State Supreme Court Holds That Evidence Cannot Be Used To Contradict Written Words In Contract

Friday, January 18, 2019

In a case closely watched by Tennessee’s business community, the Tennessee Supreme Court has held that trial courts cannot use evidence outside of the written agreement—called “extrinsic” evidence—to interpret a contract if that evidence is used to contradict the contract’s written terms.

Beginning in 1999, BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc., signed agency agreements with insurance agency Individual HealthCare Specialists, Inc., to allow Individual HealthCare to solicit applications for BlueCross insurance policies.  Their business relationship lasted over ten years, with new contracts each year that spelled out the commission rates for sales of new insurance policies and renewals of existing insurance policies.

For years, BlueCross paid Individual HealthCare commissions on renewal policies at the renewal rate in effect when the policy was first issued.  In 2011, however, BlueCross began paying commissions on renewal policies based on the rate in effect when the policy was renewed, which was substantially less.  Individual HealthCare objected, claiming that this was a retroactive change in renewal commission rates and that BlueCross could not change those rates without Individual HealthCare’s permission.  Ultimately, the parties’ business relationship ended.

Individual HealthCare sued BlueCross in Davidson County Chancery Court for breach of contract. The parties disputed, among other things, whether BlueCross had the authority to unilaterally change commission rates on renewal policies.      

At the trial level, in addition to reviewing the written language of the contract, the trial court also considered the oral testimony of former BlueCross executives who participated in negotiating the agency contract.  The executives testified that during the pre-contract negotiations neither party intended for BlueCross to have the authority to unilaterally change the commission rate for renewal policies retroactively. This oral testimony contradicted the written contract.

Interpreting the contract, the trial court ruled in line with the testimony of the former BlueCross executives, finding that BlueCross did not have authority to change commission rates retroactively. The Court of Appeals affirmed, and the Tennessee Supreme Court granted BlueCross permission to appeal. 

The Supreme Court commented that Tennessee judges have long used extrinsic evidence of the circumstances when parties entered into a contract to interpret what they intended the written words to mean.  However, the Court said, “the written words are the lodestar of contract interpretation.” Tennessee law does not allow the use of extrinsic evidence of pre-contract negotiations to justify an interpretation of the contract that contradicts the contract’s written words.

The Supreme Court found that the language in the contract between BlueCross and Individual HealthCare clearly gave BlueCross the right to unilaterally change all of the commission rates, including the renewal rates.  The Court concluded that the trial court erred by using evidence of the parties’ pre-contract negotiations to contradict the written words in their agreement.  Consequently, it reversed the trial court’s decision and held that BlueCross did not breach the contract by changing the applicable commission rate for renewal policies.

To read the unanimous opinion in Individual HealthCare Specialists, Inc. v. BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc., authored by Justice Holly Kirby, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

 


NRC Announces Opportunity To Request Hearing On Bellefonte Construction Permit Transfer Application

Reggie Piercy Named Vice President Of Sandler Training

Evann Freeman To Join EPB


The Nuclear Regulatory Commission has accepted for review Nuclear Development’s application to transfer the construction permits for the Tennessee Valley Authority’s unfinished Bellefonte reactors ... (click for more)

Reggie Piercy has joined Sandler Training in Chattanooga as vice president. Mr. Piercy brings more than 35 years of experience in the hospitality industry ranging from sales, operations, human ... (click for more)

Evann Freeman will join EPB as director of Government Relations effective Dec. 17. In his new position, Mr. Freeman will lead EPB’s government relations and economic development efforts. According ... (click for more)


Business

NRC Announces Opportunity To Request Hearing On Bellefonte Construction Permit Transfer Application

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission has accepted for review Nuclear Development’s application to transfer the construction permits for the Tennessee Valley Authority’s unfinished Bellefonte reactors near Scottsboro, Al. Nuclear Development submitted the permit transfer application on Nov. 13, 2018, and supplemented its application earlier this year following discussions with NRC staff. ... (click for more)

Reggie Piercy Named Vice President Of Sandler Training

Reggie Piercy has joined Sandler Training in Chattanooga as vice president. Mr. Piercy brings more than 35 years of experience in the hospitality industry ranging from sales, operations, human resources, and training and development. During his career, he worked most recently for Vision Hospitality as senior vice president of Operations developing and implementing their world ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Aquarium Contracting Out Gift Shops, Concessions

The Tennessee Aquarium is contracting out its gift shops and concessions. An employee said about 30 workers are affected. The contract will go to Event Network, which operates a number of similar facilities around the country. The Aquarium has used its own staff since it opened in May 1992. The employee said workers were told they could apply with the new company. ... (click for more)

CARTA Planning Free Rides For Veterans; Lively Says Veterans "Not Expecting All This"

CARTA is planning to begin providing free rides to veterans on its entire transit fleet. Lisa Maragnano, executive director, said, "I think we should be doing more for our veterans. "They put their lives on the line for us so it's the right thing to do. They deserve it." She said the goal is to have the new policy go into effect Jan. 2. Ms. Maragnano said some other ... (click for more)

Opinion

Be A Bright Spot During A Dark Time This Thanksgiving

This year will mark the fact that I have had the opportunity to live through 56 Thanksgivings. I was born on a Sunday, Nov. 24, 1963, two days after the assassination of John F. Kennedy. Thanksgiving occurred on Nov. 28 that year, the same as this year. It was a time, not unlike today, filled with political uncertainty. My mother told me I was the only child born that evening. Nurses ... (click for more)

The Opioid Epidemic Should Be First Priority Of State Legislature In Upcoming Year

When considering the most pressing matter that is threatening the great state of Tennessee, I would be willing to bet that more apparent matters come to your mind such as the state of our education system, the statewide job market, or maybe even the depressing (but improving) state of the University of Tennessee’s football program. To myself, the opioid crisis, which was declared ... (click for more)