Woman Has No Doubt Anthony Vance Was Man Who Raped Her

Wednesday, July 10, 2019 - by Joseph Dycus

Judge Don Poole will take some time to consider whether or not to use a particular piece of evidence in the case against a Chattanooga man accused of rape.

Anthony LeBron Vance, 54, sat silently as attorneys and witnesses presented their cases for and against the use of a photo lineup as permissible evidence during his upcoming trial. Vance allegedly raped a Chattanooga woman in January.

The controversy surrounding this collection of papers was the way it was created, and the circumstances of how it was presented to the victim.

Once of the witnesses was Special Victims Unit detective Damarise Goehring, who assisted with the investigation and created the police lineup. Ms. Goehring initially met the victim at Parkridge hospital, where she was recovering. Using information obtained about the physical profile of the attacker, she searched various databases and created a photographic roster of possible suspects.

When the investigator compiled the pictures, she included the most recent image of Vance, which was taken the same day as the alleged rape (he was caught stealing from a Chattanooga business). He was wearing a striped shirt, and was the only man in the lineup wearing that kind of shirt.

The victim also gave testimony, and recounted the events of that day.

When she entered the courtroom, the victim almost immediately pointed to Vance and labelled him as the man who raped her.

According to the victim, she got off of the bus at around 6:50 a.m., and was walking home. During this time, Vance began to approach her, and asked her questions about where he could find a bus, and if she wanted to buy drugs from him.

She pointed him in the direction of the nearest bus stop. After this, he attacked her from behind, and drug her to the bushes behind the duplex where she lived. After Vance initially covered her head with a jacket, she was able to get it off.

Vance’s attorney Mike Acuff asked her if she had been able to see her attacker’s face clearly due to it being dark, her head being initially covered, and the attack starting from behind.

The victim had a very strong reaction and response to that question. How could she not see his face? She had been inches from it throughout the assault, she responded.

Prosecuting attorney Andrew Coyle then continued to ask about the rape. After a man walked outside of his apartment in order to start his car, Vance stopped the assault. He began to help the victim put her clothes back on, and allegedly said, “Oh, you’re the wrong person. Can you pray with me, and forgive me?”

“How can you forgive someone who raped you, and then asks you to pray with him?” asked the incredulous victim to the courtroom.

Vance then snuck away, and the victim was quickly taken to the hospital shortly thereafter. When investigator Goehring arrived with the photo lineup a few days later, the victim “immediately broke down and kept pointing at his picture,” according to the investigator.

The victim said she recognized him not only due to his face, but also his shirt, which was the same one he was wearing when he assaulted her.

Attorney Acuff argued the nature of the photo lineup was flawed, since the victim seemed to remember Vance’s appearance based on clothing, rather than his face. He argued it was unfair for his client to be the only person in the lineup with that kind of shirt.

Prosecutor Coyle did somewhat agree with this argument, but also pointed out the large amount of other evidence corroborating the victim’s story.

A DNA test found Vance’s DNA on her body. And Vance’s GPS tracker (he was on supervised probation at the time) showed he was at the exact location at the exact time the alleged rape occurred.

Because of this, prosecutor Coyle believed the police lineup was usable as evidence in the upcoming trial.

After hearing all of the testimony and arguments, Judge Poole said he would review the case. He set the next date for Aug. 7, a few weeks before the trial, as a day when the two sides could meet and go through any other motions they would wish to discuss.

 


Man Convicted For 2nd Rape Ordered To Begin Serving 10 Years For First Rape

City Officer Suffers Hand Injury As Motorist Speeds Off In Early Morning Incident On W. 25th Street

Lorie Collier Named New Principal At Calvin Donaldson Environmental Science Academy


A man who has been convicted of two rapes was ordered on Monday to begin serving a 10-year sentence on the initial rape from 2016. Anthony Vance, 56, had been given a suspended sentence on ... (click for more)

A Chattanooga Police officer suffered a hand injury when a motorist sped off early Monday morning on W. 25th Street near Williams Street. Officers had been speaking to the driver of a yellow ... (click for more)

Hamilton County Schools has selected Lorie Collier to be the new principal at Calvin Donaldson Environmental Science Academy. Ms. Collier joins Hamilton County Schools from Knox County Schools ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Man Convicted For 2nd Rape Ordered To Begin Serving 10 Years For First Rape

A man who has been convicted of two rapes was ordered on Monday to begin serving a 10-year sentence on the initial rape from 2016. Anthony Vance, 56, had been given a suspended sentence on the earlier case. He will be sentenced on the second rape from Jan. 3, 2018, next Monday. A portion of that sentencing hearing was held on Monday. Prosecutor Miriam Johnson said Vance ... (click for more)

City Officer Suffers Hand Injury As Motorist Speeds Off In Early Morning Incident On W. 25th Street

A Chattanooga Police officer suffered a hand injury when a motorist sped off early Monday morning on W. 25th Street near Williams Street. Officers had been speaking to the driver of a yellow Ford Mustang when he suddenly drove off. His side mirror hit the officer's hand so hard that it bent the mirror. The vehicle hit a nearby tree and utility pole. The driver then got out ... (click for more)

Opinion

Would Foreign Teachers Make Better Instructors For Inner-City Students? - And Response

It seems a week doesn't go by, sometimes more in one week, without Roy or someone writing some coded messages denigrating inner-city schools and the students (using another code-hint hint) that attend inner-city schools. Which reminded me of something from decades ago about teachers from foreign countries perhaps making better instructors for inner city students. At least those ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Let’s Start With Truth

By all accounts the public schools in Chattanooga and Hamilton County are far from what the average taxpayer would want them to be. Our schools are our number one priorities, this easily reflected by the fact they now receive over 60 percent of the total county budget -- the most money ever allocated to public education in history -- and the unbridled desire of our booming area ... (click for more)

Sports

UTC Soccer Records Another Shutout At Citadel

The Chattanooga women’s soccer team earned a record-tying eighth shutout with a 2-0 win over The Citadel Sunday afternoon in Southern Conference action at the Washington Light Infantry Field. The Mocs improve to 8-4-3 on the year and 3-2-1 in league action. The Citadel falls to 5-6-2 overall and 1-4 against the conference. The Mocs matched a school record eight shutouts set ... (click for more)

Dan Fleser: 91-Yard Drive Was UT Highlight

KNOXVILLE – Of all the work that went into Tennessee’s first SEC football victory in 11 months, Jeremy Pruitt seemed to linger over one achievement in particular. The 91-yard touchdown drive in the fourth quarter that clinched the Vols’ 20-10 victory over Mississippi State was the best combination of execution and effort. It drew first mention by UT’s coach on Monday, in advance ... (click for more)