Supreme Court Upholds Death Sentences For Murders Of Memphis Family

Monday, November 20, 2017

The Tennessee Supreme Court has affirmed the convictions and sentences of death for Sedrick Clayton for the murders of Arithio, Patricia, and Pashea Fisher and the conviction for attempted murder of A’Reco Fisher in Memphis.  

During the early morning hours of Jan. 19, 2012, a domestic dispute erupted between the defendant and Pashea Fisher, the defendant’s girlfriend, at the Fishers’ home.  The situation escalated, and the defendant shot and killed all three victims and shot toward the area in which A’Reco Fisher had been sleeping.  The defendant then fled the residence in Pashea Fisher’s vehicle with his and Ms. Fisher’s then four-year-old daughter.  After having several telephone conversations with a law enforcement officer, the defendant eventually turned himself in.  He subsequently confessed to the murders. 

A Shelby County jury convicted the defendant of three counts of first degree premeditated murder, attempted first degree murder, possession of a firearm with the intent to go armed during the commission or attempt to commit a dangerous felony, employing a firearm during the commission or attempt to commit a dangerous felony, and unauthorized use of a motor vehicle.  In 2016, the Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed the convictions and sentences of death after merging the latter two convictions.

Upon automatic appeal to the Supreme Court as required by statute, the defendant raised several issues. First, the defendant argued that the evidence was insufficient to support the jury’s finding of premeditation.  The Court disagreed, based upon the evidence presented at trial that the defendant fired upon four unarmed victims without provocation, failed to render aid, and reloaded his weapon to fire a second and fatal shot at Pashea Fisher.  Second, the defendant argued that the statements he made to police the day after the shooting should have been suppressed pursuant to the Fourth Amendment.  This issue was neither raised nor ruled upon at trial or in the defendant’s motion for a new trial and was, therefore, waived.  The Court, however, reviewed the issue under the plain error doctrine and found that the defendant’s arrest was supported by probable cause and that he was brought before a magistrate in a timely manner.

The Court also conducted an independent review of the imposition of the death sentences, as required by statute, and concluded beyond a reasonable doubt that the evidence fully supported the defendant’s convictions and sentences of death, that the sentences were not arbitrary, and that the aggravating circumstances supporting the sentences outweighed any mitigating circumstances. In addition, the majority of the Court found the sentences were not disproportionate to sentences imposed in similar cases wherein a sentence of death was imposed.

In her concurring opinion, Justice Sharon G. Lee agreed with the Court’s outcome but stated she believed that when reviewing whether a death sentence is disproportionate to similar cases, the Court should not limit its review solely to cases in which the death penalty was imposed but should review all first degree murder cases in which life imprisonment or a sentence of death was imposed.  Using that analysis, she also concluded that the defendant’s sentence of death was not excessive or disproportionate to the penalty imposed in similar cases.

To read the majority opinion in State of Tennessee v. Sedrick Clayton, authored by Justice Roger A. Page, and Justice Sharon G. Lee’s separate concurring opinion regarding proportionality review, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.



Schools Featured In New Book Chattanooga In Old Photos

Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Fort Oglethorpe Arrest Report For Dec. 7-13


Chattanooga schools are featured in the new book Chattanooga in Old Photos, sponsored by Chattanoogan.com. There are scenes of McCallie School in 1910 as well as the 1927 football squad. The ... (click for more)

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ALLIGOOD, WILLIAM MICHAEL 1671 JED LANE HIXSON, 37343 Age at Arrest: 29 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County VIOLATION ... (click for more)

Here is the Fort Oglethorpe arrest report for Dec. 7-13: 12-07-18 Horatio Tremaine Williams, 30, of 823 West 12 th Street, Chattanooga arrested on a charge of criminal trespass. 12-09-18 ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Schools Featured In New Book Chattanooga In Old Photos

Chattanooga schools are featured in the new book Chattanooga in Old Photos, sponsored by Chattanoogan.com. There are scenes of McCallie School in 1910 as well as the 1927 football squad. The Baylor School quadrangle and campus by the river are also included. Other old photos are of Bright School, the old Chattanooga High, Clifton Hills Elementary, Eastside Elementary, Highland ... (click for more)

Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ALLIGOOD, WILLIAM MICHAEL 1671 JED LANE HIXSON, 37343 Age at Arrest: 29 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County VIOLATION OF PROBATION (AGGRAVATED BURGLARY) --- ALMOND, KORY LANE 1201 REEVES AVE CHATTANOOGA, 37412 Age at Arrest: 23 years old Arresting Agency: FAILURE TO APPEAR --- BANEGAS, ... (click for more)

Opinion

Tom Caldwell Was Always A Champion For Orange Grove

Tom Caldwell was a devoted husband, father of four children and 13 grandchildren, veteran of World War II, Harvard University law school graduate, church member and outstanding corporate, tax and estate planning attorney at three of Chattanooga's leading law firms. His family, personal, legal, military, religious and civic duties are too many to list. As a member of the Chattanooga ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: So Long, 'Mr. Chaudion'

It’s been a couple of years ago, almost three, when I walked into a well-respected horse barn at the foot of Lookout Mountain, not far into Georgia, and caught sight of four black men, silently watching me come. When I got to their midst, I nodded my respect to each of the four, as I was taught from the very start in my life, before I said, “I’d like a word with Mr. Chaudion Womble.” ... (click for more)

Sports

UTC Men Lose In Shootout At Georgia State 95-88

The Chattanooga Mocs got into a shootout tonight in the GSU Sports Arena falling 95-88 at Georgia State. The 183 combined points in regulation are the most in a UTC game since the 125-85 Southern Conference win over The Citadel (210 pts) on Feb. 1, 2016. Five Mocs reach double figures led by David Jean-Baptiste’s career-high-tying 19. Jonathan Scott also set a new high with ... (click for more)

Hurricanes Rally To Beat Previously Unbeaten Mustangs, 63-58, In Overtime

In a District 5-3A basketball slugfest between what may be the two best teams in the league, East Hamilton got the go-ahead points on a steal-and-drive by Darwin Randolph in overtime and the Hurricanes defeated Walker Valley, 63-58, Tuesday night and handed the Mustangs their first loss of the season. “We had to keep playing a smart basketball because Walker Valley is a very ... (click for more)