State Supreme Court Holds That Evidence Cannot Be Used To Contradict Written Words In Contract

Friday, January 18, 2019

In a case closely watched by Tennessee’s business community, the Tennessee Supreme Court has held that trial courts cannot use evidence outside of the written agreement—called “extrinsic” evidence—to interpret a contract if that evidence is used to contradict the contract’s written terms.

Beginning in 1999, BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc., signed agency agreements with insurance agency Individual HealthCare Specialists, Inc., to allow Individual HealthCare to solicit applications for BlueCross insurance policies.  Their business relationship lasted over ten years, with new contracts each year that spelled out the commission rates for sales of new insurance policies and renewals of existing insurance policies.

For years, BlueCross paid Individual HealthCare commissions on renewal policies at the renewal rate in effect when the policy was first issued.  In 2011, however, BlueCross began paying commissions on renewal policies based on the rate in effect when the policy was renewed, which was substantially less.  Individual HealthCare objected, claiming that this was a retroactive change in renewal commission rates and that BlueCross could not change those rates without Individual HealthCare’s permission.  Ultimately, the parties’ business relationship ended.

Individual HealthCare sued BlueCross in Davidson County Chancery Court for breach of contract. The parties disputed, among other things, whether BlueCross had the authority to unilaterally change commission rates on renewal policies.      

At the trial level, in addition to reviewing the written language of the contract, the trial court also considered the oral testimony of former BlueCross executives who participated in negotiating the agency contract.  The executives testified that during the pre-contract negotiations neither party intended for BlueCross to have the authority to unilaterally change the commission rate for renewal policies retroactively. This oral testimony contradicted the written contract.

Interpreting the contract, the trial court ruled in line with the testimony of the former BlueCross executives, finding that BlueCross did not have authority to change commission rates retroactively. The Court of Appeals affirmed, and the Tennessee Supreme Court granted BlueCross permission to appeal. 

The Supreme Court commented that Tennessee judges have long used extrinsic evidence of the circumstances when parties entered into a contract to interpret what they intended the written words to mean.  However, the Court said, “the written words are the lodestar of contract interpretation.” Tennessee law does not allow the use of extrinsic evidence of pre-contract negotiations to justify an interpretation of the contract that contradicts the contract’s written words.

The Supreme Court found that the language in the contract between BlueCross and Individual HealthCare clearly gave BlueCross the right to unilaterally change all of the commission rates, including the renewal rates.  The Court concluded that the trial court erred by using evidence of the parties’ pre-contract negotiations to contradict the written words in their agreement.  Consequently, it reversed the trial court’s decision and held that BlueCross did not breach the contract by changing the applicable commission rate for renewal policies.

To read the unanimous opinion in Individual HealthCare Specialists, Inc. v. BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee, Inc., authored by Justice Holly Kirby, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.

 


Caribbean And Tennessee Student Environmental Alliance Celebrates 15 Years With Week Of Events

Urban League To Host Job Fair Thursday

New Local Non-Profit Launches Free Event Series To Empower Citizens On Community Issues


The Caribbean and Tennessee Student Environmental Alliance (SEA) is celebrating its 15th anniversary with a week of celebratory events from April 26 – May 3. Chattanooga Lookouts Community ... (click for more)

Job seekers have the opportunity to meet some of Chattanooga’s top employers at a free job fair hosted by Urban League of Greater Chattanooga this Thursday at Kingdom Center, Urban League of ... (click for more)

A new local non-profit is launching a free educational event series about community and government issues impacting Chattanooga. Their first public event is titled “The History, Philosophy and ... (click for more)


Business

Caribbean And Tennessee Student Environmental Alliance Celebrates 15 Years With Week Of Events

The Caribbean and Tennessee Student Environmental Alliance (SEA) is celebrating its 15th anniversary with a week of celebratory events from April 26 – May 3. Chattanooga Lookouts Community Partner Night at AT&T Stadium April 26, kicks off this week-long celebration. Be there to witness firsthand the local non-profit’s rebranding, which will be officially announced as the ... (click for more)

Urban League To Host Job Fair Thursday

Job seekers have the opportunity to meet some of Chattanooga’s top employers at a free job fair hosted by Urban League of Greater Chattanooga this Thursday at Kingdom Center, Urban League of Greater Chattanooga, 730 M.L. King Blvd. in Chattanooga from 11 a.m.-2 p.m. Representatives from Aerotek, City of Chattanooga, Convergys, Chattanooga State, Express Employment and Goodwill ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Body Of Geneva Atkins Located In Meigs County; Car Had Wrecked Into Treeline

The body of 83-year-old Geneva Atkins, who was reported missing last Tuesday, was found Monday night in Meigs County deceased. Hamilton County Sheriff's Office personnel located Mrs. Atkins at approximately 8:15 p.m. Her vehicle was located north of Decatur, near the 22000 block of Highway 58. Initial findings show that her vehicle left the roadway, crossed a field, and came ... (click for more)

Antwon Lee, 29, Shot And Killed Monday Morning On Grove Street; Suspect Sought

Antwon Lee, 29, was shot and killed Monday morning on Grove Street. At approximately 11:33 a.m., Chattanooga Police responded to 1100 Grove Street on a report of a person shot. Upon arrival, police located Lee, who had been shot. Hamilton County EMS responded and transported Lee to a local hospital where he succumbed to his injuries. The suspect fled the scene. ... (click for more)

Opinion

Why Does Walden Need A Large Grocery Store? - And Response (2)

The town of Walden has a population of 2,118 people. What do those citizens need with a 49,000 square foot grocery store? Or with 10,000 square feet of commercial office space? Or a fuel island? Or increased tractor trailer traffic with proportional damage to the road up and down the mountain? Or multiple traffic lights at the “W” Road intersection and at Timesville Road? When ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Just Say ‘I Love You’

A dear friend sends me a note that his mom, after 40 glorious years of teaching children in public schools, is dying. The death of a mom or dad is among the worst things a child must bear, watching a parent in their final days. But I still marvel at the fact when Helen Exum died four years ago, not once did I cry and I’m a pretty emotional guy. The overwhelming reason I could ... (click for more)