Discrimination And Double Taxation For Animal Shelters - And Response

Wednesday, November 21, 2018

Some Commissioners want Hamilton County to donate $10 million in tax dollars to help the Humane Education Society (HES) build a new facility. The majority of Hamilton County residents (specifically those residing in Chattanooga, East Ridge, Lakesite, Walden, Signal Mountain, Lookout Mountain, Soddy Daisy, and Collegedale) will be prohibited from using HES animal services unless their respective cities ALSO pay separate fees from city taxes to obtain coverage.

Un-incorporated county residents will continue to receive animal services for their one county tax payment.

Unless something changes, this multimillion dollar county donation will not bring city residents any significant benefit unless HES allows or the County Commissioners demand all county taxpayers be treated equally.

The services are not equal now and the County Commissioners have made no appreciable efforts to correct the service inequality.

Some cities pay an additional contract fee to buy HES services and some don't. Some support different facilities. East Ridge is considering building their own animal facility. It will be a costly ongoing expense for them. Chattanooga helped build and helps facilitate an animal facility known as the McKamey Animal Shelter. McKamey is a non-profit agency supported by public (Chattanooga taxes) and private donations. Chattanoogans’ are NOT allowed to use HES services even though Chattanoogans also pay county taxes which are used to annually support HES services.

If Hamilton County donates the money, it will allow County Commissioners to wash their hands of the responsibility of providing countywide animal services to city residents who are also county taxpayers. This will occur because the county won't be running or owning the new facility. The arrangement is a fool proof way of reducing county costs via cost shifting. By doing it this way, it legally discriminates against city residents who pay county taxes, while continuing to take care of the animal control needs of unincorporated county residents.

Most citizens want to take care of stray animals. That could happen using one administrative body for Hamilton County. It should happen by using one funding mechanism-county taxes. If animal services are needed countywide, why shouldn't countywide taxes pay the bill?

HES is a fine organization. Knowing that does no diminish the need to do what is right for county residents AND animals. The decision about animal care should be about what's best for the animals and ALL the people who pay to support animals via county taxes.

Big Question: What makes unincorporated citizens worthy of HES animal services based on payment of county taxes, while city residents are denied services despite having paid the same county taxes?

Before you dismiss this editorial, know that I am a city resident and a past volunteer at the HES facility located on Highland Avenue. I admire what HES has done. My husband and I have adopted 5 shelter animals during our 40 plus years of marriage. We are for high quality animal care, adoption, spay and neutering. We don't object to an additional shelter space, if that's what's needed. We object to paying county taxes and being denied the county services.

This is not rocket science. Common sense can solve this, if the "powers that be" will stow their territorial animosities in favor of a broad solution. It's not about what's best for HES or McKamey. It's about what's best for animals and citizens who should be charged ONLY once for services. 

Bottom LIne:
Regardless of whether the County donates $10 million for a new facility or not, double taxation of city residents in order to qualify for HES services is wrong. It is discriminatory. County Commissioners can and should intervene to stop it.

Deborah Scott

* * *

Deborah, while I appreciate your sentiment, the logic of your economics are flawed to say the least. Here’s the facts about county funding and taxation:

Property taxes fund schools which are distributed equitably. 

Sales taxes are another story. In incorporated areas and cities, the cities not the county, gets the bulk of the revenue. 

So, to refute your statement, it’s actually the unincorporated areas of the County carrying most of the burden. Cities should absolutely bare an additional expense to utilize these services and facilities.

PS: Y’all can take back the City School system you bankrupted anytime you like.

James Berry and the rest of the County

Reasons To Choose Another Sewer Treatment Plant Site

Why WWTA's Plan Should Be Discarded

The Deck Is Rigged Against Howard

The Hamilton County Commission is being asked to make a tough decision when it comes to the location of the WWTA WWTP. On one side, you have a handful of people who are pro WWTP at Mahan Gap ... (click for more)

Thanks to a live feed, I was able to watch about three hours of the very important Hamilton County Commission meeting on Dec. 12 while in Alabama. This was the first time I have been able to ... (click for more)

I was more than appalled when I read the list of vocational programs per school across Hamilton County. We put a man on the moon nearly 60 years ago, yet HCDE can’t figure out how to make opportunities ... (click for more)


Reasons To Choose Another Sewer Treatment Plant Site

The Hamilton County Commission is being asked to make a tough decision when it comes to the location of the WWTA WWTP. On one side, you have a handful of people who are pro WWTP at Mahan Gap because they want to develop northern Hamilton County and on the other hand, you have residents who want to protect the largest investment that they've made, i.e., their home and their ability ... (click for more)

Why WWTA's Plan Should Be Discarded

Thanks to a live feed, I was able to watch about three hours of the very important Hamilton County Commission meeting on Dec. 12 while in Alabama. This was the first time I have been able to hear both sides of the WWTA vs. Ooltewah Homeowners fully present their arguments. One thing we can all agree on is that they have to do something, the question is what is the best for all. ... (click for more)

Breaking News

State Dismisses All Charges Against Charles Toney In Controversial Arrest

The state on Tuesday morning dismissed all charges against aspiring rapper Charles Toney in connection with his arrest that led to a U.S. Department of Justice probe. The arrest on Dec. 3 on Donaldson Road was caught on video by a neighbor and went viral. It showed Toney being punched and kicked by an officer while he was handcuffed. District Attorney Neal Pinkston afterward ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Schools Announces New School Options And Timeline

For the 2019-2020 school year, Hamilton County Schools is opening enrollment to a select group of schools, “My Future Schools,” to which students across the district will be eligible to apply. Officials said, "Opening enrollment to these schools will provide students with a diverse range of options outside of their neighborhood zoned school. These schools will be in addition to ... (click for more)


Cleveland Boys' And Girls' Basketball Teams Involved In "Inappropriate Conduct"

Reports surfaced Monday that Cleveland’s boys’ and girls’ basketball teams broke curfew and engaged in inappropriate conduct after a basketball double-header last Friday in Oak Ridge. The Blue Raiders and Lady Blue Raiders played doubleheaders at Fulton and Oak Ridge over the weekend. On Tuesday, Russell Dyer, director of Cleveland schools, released a statement through the ... (click for more)

St. Francis Knocks Off East Hamilton, 58-53, Despite Hayes' 33-Point Effort

East Hamilton’s Lady Hurricanes fell to St. Francis (Georgia), 58-53, in their opening game Tuesday in the CresCom Bank Holiday Invitational at the Myrtle Beach Convention Center in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. Junior Madison Hayes scored a game-high 33 points on 12-of-20 shooting and also grabbed 11 rebounds for the Lady Canes (7-5), but even that wasn’t enough to overcome ... (click for more)