Former Executive Assistant To Pilot Sales Director Recalls Being Interviewed By FBI While Nursing Her Baby On The Front Porch

Monday, November 20, 2017 - by John Wilson

The executive assistant to the vice president of sales at Pilot Flying J told a Chattanooga jury on Monday that she never expected to be interviewed by the FBI on the front porch of her Knoxville home, nursing a one-month-old and with her other two young children running around in the yard.

Katy Bibee, who worked directly for an expected star witness for the prosecution, said she was off on maternity leave at the time of the April 15, 2013, raid at the Haslam-owned company.

She said she talked with two FBI agents for about 45 minutes before her father-in-law showed up and put a stop to it. However, she said she decided that evening to go to Pilot headquarters and give a further statement.

"They told me the others were cooperating and giving statements also," she told the jury at the Federal Courthouse.

Standing trial are former Pilot president Mark Hazelwood, national sales director Scott Wombold and regional sales accountants Karen Mann and Heather Jones.

Ms. Bibee said she was almost a defendant herself, but she agreed to plead guilty just this past July to mail and wire fraud. The mother of children 9, 7 and 4 said she was told she faces up to 20 years in prison.

The witness said she got a job not long out of college as the accountant for John "Stick" Freeman - a key figure in the case also said by one witness to have been close with CEO Jimmy Haslam. She said one in she had with the company was that her husband graduated from high school "with a Haslam daughter." Another was that Jay Stinnett, a regional sales director for Pilot, had coached her husband in football.

She went to work for Pilot when she was 24 - just after getting married and coming back from her honeymoon.

Ms. Bibee said, "I loved the people I worked with. It was very fast-paced and demanding. I thought I was very blessed to have the job."

Asked about Freeman, whose salty language fills a number of transcripts in the case, she said, "I thought he was a character" and a "storyteller."

She added, "He was never anything but kind and good to my family."

She said Freeman was "very high strung. He wanted it done right." 

Of Ms. Mann, she said, "She was just like a mom to me. She is the same age as my mother. She got me through all my pregnancies."

Ms. Bibee, questioned about her going along with trucking customers not getting their promised discounts, said, "It was just understood that we did what we were asked to and as fast as we could."

She said, "There's no reason to lie to the customer. It was one of those things - I was not thinking obviously."

Ms. Bibee, who has also been battling cancer after getting the diagnosis in July 2013, said, "Things felt uncomfortable at times. There were definitely some things I was asked to do that were wrong. But I was not thinking that I had broken the law."

She added, "Looking back, I wish I had said something. But I never asked why. I thought - I work for Pilot. They do everything good for the community."

Prosecutor Trey Hamilton showed Ms. Bibee a Dec. 9, 2008, Freeman email in which he said Pilot was "eliminating discounts within our system. The customer does not need to know the numbers." The plan was to manually send out rebate checks each month to certain less-sophisticated, smaller trucking firms.

Ms. Bibee said a certain discount was promised to BP Express, but a lower figure was paid out. She said many of the smaller firms did not ask for detailed information about the discounts.

By not paying the promised discount, Pilot was making about $4,000 more a month on BP Express, it was stated.

The same trick was pulled on Mike Queen and his Queen Transport, the witness said. She said Mr. Queen called "begging for his extra penny" of discount. She said Freeman told her to tell him that "the extra penny is fine," but Freeman instructed her, "Don't change the deal." 

In another email, Freeman belittled trucking company executive "Little Man" Don Gregory of the Allied firm, saying during his whole visit with him he "kept his head in his Blackberry."  

Ms. Bibee emailed Freeman, "Let's remember that when it's time for his rebate check this month."

Freeman replied, "SMF." She said that stood for "Stupid Mother F-----."

Another regional account executive who has pleaded guilty, Holly Radford, also discussed the situation with Queen Transport. She said Freeman said of Mike Queen, "He's crazy and thinks he's getting a deal. He's not getting what he thinks."

She said Jay Stinnett reminded that all those in on the scheme to pay the lowered amount "need to sing off the same hymnal."

That did not happen later with Mike Queen as a new Pilot salesman blurted that he was suppose to be getting a much higher rate. J.W. Johnson made the admission to Queen after noting that "this guy can talk forever." Johnson afterward reported, "I'm going to hold off in the back track to make up something. Oh, crap."

Ms. Radford was shown another email where Freeman discussed having "wiggle room" and "saying one thing and doing another."

The tactic was used in a big way on Chip Hall and RWH Trucking as Stinnett instructed that the discount be cost plus 20. Ms. Radford said he wrote out TWENTY so it was not misunderstood as cost plus two. The firm had been promised cost plus zero.

The sales staff compiled a chart that showed savings to RWH Trucking, but also had a column for savings to Pilot by cheating the firm. Ms. Radford said it showed "that we should have been sending them $64,521 a month, but we actually were sending $32,540. We saved almost $32,000 a month. That's how much we shorted them."

Shown the "savings" report, office manager Vicki Borden, commented to Freeman and Stinnett, "You are the best."

However, Freeman did have some concern about compiling documents with some possibly incriminating information and sharing it with several staff members.

Stinnett commented about Ms. Radford, "Hell, she does them and she knows."

The witness said one document showed the company cheating another trucking firm out of $115,000 in rebates it had been promised.

Stinnett called it "a good number - a $115,000 screw."

Ms. Radford said she was present at a sales break-out meeting in November 2012 when regional sales director Brian Mosher was describing how to cheat trucking companies. She said Wombold was in the room and "he agreed with the system and what he was trying to teach us."

She said Ms. Jones was there too and commented that "very few trucking companies actually ask for backup - fewer than 10 percent."

 

 

 

 

 

 


Jeff Smith Is Winner Of Zarzour's Drawing For Set Of Chattanooga Photo Books

Latest Bradley County Arrest Report

Judge Collier Keeps Hazelwood Under House Arrest During Appeal Of His Fraud Conviction


Jeff Smith is the winner of a drawing at Zarzour's Restaurant on the Southside for a set of the Chattanooga Photo Books, including the new book Chattanooga in Old Photos, sponsored by Chattanoogan.com. ... (click for more)

Click here for the latest Bradley County arrest report. (click for more)

Judge Curtis Collier has issued an order keeping former Pilot Travel Centers president Mark Hazelwood under home confinement during the appeal of his fraud conviction. Now that the Sixth Circuit ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Jeff Smith Is Winner Of Zarzour's Drawing For Set Of Chattanooga Photo Books

Jeff Smith is the winner of a drawing at Zarzour's Restaurant on the Southside for a set of the Chattanooga Photo Books, including the new book Chattanooga in Old Photos, sponsored by Chattanoogan.com. Mr. Smith, an employee of Tuftco, is one of the Zarzour's regulars. Chattanooga in Old Photos is the fourth book in the collection called the Chattanooga Photo Books. The others ... (click for more)

Latest Bradley County Arrest Report

Click here for the latest Bradley County arrest report. (click for more)

Opinion

Discrimination And Double Taxation For Animal Shelters - And Response

Some Commissioners want Hamilton County to donate $10 million in tax dollars to help the Humane Education Society (HES) build a new facility. The majority of Hamilton County residents (specifically those residing in Chattanooga, East Ridge, Lakesite, Walden, Signal Mountain, Lookout Mountain, Soddy Daisy, and Collegedale) will be prohibited from using HES animal services unless ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Thanksgiving Eve

At some point this spring, as I impatiently awaited the song birds as I do every year, I took a less-traveled path during My Morning Readings and came across a Thanksgiving story that I loved. Trust me, I have been waiting for about six months … yes, impatiently … to share a story that was written seven years ago by J. Allen Wilson. I searched for him yesterday but the closest ... (click for more)

Sports

Garrick Hall Gets 300th Win As Hixson Wrestling Coach

Tuesday, November 20 will be a day coach Garrick Hall remembers for the rest of his life. He took his Hixson wrestling team to Crossville to face teams from Cookeville and Stone Memorial. The Wildcats won both, beating the Cavaliers by a 42-27 final before topping the Panthers by a 52-27 margin, handing Hall his 300 th dual-meet victory in the process. “It took a while, ... (click for more)

Strong Second Half Leads East Hamilton Past Franklin County, 58-40

East Hamilton’s Lady Hurricanes broke away from a 25-all tie at halftime with Franklin County on Tuesday as Madison Hayes scored 13 of her game-high 27 points in the third quarter of a 58-40 non-district victory in Winchester. The Lady Canes (3-0) have won their first three games by an average of 13 points and Hayes has scored 84 points and averaged 28 points in the team’s fast ... (click for more)