Judge In Pilot Travel Centers Case Directs Government To List Defendants In Order Of Culpability

Thursday, February 22, 2018

The Chattanooga judge overseeing the Pilot Travel Centers fraud case has directed prosecutors to rank the 17 defendants in order of culpability for purposes of sentencing.

Judge Curtis Collier said he plans to handle the sentencings in groups of three or four.

Authorities said earlier that those who entered guilty pleas were facing up to five years in prison, while those who went to trial faced up to 20 years.

A jury last week found Karen Mann not guilty, but returned single convictions against Heather Jones and former Pilot national sales director Scott Wombold. Former Pilot president Mark Hazelwood was found guilty of three felony counts. He is under home confinement at his Knoxville residence.

Judge Collier said in an order, "The Court intends to conduct the sentencing hearings in groups of three or four Defendants at a time. In order to guide the Court in scheduling the sentencing hearings in an orderly and logical manner, the United States (the “Government”) SHALL file a document listing Defendants in order of the Government’s approximation of their respective culpability within seven days of the issuance of this Order. The Government may include any other information it believes is relevant to scheduling the sentencing hearings. Any Defendant MAY file an optional response within seven days of the Government’s filing.

"The purpose of this Order is solely to facilitate the orderly and just sentencing of the multiple Defendants in this case. The Court does not expect—and will not review—a sentencing memorandum on any Defendant at this time, and no party will be limited to the opinion or position it states in any response to this Order."

The case involves a scheme to defraud trucking companies of promised rebates.

Other defendants to be sentenced are John Freeman, Vicki Borden, John Spiewak, Katy Bibee, Ashley Judd, Arnie Ralenkotter, Jay Stinnett, Holly Radford, Kevin Clark, Michael Scott Fenwick, Janet Welch, Chris Andrews, Brian Mosher and Lexie Holden.

Many of those testified during the lengthy trial at the Federal Courthouse in Chattanooga that began in early November.


Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Grand Jury Indicts 5 Men On Separate Rape, Sexual Abuse Charges

Rossville Man Caught Breaking Into East Ridge Home When Owner Comes Home For Lunch


Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: AYALA, EDWIN SAMUEZ 6202 MELTON DRIVE CHATTANOOGA, 37416 Age at Arrest: 41 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County DRIVING ... (click for more)

The Hamilton County Grand Jury has indicted five men on separate rape and sexual assault cases. Joshua Conrad Smith, 32, of Panavista Lane, was charged with five counts of aggravated statutory ... (click for more)

A 28-year-old Rossville man has been charged with breaking into a house in East Ridge on Sunday. Dustin Scott Sherlin, of 105 Amanda Lane, was charged with aggravated burglary, drug possession, ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: AYALA, EDWIN SAMUEZ 6202 MELTON DRIVE CHATTANOOGA, 37416 Age at Arrest: 41 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County DRIVING ON REVOKED, SUSPENDED OR CANCELLED LICENSE DRIVERS TO EXERCISE DUE CARE REGISTRATION, DRIVING UNREGISTERED VEHICLE FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY --- BALLARD, GALAN GREGORY 1140 ... (click for more)

Grand Jury Indicts 5 Men On Separate Rape, Sexual Abuse Charges

The Hamilton County Grand Jury has indicted five men on separate rape and sexual assault cases. Joshua Conrad Smith, 32, of Panavista Lane, was charged with five counts of aggravated statutory rape. Police said the incidents happened between Feb. 15 and June 1, 2017, and involved two different victims. Their ages were "less than 18 but at least 10." Smith is director of ... (click for more)

Opinion

An Open Letter Concerning The Proposed Ooltewah Waste Treatment Facility - And Response

The Hamilton County Water and Wastewater Treatment Authority and County Commissioner Tim Boyd want to build a sewage treatment plant in my backyard. I bought my house in Ooltewah in 1994, raised my children here and worked hard to pay it off. My home has been my small piece of the American Dream. Now, the WWTA and Commissioner Boyd want to reward my hard work by taking away about ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Loving Hands…

For a great part of my life that I spent with my family at the former Chattanooga News-Free Press, we were in a lockjaw fight with the family who owned the Chattanooga Times. Up until the 1970s the two newspapers existed under the same roof, splitting expenses, but that got sour when the Times had a lot more “expenses” than we were duty-bound to share. So then my grandfather ... (click for more)

Sports

Kurtz, Pippenger Pace Unbeaten Baylor Past Riverdale, 62-41

Riverdale basketball coach Michael Voss has a reason for his scheduling philosophy. “I’m just trying to schedule good teams,” Voss said Monday night after his previously once-beaten Warriors fell to undefeated Baylor, 62-41, on Austin Clark court in Duke Arena. “Baylor is good, East Hamilton is good and McCallie is good, so you know what you’re getting into.” Before Monday, ... (click for more)

Belmont Hands Lady Mocs Sixth Straight Loss

Chattanooga’s Lady Mocs got off to a good start and had a six-point lead after the first quarter, but they couldn’t maintain that level of play and lost for the sixth straight game Monday night at McKenzie Arena. The Belmont Lady Bruins improved to 6-3 with their second straight win as they pulled away in the second half for a comfortable 67-51 victory. Chattanooga is now ... (click for more)