The “Green New Deal” Is A Failure In Its Current Form

Saturday, August 24, 2019

Mid to late-August brings extreme summer heat, and this year, it also brought a thinning of the heard of the current field of Democratic Presidential contenders. With this, Bernie Sanders is attempting to take sole ownership of environmental issues in order to make him stand out from the rest of the pack. His approach: the “Green New Deal”……on steroids.

Now, I won’t entirely dismiss this plan. There are some aspects of it that make sense. For example, nationalizing the electric grid makes perfect sense. When the electric grid was deregulated in the 1990s, the thought was that it would enhance reliability while reducing costs. Neither of those have happened. In fact, the exact opposite has happened. Private companies neglected maintenance, operated assets well beyond their designated maintenance intervals, and now we’re paying for it. Having a reliable, low-cost national power grid is in the national economic and security interest of the United States; so much so, that it must have the backing of the U.S. government.

While this part is a great idea, the Green New Deal is far from perfect. For example, the current plan aims to largely decarbonize the electric grid using wind, solar, tidal, geothermal and energy storage. While some of those energy sources might offer some assistance in the race to decarbonize, they are not, nor will they ever be the primary solution. The problem that each one of them has can be summed up in one word: reliability. In engineering space, “reliability” is the ability for something to perform a required task when called upon, consistently. If we say a car is 99 percent reliable, it means it will start and run 99 key turns out of 100. In electricity space, we measure this by capacity factor and availability factor. Capacity factor is the ability for an electrical generator to perform at its nameplate capacity over a period of time. So, if I have a 2000 watt gas-powered generator and its label says it can run at 1000 watts for eight hours before running out of fuel, its capacity factor in that sense would be 50 percent. For nuclear plants, this number is around 90 percent. For coal-fired power plants, this number is around 70 percent. For modern combined cycle natural gas plants, this number is around 40 percent. For all renewables, this number is around 25 percent.

Bernie & Company’s Green New Deal says that a generating source that is there 25 percent of the time will adequately replace generating sources that are there 70-90 percent of the time. You don’t have to be an engineer or particularly good at math to know that’s just not true. You don’t replace a car that consistently runs five to six days of the week with a car that may run one or two days. If you still expect your car to start the way your old one did, you’d quickly be taking that new model back to the dealer.

That’s the problem with the current Green New Deal. It largely ignores scientific and engineering facts to cater to a dialogue and ideology that's just not true. Anyone is entitled to their own opinions, but as it relates to science, we’re not entitled to our own facts. Bernie Sanders cannot assume sole ownership of science while ignoring some fundamental laws that govern it. His campaign chastises those that disagree with his plan, saying they are “wrong” and “ignorant.” You simply cannot make that assertion when your hallmark energy plan ignores basic laws of physics and science. It’s disingenuous and wrong.

The scientific community agrees that global climate change is a serious problem and is the biggest existential threat to the human species over the next 50 years. The laws of physics (i.e. science) say that nuclear power is the only viable solution to having a chance at mitigating some of the most severe effects of climate change. You’re either in total agreement with this or you hold the same effective validity as those who deny climate change as even being a problem. There is no in between. It's science.

A real “Green New Deal” prioritizes nuclear and makes it and a truly resilient, nationalized electric grid a priority. This will be how we power our electric cars, our homes, our businesses, our factories, our water desalinization plants, and our society to not mitigate climate change, but beat it.

If you like Bernie’s plan, great. I’m happy for you. But you do not get to claim sole ownership as the party of “science” when you largely ignore some glaring fundamentals that are staring you right in the face. You can change this though. You can change how history gets written. Demand more form the Green New Deal. Demand something that works. Demand something that your kids and grandkids will be able to write about in the same way we write about the moon mission of 1969….something that worked.

Revise the Green New Deal to include nuclear, and win.

Nick Rutledge


Roy Exum: The Super’s 25% Sham

Roy Exum: Believe In Harbingers?

Reappraisal Equals Redistribution Of Wealth


I was talking to some fellas the other day – and these are pretty smart country boys – and posed this question: if a man was getting paid a base salary of $197,000, and then had a chance to jump ... (click for more)

A harbinger, we have been taught, is “something that foreshadows a future event,” or “something that gives an anticipatory sign of what is to come.” Last week in Connecticut, the families of ... (click for more)

Here’s a simple and accurate explanation of the Hamilton County property reappraisal results. Picture three adjacent property owners–you and your two next door neighbors. One neighbor to your ... (click for more)


Opinion

Roy Exum: The Super’s 25% Sham

I was talking to some fellas the other day – and these are pretty smart country boys – and posed this question: if a man was getting paid a base salary of $197,000, and then had a chance to jump to $240,000, what would be the percentage of ol’ Slick’s increase? One pulled out his cell phone and punched it, erased it, and punched some more. “Well, this thing says that if you had ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Believe In Harbingers?

A harbinger, we have been taught, is “something that foreshadows a future event,” or “something that gives an anticipatory sign of what is to come.” Last week in Connecticut, the families of three high school athletes – all female – filed a lawsuit against the Connecticut Interscholastic Athletic Conference. The lawsuit claims a current CIAC policy is a violation of the federal ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Human Remains Found In Walker County

Human skeletal remains were found in Walker County in a wooded area about 500 yards off the roadway, east of the 4000 block of South Highway 27, Lafayette, by a man and his son while they were hunting Monday morning, according to Walker County Sheriff Steve Wilson. The remains are believed to be those of a Walker County man missing since Sept. 30. Robert “Robbie” Sisson III, ... (click for more)

Body Of Attorney Who Jumped From Market Street Bridge Found Near Guntersville Dam; Wife Recounts Last Contact With Him; Funeral Is Saturday

The body of a prominent Chattanooga attorney who jumped from the Market Street Bridge has been found 122 river miles away and 19 days later near Guntersville Dam in Alabama. It was identified as that of George Edward Koontz, 66, of Chattanooga. Authorities said several people saw a man jump from the bridge on Jan. 29. The family of attorney Koontz reported him missing that ... (click for more)

Sports

Tennessee's Trey Smith Named Jason Witten Man Of The Year

ennessee junior offensive lineman Trey Smith was named the 2020 Jason Witten Collegiate Man of the Year by a subset of the award’s Board of Directors on Tuesday night at the Star in Frisco, the practice facility of the Dallas Cowboys. The Jason Witten Collegiate Man of the Year Award is presented annually to the Division I college football player who has demonstrated a record ... (click for more)

Hoops Central: Lady Vols At #25 Arkansas On Thursday

ennessee (17-8, 7-5 SEC), which is receiving votes in this week's AP and USA TODAY Coaches Polls, will travel to Fayetteville, Arkansas, where it will meet the No. 22/25 Arkansas Razorbacks (20-5, 8-4 SEC) on Thursday at 6:02 p.m. CT (7:02 ET) at Bud Walton Arena. The Lady Vols enter the contest in seventh place in the SEC standings and a game back of UA, which is tied for ... (click for more)