conditions is illegal. “So why have we stigmatized these people as criminals?” asks Gino Bennett who handles a huge myriad of support services for the sheriff’s department.
“Their neighbors see someone whose ability to reason is impaired in a police car, or they see our officers handcuffing someone who is acting abnormally. Someone will dial 9-1-1 if they see some guy urinating in public. Unfortunately, ‘the buck stops here’ but they are not criminals … they are members of somebody’s family who are pleading for help.”
Over the past year Sheriff Hammond has headed a team to address “doing a better job” with arrestees who do not belong in his jail. Bennet has teamed with dynamic Janna Jahn, an impressive array of team members and elected officials and the results of their study will result in the biggest diversion project ever tried in Hamilton County.
Bennett said, “We have had some businesses step up to provide funds and we have signed a contract with CSH to help us get the pilot project off the ground. The biggest thing we’ve learned is that the whole thing is centered on housing. If we can get a homeless person, for example, where he knows he’ll be safe, where he knows no one will steal his stuff and take this horrible anxiety away, everybody wins.
“The county jail costs up to $87,000 a day but we can provide far better care with much greater results if we can ‘break the cycle,’” added Bennet. “What happens is a person gets off their meds and the social worker loses track of them. So they act out, get in jail until they’ll take their medicines, and see a judge. They get out and – boom – something happens. They drop their meds, the symptoms return and the cycle begins again.”
The pilot program will take between one and two years to handle 50 patients. “There are so many facets to this that Janna has been assigned by Mayor Coppinger on a full-time basis. Sheriff Hammond wants me to do as much as I can and Linda Bennett has been added part time. The Chattanooga Housing Authority is really involved and, for instance, we had a great meeting with Erlanger’s leaders the other day. Memorial Hospital and Blue Cross-Blue Shield were our first contributors.”
“When we sat down with city mayor Andy Berke he bought in completely. He’s been doing work with the homeless veterans and realizes the huge amount of data that must be gathered and he has committed to be that part of the program. You have no idea what that means. The CSH team could hardly believe Mayor Berke did that but Andy has been doing it already. He understands what it will take to make this work.”
Last fall Janna discovered Moore Place in Charlotte where in the first two years, a diversion model involving 84 patients saved the county $2.5 million. How? 648 fewer emergency room visits, 292 fewer hospital days, 90 fewer arrests, 1,050 fewer days in jail and 76 percent fewer 9-1-1 calls.
“The financial savings in Nashville and in Knoxville are already incredible,” Sheriff Hammond said, “but the jail is no longer a bottleneck, people are getting treatment, and the best part is our society is doing what is right,” said the sheriff.
“One more thing … don’t give me credit for this,” said Hammond. “A lot of wonderful people have a hand in what will be one of the best things this county has ever done. In the end, all that matters is the people we serve. And never forget every last one of us matters to Someone who is bigger than the rest of us.”
* * *
“The purpose of life is not to be happy. It is to be useful, to be honorable, to be compassionate, to have it make some difference that you have lived and lived well.” -- – Ralph Waldo Emerson
* * *
“Compassion is a verb.” --  Thich Nhat Hanh
* * *
“I follow three rules: Do the right thing, do the best you can, and always show people you care.” Lou Holtz
* * *

Insanity - The Platform Of The Democratic Party

The Importance Of Early Detection Of Peripheral Artery Disease

Collegedale Should Contract With The Hamilton County Sheriff's Office

Once upon a time an arrogant, pompous man who fancied himself as America’s Foreign Minister rather than Secretary of State, John Kerry, agreed to a terrible deal with Iran in the closing days ... (click for more)

As a physician, I am observing Peripheral Artery Disease Awareness Month to increase public understanding the risks, effects and treatment options for PAD. A vascular disease that causes narrowing ... (click for more)

As I have read about the events with the Collegedale Police Department unfolding, I have started to wonder why doesn’t the Collegedale Police Department contract with Hamilton County Sheriff’s ... (click for more)


Insanity - The Platform Of The Democratic Party

Once upon a time an arrogant, pompous man who fancied himself as America’s Foreign Minister rather than Secretary of State, John Kerry, agreed to a terrible deal with Iran in the closing days of the Obama administration. By-passing the Constitutional process for treaties, Lord Kerry agreed to a deal which allowed Iran to continue its nuclear weapons program with only self-inspection ... (click for more)

The Importance Of Early Detection Of Peripheral Artery Disease

As a physician, I am observing Peripheral Artery Disease Awareness Month to increase public understanding the risks, effects and treatment options for PAD. A vascular disease that causes narrowing or blockage of arteries in the legs, PAD can result in life-altering limb amputations if not properly diagnosed and treated. As a vascular specialist, I have treated hundreds of PAD ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Dr. William Jackson Named Erlanger’s New CEO; Spiegel Gets Year's Salary, Continuing Insurance

During a specially-called meeting of the Erlanger Health System Board of Trustees, Chairman Mike Griffin announced that Chief Medical Officer Dr. William L. Jackson Jr., has been appointed as the health system’s new president and chief executive officer. Also a settlement was reached with former president Kevin Spiegel, who resigned last week under pressure from the board. ... (click for more)

Car Accident On Lee Highway Causes Vehicle To Crash Into Hotel

A car accident on Lee Highway caused a gold van to leave the road, crash into an SUV in a hotel parking lot and then into two hotel rooms, structurally damaging the building. The incident happened just after 3 p.m. Wednesday at the In Town Suites on Lee Highway. Both hotel rooms were empty at the time of the incident. A total of 12 surrounding rooms were evacuated as a precaution. ... (click for more)


Mocs Football Set To Host 2nd Ranked James Madison Saturday

The University of Tennessee at Chattanooga football team has a chance to make history this weekend when second ranked James Madison visits the Scenic City. With the release of the FCS polls today, the Dukes are officially the highest ranked non-conference opponent to take on the Mocs in Finley Stadium. Kickoff is set for 4:00 p.m. (E.D.T.) on Saturday, Sept. 21. JMU (2-1, 0-0 ... (click for more)

UTC Women 7th At Mercedes-Benz Collegiate

--The Chattanooga Mocs women’s golf team’s posted their best season-opening score shooting 872 (+20) over 54 holes at Cherokee Country Club. That was good for a seventh-place finish in the Mercedes-Benz Collegiate after today’s 294. Maddy McDanel and Esme Hamilton tied for the team’s low card with level-par 71s. Rheagan Hall and Dorota Zalewska each tallied 76, while Kirsty ... (click for more)