Greg Vital Says TVA "Trampling Private Property Rights"; Attorneys Ask Judge Mattice To Set Aside Order Of Possession By TVA For Meigs County Farm

Sunday, December 9, 2018

Attorneys for Greg Vital are asking Federal Judge Sandy Mattice to set aside his earlier order giving TVA right to possess a portion of his Meigs County farm relating to the construction of a high-voltage  power line leading to a new $300 million power control center.

Mr. Vital said, “TVA continues to trample the rights of individual property owners in Georgetown to its advantage, It has chosen to buy some property and condemn others. They are abusing their power of eminent domain.”

The motion by Mr. Vital’s lawyers said that TVA went to court for the order of possession “before Mr. Vital entered the case and had an opportunity to respond, and they are vague, overbroad, and the order seems to grant to the TVA a property right that is more than what the TVA is presently entitled to and is worth more than $1.00.”

The Vital lawyers contend in the motion that the TVA filings are so broad that “TVA’s careless use of power has in this instance resulted - possibly inadvertently - in an actual taking which the TVA’s deposit of $1.00 in nominal compensation is inadequate.” Additionally, the motion says that the case has resulted “in an actual taking that is far more expansive than simply the right to enter onto private land to perform surveying activities.”

The motion says, "Mr. Vital requests that the Court set aside its Order of Possession (Doc. 5) and require the Tennessee Valley Authority to (i) file appropriately-specific documentation to establish a true “temporary” right to enter Mr. Vital’s land, rather than divest him entirely of possession of his property for an indeterminate time and scope, (ii) define the activities the TVA may perform on the property and the times they may perform these activities, and (iii) define the property rights Mr. Vital retains during this “temporary” taking.

"Alternatively, Mr. Vital asks that the Court set aside the Order of Possession due to the TVA’s failure to estimate and deposit just compensation for the actual taking." 

Attorneys for Mr. Vital are Crews Townsend, Roger Dickson and Heith Frost.


Fire Causes Extensive Damage To Loudon County Courthouse

Woman, 41, Shot Early Tuesday Morning On East 23rd Street

Autopsy Says 4-Week-Old Girl Died Of Blunt Force Injuries To Her Head And Chest


A fire caused extensive damage to the Loudon County Courthouse on Tuesday night. A large number of firefighters converged on the scene and roads nearby were closed. Officials said the courthouse, ... (click for more)

A woman, 41, was shot early Tuesday morning on East 23rd Street. At approximately 6:22 a.m., Chattanooga Police responded to the 2000 block of E. 23rd Street on a report of a person who ... (click for more)

An autopsy for a four-week-old Chattanooga girl who died March 4 said she died from blunt force injuries to her head and chest. The report on Olivia Destiny Dunton found bruises on her face ... (click for more)


Breaking News

Fire Causes Extensive Damage To Loudon County Courthouse

A fire caused extensive damage to the Loudon County Courthouse on Tuesday night. A large number of firefighters converged on the scene and roads nearby were closed. Officials said the courthouse, described as one of the oldest in Tennessee may be a total loss. (click for more)

Woman, 41, Shot Early Tuesday Morning On East 23rd Street

A woman, 41, was shot early Tuesday morning on East 23rd Street. At approximately 6:22 a.m., Chattanooga Police responded to the 2000 block of E. 23rd Street on a report of a person who had been shot. Upon arrival, police located the victim who was suffering from a gunshot wound. Hamilton County EMS responded to the scene and transported the woman to a local hospital. ... (click for more)

Opinion

How Can City, WWTA Get Away With Chronic Sewage Discharges Onto Our Streets?

A wastewater or service utility is simply a defined service in exchange for a fee. What if I pay a utility fee in exchange for a defined service, and the utility fails to deliver the service as agreed? As an example, I pay a private solid waste collection service to collect, transport, and dispose of garbage. Municipalities also operate waste collection and disposal. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Just Say ‘I Love You’

A dear friend sends me a note that his mom, after 40 glorious years of teaching children in public schools, is dying. The death of a mom or dad is among the worst things a child must bear, watching a parent in their final days. But I still marvel at the fact when Helen Exum died four years ago, not once did I cry and I’m a pretty emotional guy. The overwhelming reason I could ... (click for more)

Sports

Late-Inning Hero: Bowman Leads McCallie Comeback

Kristopher Bowman has been around organized baseball long enough to know that it’s never too late to overcome a mistake or a bad outing. The slender McCallie senior entered Tuesday’s non-district game at East Hamilton with a 4-0 lead. He’s normally a pretty reliable relief pitcher, but Tuesday wasn’t his day on the hill as he walked all four batters he faced and they all scored. ... (click for more)

Baseball: Soddy-Daisy Rallies With Two Runs In 7th To Sweep Ooltewah, 5-4

(Story will be updated) Soddy-Daisy rallied for two runs in the seventh inning Tuesday and completed a two-game sweep of Ooltewah with a 5-4 victory in District 5-3A baseball action at Tom Higgins Field. The Trojans, trailing 4-3, started the game-winning rally when Jacob Jennings reached on a hard ground ball at Ooltewah reliever Jacob Robinson, who recorded three strikeouts ... (click for more)