Woman Has No Doubt Anthony Vance Was Man Who Raped Her

Wednesday, July 10, 2019 - by Joseph Dycus

Judge Don Poole will take some time to consider whether or not to use a particular piece of evidence in the case against a Chattanooga man accused of rape.

Anthony LeBron Vance, 54, sat silently as attorneys and witnesses presented their cases for and against the use of a photo lineup as permissible evidence during his upcoming trial. Vance allegedly raped a Chattanooga woman in January.

The controversy surrounding this collection of papers was the way it was created, and the circumstances of how it was presented to the victim.

Once of the witnesses was Special Victims Unit detective Damarise Goehring, who assisted with the investigation and created the police lineup. Ms. Goehring initially met the victim at Parkridge hospital, where she was recovering. Using information obtained about the physical profile of the attacker, she searched various databases and created a photographic roster of possible suspects.

When the investigator compiled the pictures, she included the most recent image of Vance, which was taken the same day as the alleged rape (he was caught stealing from a Chattanooga business). He was wearing a striped shirt, and was the only man in the lineup wearing that kind of shirt.

The victim also gave testimony, and recounted the events of that day.

When she entered the courtroom, the victim almost immediately pointed to Vance and labelled him as the man who raped her.

According to the victim, she got off of the bus at around 6:50 a.m., and was walking home. During this time, Vance began to approach her, and asked her questions about where he could find a bus, and if she wanted to buy drugs from him.

She pointed him in the direction of the nearest bus stop. After this, he attacked her from behind, and drug her to the bushes behind the duplex where she lived. After Vance initially covered her head with a jacket, she was able to get it off.

Vance’s attorney Mike Acuff asked her if she had been able to see her attacker’s face clearly due to it being dark, her head being initially covered, and the attack starting from behind.

The victim had a very strong reaction and response to that question. How could she not see his face? She had been inches from it throughout the assault, she responded.

Prosecuting attorney Andrew Coyle then continued to ask about the rape. After a man walked outside of his apartment in order to start his car, Vance stopped the assault. He began to help the victim put her clothes back on, and allegedly said, “Oh, you’re the wrong person. Can you pray with me, and forgive me?”

“How can you forgive someone who raped you, and then asks you to pray with him?” asked the incredulous victim to the courtroom.

Vance then snuck away, and the victim was quickly taken to the hospital shortly thereafter. When investigator Goehring arrived with the photo lineup a few days later, the victim “immediately broke down and kept pointing at his picture,” according to the investigator.

The victim said she recognized him not only due to his face, but also his shirt, which was the same one he was wearing when he assaulted her.

Attorney Acuff argued the nature of the photo lineup was flawed, since the victim seemed to remember Vance’s appearance based on clothing, rather than his face. He argued it was unfair for his client to be the only person in the lineup with that kind of shirt.

Prosecutor Coyle did somewhat agree with this argument, but also pointed out the large amount of other evidence corroborating the victim’s story.

A DNA test found Vance’s DNA on her body. And Vance’s GPS tracker (he was on supervised probation at the time) showed he was at the exact location at the exact time the alleged rape occurred.

Because of this, prosecutor Coyle believed the police lineup was usable as evidence in the upcoming trial.

After hearing all of the testimony and arguments, Judge Poole said he would review the case. He set the next date for Aug. 7, a few weeks before the trial, as a day when the two sides could meet and go through any other motions they would wish to discuss.

 


Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Charges Bound To Grand Jury Against Man Who Sped Toward Firefighters At Boy Scout Road

Dalton Police Department Investigating Fraudulent Gift Card Use


Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: BAILEY, SIRENA DANIELLE 3501 JASPER LN CHATTANOOGA, 37411 Age at Arrest: 38 years old Arresting Agency: East Ridge DRIVING ON REVOKED ... (click for more)

Charges have been bound to the Grand Jury against a man who police say sped toward several firefighters at Boy Scout Road near Highway 153. General Sessions Court Judge Christie Sell bound ... (click for more)

At least three people in Dalton have reported trying to use gift cards that were apparently cleaned out electronically and the Dalton Police Department is investigating. In each case, the ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Arrest Report

Here is the latest Hamilton County arrest report: BAILEY, SIRENA DANIELLE 3501 JASPER LN CHATTANOOGA, 37411 Age at Arrest: 38 years old Arresting Agency: East Ridge DRIVING ON REVOKED DL --- BLAKE, BENJAMIN ANTHONY 237 WATER ST CHATTANOOGA, 374101352 Age at Arrest: 19 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga DRIVING ON REVOKED, SUSPENDED OR CANCELLED LICENSE ... (click for more)

Charges Bound To Grand Jury Against Man Who Sped Toward Firefighters At Boy Scout Road

Charges have been bound to the Grand Jury against a man who police say sped toward several firefighters at Boy Scout Road near Highway 153. General Sessions Court Judge Christie Sell bound the charges against Richard Roy Hill, 56, of Echo Glen Drive. He was charged with aggravated assault, three counts of reckless aggravated assault, violation of a traffic control device and ... (click for more)

Opinion

Opinion Correction: Erlanger Does Not Offer $20,000 Nurse Signing Bonuses

An opinion in Chattanoogan.com on Monday said Erlanger Health Systems had $20,000 nurse signing bonuses. Erlanger officials said that is another local hospital - not Erlanger. Columnist Roy Exum said, "In a story that I wrote on July 15, “A Nursing Shortage?” I mistakenly identified Erlanger Hospital as one hospital that offers prospective nurses a $20,000 signing bonus. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Use 'Tags' At Erlanger

When I was a senior in high school, the Vietnam catastrophe held the guys who were in my class spellbound. Back then, and has since been proven again and again, the conflict was a terrible error in our nation’s judgment and almost 60,000 young and promising Americans died in some stinking South Asian battle zone that didn’t mean squat to our freedom or our nation’s future. In ... (click for more)

Sports

CFC's Season Ends With 2-0 Loss To Miami; However Founder's Cup Starts In August

The Chattanooga Football Club’s rose-colored season was ended Tuesday night in the oppressive Florida heat against Miami FC, with their championship aspirations wilted by the end of the 2-0 shutout. While Miami dominated possession in the first half, Chattanooga briefly took the lead in the 40th minute. After Caleb Cole regained possession, the talented midfielder made a quick ... (click for more)

Red Wolves' Amponsah Named To USL One Team Of The Week

Chattanooga Red Wolves SC defender Nicholas Amponsah has been named to the USL League One Team of the Week for Week 16 of the league’s inaugural 2019 season. Amponsah scored the game-tying goal for the Red Wolves against Madison in addition to completing 45 of 54 passes, recording five tackles and winning 10 of 13 duels Saturday night. Amponsah leveled the match in the ... (click for more)