Chattanooga Softball Gets Alabama Regional With Alabama, Stanford, Murray State

Supreme Court Rules Jury Trial Not A Right In All TPPA Claims

Wednesday, August 26, 2015

A plaintiff does not have the right to a jury trial for a claim filed in circuit court under the Tennessee Public Protection Act, according to a Tennessee Supreme Court opinion filed Wednesday. The Court also determined that the Governmental Tort Liability Act does not apply to retaliatory discharge cases filed under the TPPA. 

The case is an appeal by the former city administrator of LaFollette in a lawsuit he filed against the city. David Young sued the city under the TPPA, which protects employees terminated “solely for refusing to participate in, or for refusing to remain silent about, illegal activities.” 

The circuit court judge granted Mr. Young’s request for a jury trial, but permitted the city to appeal his decision on that issue only. The appeal is referred to as an interlocutory appeal, or an appeal of a narrow issue in a pending case. The case was brought to the Court of Appeals, which determined that Mr. Young’s claim, because he was suing a municipality, fell under the Governmental Tort Liability Act and therefore was not entitled to a jury trial. 

Mr. Young then sought permission from the Supreme Court to appeal, which was granted. The Supreme Court first examined whether or not the claim indeed fell under the GTLA, a specific set of laws that controls lawsuits against government entities. While the GLTA provides immunity to the government in most such suits, it also identifies specific instances where claims are permitted. In addition, the legislature has enacted other laws that carve out further exceptions to the sovereign immunity provisions of the GTLA. The Supreme Court ruled that, because of the specialized provisions of the TPPA, the legislature had enacted an entire statutory scheme that substituted for the GTLA in retaliatory discharge claims. 

The Court then went on to determine whether a TPPA claim includes a right to a jury trial in circuit court. The Court explained that the Tennessee Constitution does not guarantee jury trials in all cases and the TPPA, as a remedy created by the legislature, does not specifically grant that right in circuit court. 

The issue is further complicated by the fact that jury trials are provided by statute for TPPA claims filed in chancery court, but no similar statute applies to TPPA claims filed in circuit court, which also has jurisdiction of such claims. 

The case will now return to the trial court for further action on the claims. 

To read the David Young v. City of LaFollette opinion, authored by Justice Cornelia A. Clark, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Driver Services Offers At-Home Knowledge Testing

New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Shaw Announces 2022 Associate Dependent Scholarship Recipients


The Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security's Driver Services division is now offering a new online service, "At-Home Knowledge Testing," for Tennessee teenagers. Teenagers ... (click for more)

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: 2 GIRLS AND A LASER KIMBERLY KOSAL 2130 N FORK DR SODDY DAISY TN 37379 ADH CONSTRUCTION AVERY HALLORAN 8460 JAY TRENT ... (click for more)

Shaw Industries Group, Inc. has announced the recipients of its 2022 Associate Dependent Scholarship. The company is investing in this group as part of its efforts to "create a better future ... (click for more)



Business

Driver Services Offers At-Home Knowledge Testing

The Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security's Driver Services division is now offering a new online service, "At-Home Knowledge Testing," for Tennessee teenagers. Teenagers between the ages of 15 to 17 may now take their written knowledge test online under a proctor's supervision (parent/legal guardian) via the Tennessee Proctor IDentification (PID) app. Those ... (click for more)

New Hamilton County Business Licenses

Here are the new business licenses from the County Clerk's office: 2 GIRLS AND A LASER KIMBERLY KOSAL 2130 N FORK DR SODDY DAISY TN 37379 ADH CONSTRUCTION AVERY HALLORAN 8460 JAY TRENT CT OOLTEWAH TN 37363 ALEX GRAYSON HAIR STYLIST ALEXANDRIA M GRAYSON 5591 HIGHWAY 153 STE 156 CHATTANOOGA TN 37343 ANGIE'S FABRICATIONS ANGELA N SIMS 307 W RIDGEWOOD AVE CHATTANOOGA ... (click for more)

Breaking News

Woman Gets 6-Year Suspended Sentence In 2018 Stabbing Death Of George Deramus

A woman charged in the stabbing death of 60-year-old George Deramus pleaded guilty on Monday morning to the lesser charge of voluntary manslaughter. Tavowia Hinton, who was 49 at the time of the Dec. 2, 2018, incident, had been facing a charge of second-degree murder. She was given a six-year prison sentence, but it was suspended. Ms. Hinton was directed not to have any contact ... (click for more)

Florida Man Says Deal Should Go Through To Buy 6,161 Acres In Hamilton, Sequatchie Counties From Pattens

A Florida man has filed suit in Federal Court, saying he had a deal to buy 6,160 acres in Hamilton and Sequatchie counties from Bryan and Cartter Patten, but they are backing out of the deal. C. Lee Eggert, of Brandon, Fla., said the agreed purchase price was over $11.6 million. He acknowledged that he was being furnished the money by a logging company, Consolidated Timberlands. ... (click for more)

Opinion

Election Integrity

I find the complaints about the recent win by Weston Wamp in the Hamilton County mayor’s primary to be interesting and amusing. Interesting because of the attempt by some to portray his win as the result of some kind of nefarious manipulation by a group of clergy to get Black voters to crossover and vote for Wamp. Also interesting because for weeks it was assumed by the local political ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: "Miss Mary Frances"

I have written dozens of obituaries in my life and eulogized many people. I am not ashamed to admit I think I am good at it and I am flattered when a friend’s family approaches me to ask for my help. I have written a number of obituaries on those who are still alive who want to “proof-read” what will be turned into the funeral home and I have honored death-bed requests that this ... (click for more)