Tennessee Supreme Court Reverses Trial Court's Exclusion In DUI Case

Friday, July 20, 2018

The Tennessee Supreme Court reversed a trial court’s decision to exclude certain evidence obtained from a blood sample drawn from the defendant, Angela Faye Daniel.  In this case, Daniel was arrested for driving under the influence, and she was transported to a medical facility for a blood draw.  Although the arresting officer obtained a search warrant for the blood draw, the officer failed to leave a copy of the warrant with Daniel, in violation of Tennessee Rule of Criminal Procedure 41. The trial court suppressed the evidence obtained from the blood draw on this basis. On interlocutory appeal by the State, the Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the trial court’s suppression of the evidence. The State appealed to the Tennessee Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court granted the appeal and requested additional briefing as to whether the Court should expand the good-faith exception adopted in State v. Davidson to include technical violations during the service of a search warrant when the search is otherwise constitutional and whether the Exclusionary Rule Reform Act (“the ERRA”) violates the Separation of Powers Clause of the Tennessee Constitution.

In its unanimous opinion authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, the Court first noted that, in State v. Lowe, another case released today, the Court held that the ERRA violated the Separation of Powers Clause of the Tennessee Constitution.  The Court then went on to hold that a good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule applied in this case, given that any failure of the arresting officer to provide Daniel with a copy of the warrant was due to an inadvertent oversight and that the technical noncompliance did not prejudice her. 

As it also did in State v. Lowe, the Court provided guidance to trial courts as to what should be considered when hearing a motion to suppress based on technical violations of Tennessee Rule of Criminal Procedure 41.  Specifically, the Court directed that, in situations where a defendant has established that a search warrant, or its supporting affidavit, fails to comply with the technical requirements pursuant to Tennessee Rule of Criminal Procedure 41, the State then has the burden of establishing that the technical noncompliance was due to a good-faith error and that the error did not prejudice the defendant. 

Based on the Court’s determination in this case that a good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule was applicable, the Supreme Court reversed the judgment of the trial court and the Court of Criminal Appeals and remanded the matter to the trial court.

To read the Supreme Court’s unanimous opinion in State v. Angela Faye Daniel, authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Gas Prices Drop 0.8 Cents In Chattanooga

Chattanooga Chamber Calendar Of Events For Jan. 24-28

TN Unemployment Rate Reaches Its Lowest Level Since January 2020


Average gasoline prices in Chattanooga have fallen 0.8 cents per gallon in the last week, averaging $2.94 per gallon on Monday, according to GasBuddy's survey of 170 stations in Chattanooga. ... (click for more)

Jan. 25, [online] East Brainerd Council Meeting noon-1 p.m. Join us for a mid-year update from East Brainerd Elementary. We will also discuss plans to move back to in-person meetings and ... (click for more)

Unemployment in the state of Tennessee reached a two-year low in December, according to new data released by the Department of Labor and Workforce Development. The state ended 2021 with an unemployment ... (click for more)



Business

Gas Prices Drop 0.8 Cents In Chattanooga

Average gasoline prices in Chattanooga have fallen 0.8 cents per gallon in the last week, averaging $2.94 per gallon on Monday, according to GasBuddy's survey of 170 stations in Chattanooga. Prices in Chattanooga are 3.0 cents per gallon higher than a month ago and stand 82.0 cents per gallon higher than a year ago. According to GasBuddy price reports, the cheapest station ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Chamber Calendar Of Events For Jan. 24-28

Jan. 25, [online] East Brainerd Council Meeting noon-1 p.m. Join us for a mid-year update from East Brainerd Elementary. We will also discuss plans to move back to in-person meetings and things to look forward to in 2022. Join us at noon on Zoom. Register here . No cost. Jan. 27, [in-person] Enterprise/Gateway Council Meeting 8-9:30 a.m. Chattanooga State ... (click for more)

Breaking News

3 More County Schools Shift To Remote Learning Due To High COVID Numbers

Three more county schools have switched to remote learning due to high COVID-19 numbers. School officials said, "The health and well-being of all Hamilton County students and staff has and will always be our highest priority. We are monitoring the current wave of COVID-19 spreading across our community and schools. Current state law does not permit the entire school district ... (click for more)

Firefighters Battle 2 Sunday Morning Restaurant Fires

Several LongHorn Steakhouse employees acted fast Sunday morning when a fire in the kitchen got out of control, safely exiting the restaurant and calling 911 for help. Multiple CFD Red Shift companies responded to the business at 5771 Brainerd Road. The kitchen hood was on fire and flames were coming through the hood vent on the roof. A second alarm was called to bring additional ... (click for more)

Opinion

Earl Freudenberg: Johnny Haynes Overcame His Disability To Become A Police Department Fixture

Johnny Haynes was a special person. Under almost clear skies and 45 degree temperatures, he was buried Saturday afternoon when a small group of his friends gathered at Greenwood Cemetery off Wilcox Boulevard for the committal service. The retired Chattanooga Police Department employee has been my friend since 1962. The Central High School graduate was born with polio but was ... (click for more)

Employers Broke The Social Contract - And Response

Along with our trust, most employers are going to need to give those who participated in the great resignation something to hold onto. The cliché during the pandemic is that we’re all in the same storm, not the same boat. Some of you are in yachts while the rest of us are drowning, grasping at driftwood. For some it’s being deep in medical debt, for others they suffer from burnout ... (click for more)